How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
If you want a wired, officially licensed Xbox One gaming headset with a boom mic and in-line controls, choose PDP Xbox One Afterglow; if you need a wireless Bluetooth earpiece for hands-free calls and all-day battery, choose Marnana Headset.
• PDP Xbox One Afterglow — biggest strength: Officially licensed by Microsoft for Xbox One, with 40mm stereo drivers, a flexible noise-cancelling boom mic, and easy in-line volume and mute controls. Bigger drivers than a standard chat headset means fuller game audio.
• PDP Xbox One Afterglow — biggest trade-off: It's wired (3.5mm) and built for Xbox One controllers with a 3.5mm port — first-gen controllers need a separate headset adapter. It's a gaming-first tool, not a phone headset.
• Marnana Headset — biggest strength: True wireless freedom via Bluetooth with up to 18 hours of music time, 19 hours of talk time, and 14 days of standby, plus multi-point pairing for two devices at once.
• Marnana Headset — biggest trade-off: It's a single-ear in-ear earpiece — no stereo, no boom mic, no wired 3.5mm connection, and a 33 ft wireless range you have to stay inside.
• Who each is for: PDP Xbox One Afterglow is for console gamers who want immersive stereo and clear party chat; Marnana Headset is for drivers, office workers, and anyone taking hands-free calls on a phone.
The Afterglow LVL 3 is a step up from the basic mono chat headset that ships with an Xbox One. Its 40mm drivers are 50% larger than those in a typical chat headset, so you get a real stereo spread of game audio rather than a thin single-channel voice feed. That matters in shooters and racing games where directional cues and a bit of low-end punch help you react. The frequency range runs the full 20 Hz to 20,000 Hz, so it covers everything from rumble to high-frequency detail.
Chat is the other half of the story. PDP fitted a flexible, noise-cancelling boom mic so you can position it right at your mouth, and the in-line controls put volume and mic muting within thumb's reach without pausing the game. The breathable leatherette cushions and on-ear/over-ear design are made to stay comfortable through long sessions, and the ear cups lay flat for storage and travel. It's also officially licensed by Microsoft — a meaningful signal for anyone who wants a headset that's actually built for the console.
Here's where buyers should pause. This is a wired 3.5mm headset designed for second-generation Xbox One wireless controllers with a 3.5mm port. If you're on a first-generation controller, you'll need a separate headset adapter. It also won't do double duty as a phone or PC headset in the way a wireless earpiece will, and the 100g weight with over-ear cups is a very different feel from an ultralight earbud. If you want wireless freedom or take a lot of calls off-console, this isn't your pick.
The Marnana Headset is a completely different animal: a single-ear Bluetooth earpiece for hands-free calling and casual listening. Its headline number is battery life — up to 18 hours of music, 19 hours of talk time, and 14 days of standby from one charge, recharged in about 2 hours over Micro-USB. For a truck driver, delivery worker, or anyone on calls all day, that's the whole point: you charge it overnight and forget about it.
Connectivity is the second strength. The Bluetooth 4.0 radio reaches up to 33 ft / 10 meters, and multi-point technology lets it stay paired to two Bluetooth devices at once — say a work phone and a personal phone, or a phone and a tablet. The CSR chip is there to make pairing quick. It works with iOS and Android across iPhone, iPad, Samsung, Sony, Motorola, LG, HTC, Nexus, and more, so you're not locked to one ecosystem.
Comfort and fit are handled with a lightweight build — just 9.93 g / 0.35 oz — plus a soft earbud and a 360° rotatable, retractable ear hook, with ear hooks and wingtips included in the box to dial in a secure fit. The kit also bundles a Micro-USB cable, a carrying case, and a user manual, backed by an 18-month warranty.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for Xbox One gaming → PDP Xbox One Afterglow. Officially licensed, console-tuned, stereo.
• Best for immersive stereo audio → PDP Xbox One Afterglow. 40mm drivers, 50% larger than a standard chat headset.
• Best for hands-free calls and all-day battery → Marnana Headset. Up to 19 hours of talk time and 14 days standby.
• Best for wireless freedom → Marnana Headset. Bluetooth 4.0, up to 33 ft range, no cable to snag.
• Best for multi-device users → Marnana Headset. Multi-point pairing keeps two Bluetooth devices connected at once.
• Best for positioning a mic at your mouth → PDP Xbox One Afterglow. Flexible boom mic with in-line mute.
• Best for travel and portability → Marnana Headset. Under 10 g, with a carrying case in the box.
• Best for controller comfort over long sessions → PDP Xbox One Afterglow. Breathable leatherette cushions and lay-flat ear cups.
In my opinion, the right call is almost entirely about where you'll use it. If your setup is an Xbox One with a second-gen controller, I'd buy the PDP Xbox One Afterglow — it's the only one of the two built for that job, and the stereo drivers plus flexible boom mic make it a genuine upgrade over the stock chat headset. If you mainly take calls on the go, drive for a living, or want one earpiece to pair with your phone and tablet, I'd buy the Marnana Headset instead; its battery life and multi-point Bluetooth are the reasons. Since both are long-term purchases, check the current price on Amazon before you commit and confirm your controller has a 3.5mm port if you go PDD.
FAQ
It's not built for it. The Marnana is a Bluetooth earpiece for phones and tablets; it has no 3.5mm jack and no Xbox integration, so it's a poor fit for console gaming.
The Marnana Headset, by a wide margin. It delivers up to 18 hours of music, 19 hours of talk time, and 14 days of standby. The PDP Afterglow is wired and draws no battery at all — it just needs a 3.5mm connection.
The Marnana Headset. Its Bluetooth pairing, multi-point support, 33 ft range, and noise-cancelling mic are all aimed at hands-free calling — something the wired, console-focused PDP simply isn't designed to do.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.