How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-25 · 6 min read · Independent comparison
• P&P CHEF 7.5 — biggest strength: pure stainless steel with solid seamless welding, a 1-inch elevation for airflow, and a two-pack so you always have a spare. Biggest trade-off: it is a general-purpose round rack, not a fitted replacement part, so it sits loosely in most baskets and does nothing to upgrade a worn-out crisper plate.
• GCQ Air Fryer Pan — biggest strength: a 13 x 13 inch crisper plate sized for Ninja Foodi SP100, SP101, SP1001C and SP201 ovens, with a non-stick surface and a dedicated airflow design. Biggest trade-off: it only fits those specific ovens — buy it for anything else and you own a very large paperweight.
• Who each is for: P&P CHEF 7.5 suits anyone who wants one cheap, durable rack that works across an air fryer, stockpot, pressure cooker and canning pot. GCQ Air Fryer Pan suits a Ninja Foodi SP-series owner who needs to replace or add a crisper plate.
The P&P CHEF 7.5 is a round stainless-steel rack, 7.5 inches across and 1 inch tall, sold as a two-pack. That 1-inch lift is the whole point: it raises food off the pot or basket floor so hot air can move underneath and around it. For air fryer steak, that means the underside of the meat is not sitting in its own juices — air circulates, and you get a more even cook instead of a steamed bottom and a browned top.
Build quality is where this rack earns its place. The wires are solidly welded with no loose joints, so the rack resists warping and does not shed wires into your food. The surface is mirror-finished, which keeps it less sticky and easy to rinse. It is dishwasher safe, though hand washing in warm soapy water is just as quick. The edge is polished smooth with no rough spots, which matters more than people expect — a bare wire end on a rack is a genuine hand injury waiting to happen, and this one avoids it.
Who should buy it: anyone who wants one small, honest tool that does several jobs. Use it to steam eggs, cool cookies, roast a chicken, drain oil, or keep a hot pot off your tabletop. Two racks mean you can use one while the other is in the wash. Who should skip it: anyone whose actual problem is a cracked, warped or missing crisper plate in a Ninja Foodi oven. This rack will not bolt into that slot, and it will not restore the fitted airflow path the oven was designed around.
The GCQ Air Fryer Pan is a purpose-built replacement part, and it should be judged as one. It is a 13 x 13 inch stainless-steel crisper plate designed for Ninja Foodi SP100, SP101, SP1001C and SP201 air fry ovens. The plate is food-grade steel with a non-stick coating, dishwasher safe, and built around an airflow pattern meant to push heat under and around food rather than letting it sit flat.
That design is exactly what air fryer steak wants. A steak on a perforated, elevated plate gets contact with moving hot air on both faces, which is how you build a browned crust without flipping it into a puddle of fat. The same plate handles vegetables, fish, chicken wings, fries, pizza and dehydrated fruit — it is a general cooking surface for that oven, not a one-trick accessory.
Who should buy it: Ninja Foodi SP-series owners whose original plate is scratched, warped, lost or simply worn out, and who want a spare so dinner is not derailed mid-week. Who should skip it: everyone else. If your air fryer is a basket model, a different brand, or a different Ninja line, this plate will not fit. GCQ says it plainly in the product notes — measure your existing grill plate before ordering. Take that seriously. It is a 13-inch part with a fixed footprint and no adjustment.
One care note worth repeating: the coating is non-stick, so keep abrasive scrubbers and metal scouring pads away from it. A soft sponge or the dishwasher preserves the surface; steel wool destroys it.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for air fryer steak in a Ninja Foodi SP-series oven → GCQ Air Fryer Pan. It is the fitted plate that oven was designed to use.
• Best for a worn-out or missing crisper plate → GCQ Air Fryer Pan. P&P CHEF cannot replace a part it was never shaped for.
• Best for multi-purpose kitchen use → P&P CHEF 7.5. Steaming, cooling, roasting, oil draining and trivet duty all in one small tool.
• Best for fit-and-forget cooking → GCQ Air Fryer Pan. No wobbling, no guessing where the rack sits.
• Best for buyers who want a spare on hand → P&P CHEF 7.5. It is sold as a two-pack; the GCQ plate is a single part.
• Best for cleanup convenience → a tie. Both are dishwasher safe, though the GCQ plate's coating needs gentler handling.
• Best for anyone unsure of their oven model → P&P CHEF 7.5. A round rack has no model lock-in.
In my opinion, most people shopping this comparison should buy the P&P CHEF 7.5. It is the more flexible tool: it works in an air fryer, a stockpot, a pressure cooker and a canning pot, it comes as a pair, and it does not care what brand of appliance you own. Its only real limitation is that it is a rack, not a fitted part.
I would buy the GCQ Air Fryer Pan only if I owned a Ninja Foodi SP100, SP101, SP1001C or SP201 and my crisper plate was damaged or gone. In that one situation it is the correct purchase, because a general rack cannot do a fitted plate's job.
FAQ
how to air fryer steak
Pat the steak dry, season it, and set it on a rack or crisper plate so hot air reaches both sides — that is the entire advantage of the P&P CHEF 7.5's 1-inch lift or the GCQ plate's airflow pattern. Cook at high heat, then rest the meat before slicing.
how to air fryer steak medium rare
how to air fryer steak well done
Use a slightly lower temperature for a longer time so the outside does not scorch before the middle cooks through. Elevating the meat on the P&P CHEF 7.5 or the GCQ Air Fryer Pan keeps the bottom from stewing in drippings. Rest it, then slice against the grain.
how to air fryer steak bites
Cut the steak into even cubes, toss with oil and seasoning, and spread them in a single layer on the rack or plate — crowding steams them instead of browning them. Shake or turn them partway through. The GCQ plate's larger 13-inch surface suits bigger batches; the P&P CHEF 7.5 suits smaller ones.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: waykea 9 vs Yunlnny 2: Air Fryer Pizza Pan, Sunenlyst 3PCS vs P&P CHEF Air Fryer Grill: Air Fryer Bacon, INFRAOVENS Air Fryer Rack vs GCQ Air Fryer Replacement