How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
If you want a drop-in replacement boom mic for a Razer Barracuda X headset with a flexible, stable arm and an extra foam cover, choose PDEEY Barracuda X Mic; if you need a compatible boom for a SteelSeries Arctis 1 with a gold-plated 3.5 mm jack and a 2-year manufacturer warranty, choose NewTH Replacement Game Mic. These are two different mics for two different headsets, so compatibility decides almost everything here.
• PDEEY Barracuda X Mic — biggest strength: Purpose-built as a replacement boom for the Razer Barracuda X, with an omnidirectional condenser capsule, a flexible-but-sturdy boom and an extra foam cover included.
• PDEEY Barracuda X Mic — biggest trade-off: It is tied to one headset family, so if you own an Arctis 1 it will not fit; also, it is a 3.5 mm corded mic with no battery and no active noise cancellation.
• NewTH Replacement Game Mic — biggest strength: Built specifically for the SteelSeries Arctis 1, with a 360-degree bendable neck, a gold-plated copper 3.5 mm jack, a stated 6.5-inch cable and a 2-year manufacturer warranty.
• NewTH Replacement Game Mic — biggest trade-off: It only works with Arctis 1 headsets, so Razer owners should look elsewhere; the weight is just 15 g and the housing is plain plastic.
• Who PDEEY is for: Razer Barracuda X owners who lost or broke the original mic and want a plug-and-play stand-in.
• Who NewTH is for: SteelSeries Arctis 1 owners who want a cheap, warranty-backed replacement boom with a bendable neck.
The PDEEY Barracuda X Mic is a single-purpose part. It exists to replace the detachable boom on a Razer Barracuda X wireless gaming headset. That is the whole pitch, and honestly it is a good one: the original boom on a headset is the first thing to fail or vanish, and a lot of people end up buying a whole new headset when only the mic is gone. This one is designed to slot in and get you back to voice chat.
What you get in the spec sheet is straightforward. The capsule is omnidirectional condenser, which is the standard design for a headset boom — it picks up your voice from any angle in front of it rather than demanding you talk straight into the tip. The boom itself is described as flexible but sturdy, so you can bend it toward your mouth and it should hold that position instead of drooping mid-match. There is an extra foam cover in the box, which matters more than people think: foam cuts breath pops and wind noise, and having a spare means you are not hunting for a replacement pop filter later. The enclosure is polycarbonate, a tough plastic that keeps the arm light, and the connector is a plain 3.5 mm jack. Plug and play, no drivers, no battery — it draws nothing because it is a corded part.
Compatibility is where you need to be careful. The listing ties this mic to the Razer Barracuda X and lists PC, Xbox One, PS5, PS4, PS3 and Xbox as the platforms that headset is used with. That is the headset's compatibility, not the mic's. The mic fits the headset. So buy this if you own a Barracuda X and the boom is broken, lost, or crackling.
Skip it if you own a SteelSeries Arctis 1, or any other brand. Also skip it if you are hoping for active noise cancellation or a battery — there is none, and there is no reason for one on a passive boom. And if you want the absolute cheapest possible part regardless of fit, this one is not aimed at you; it is aimed at people who need the right part. Check the current price on Amazon before you commit.
The NewTH Replacement Game Mic is the mirror image of the PDEEY. It is made for one headset too, and that headset is the SteelSeries Arctis 1. NewTH is blunt about it: the mic will only work for Arctis 1 headsets. That is not marketing hedging, it is a real constraint, and you should take it seriously before ordering.
Where the NewTH earns its keep is in the details. The boom bends a full 360 degrees and is designed to stay where you put it, so you can swing it up out of the way when you are not talking and pull it back down when you are. The neck is soft, the head is ABS plastic, and the connector is a gold-plated copper 3.5 mm jack — gold plating is there to resist corrosion over time, which is a genuine plus on a part that gets plugged and unplugged and sweated on for years. The cable is stated at 6.5 inches, which is roughly the right length to reach your mouth without a loop of slack dangling off your jaw. The mic ships with a foam cover, and the foam is described as dust-resistant and tuned to hold audio quality while cutting unwanted background noise.
There is also a stated 2-year manufacturer warranty. That is unusually generous for a small replacement part and it is the single most reassuring line in the spec sheet. NewTH also says every mic is individually tested before shipping, which is the kind of claim you cannot verify, but the warranty is the thing that actually protects you.
Buy it if you own an Arctis 1 and want a bendable, warranty-backed boom with a proper pop filter. Skip it if you own a Razer, a HyperX, a Corsair, or anything else — it will not fit. Also note the noise control listed is active noise cancellation, but do not read that as a full ANC headset experience; it describes the mic's noise handling, and the mic has no battery of its own. For a passive 3.5 mm boom, expect it to reduce background noise, not erase a room full of people.
• Own a Razer Barracuda X → PDEEY Barracuda X Mic. It is built for that headset and nothing else.
• Own a SteelSeries Arctis 1 → NewTH Replacement Game Mic. Same logic in reverse; the fit is the whole point.
• Want a spare foam cover included → either one. Both ship with foam, and both treat the cover as a real part rather than an afterthought.
• Want a boom that swings fully out of the way → NewTH. Its 360-degree bendable neck is spelled out in the specs; the PDEEY is described as flexible but sturdy, which reads more like "set and leave it."
• Want corrosion-resistant contacts → NewTH. The gold-plated copper 3.5 mm jack is a stated feature. PDEEY does not list plating.
• Want the lightest possible arm → PDEEY. Polycarbonate construction and a lightweight design are both called out. NewTH's mic weighs 15 g, which is light, but the material listed is plain plastic.
• Want warranty coverage → NewTH. A stated 2-year manufacturer warranty is the strongest after-sale protection between the two.
• Want the simplest possible install on a supported headset → both. Neither needs drivers or batteries; both are plug and play.
In my opinion, the deciding factor is the headset you already own, not the mic. If you have a Razer Barracuda X, I would buy the PDEEY Barracuda X Mic — it is the part designed for your headset, and the flexible polycarbonate boom with an extra foam cover is exactly what a broken-boom fix should be. If you have a SteelSeries Arctis 1, I would buy the NewTH Replacement Game Mic, mainly for the 360-degree bendable neck, the gold-plated jack and that 2-year warranty. There is no universal winner here, and anyone telling you otherwise has not checked which headset is sitting on your desk.
FAQ
No. NewTH states the mic only works with SteelSeries Arctis 1 headsets. If you own anything else, the PDEEY or a different model made for your headset is the better route.
Neither. Both are passive 3.5 mm boom mics — plug and play, no battery, no app. PDEEY lists a corded electric power source, and NewTH explicitly says no driver and no batteries required.
Not automatically. Its noise control is listed as active noise cancellation, but on a passive 3.5 mm boom you should expect reduced background noise rather than silence. The PDEEY uses an omnidirectional condenser capsule without a noise-cancelling claim. Pick based on fit and warranty first, then features. And since neither listing shows a price here, check the current price on Amazon before you decide.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.