Early Versions
[Demo, 2000]
Jason Robert Brown, Andréa Burns, Lauren Kennedy, Jessica Molaskey
Format: Tracked, mp3.
[Northlight Theatre | North Shore Center for the Performing Arts in Skokie, IL, 6-23-01]
Lauren Kennedy (Cathy), Norbert Leo Butz (Jamie)
Format: Tracked, mp3.
London
[Menier Chocolate Factory in London, 8-10-06]
Lara Pulver (Cathy), Damian Humbley (Jamie)
Format: Tracked, m4a.
Off-Broadway - 1st Revival
[Off-Broadway | Second Stage Theater | Tony Kiser Theater in New York, 3-10-13m] - My master
Betsy Wolfe (Cathy), Adam Kantor (Jamie)
Format: Tracked, mp3.
[Off-Broadway | Second Stage Theater | Tony Kiser Theater in New York, 5-18-13e]
Betsy Wolfe (Cathy), Adam Kantor (Jamie)
Notes: Final Off-Broadway revival performance.
Format: Tracked, mp3.
London - 1st Revival
[Greenwich Theatre in London, 5-17-14]
Danielle Hope (Cathy), Jon Robyns (Jamie)
Format: Tracked, m4a.
London - 2nd Revival
[Preview at St. James Theatre in London, 10-28-16]
Samantha Barks (Cathy), Jonathan Bailey (Jamie)
Notes: First performance. Includes opening speech by composer/lyricist Jason Robert Brown (who directed this production) explaining that there may be some technical difficulties. There ended up being a few little mishaps here and there, but nothing that interrupted the show.
Format: Tracked, mp3.
[St. James Theatre in London, 11-28-16]
Samantha Barks (Cathy), Samuel Thomas (u/s Jamie)
Notes: Samuel's first as Jamie.
Format: Tracked, mp3.
Broadway
[Broadway | Hudson Theatre in New York, 5-31-25m] - boqthemunchkin's master
Adrienne Warren (Cathy), Nick Jonas (Jamie)
Format: Untracked, m4a.
[Broadway | Hudson Theatre in New York, 6-15-25e] - smokeline's master
Nasia Thomas (s/b Cathy), Noah Kieserman (s/b Jamie)
Notes: Noah's first as Jamie. Added standby performance for Nasia and Noah.
Format: Tracked, mp3.
Other
[Philadelphia Theatre Company | Plays and Players Theatre in Philadelphia, PA, 3-21-03]
Nicole Van Giesen (Cathy), Wayne Wilcox (Jamie)
Format: Tracked but unlabeled, wma.
[George Street Playhouse in New Brunswick, NJ, 4-21-05]
Sarah Litzsinger (Cathy), Colin Hanlon (Jamie)
Format: Tracked, mp3.
[Freud Playhouse at the Center for the Art of Performance in Los Angeles, CA, 1-30-06]
Julia Murney (Cathy), Jason Robert Brown (Jamie)
Notes: One-night-only staging as part of Reprise Theatre Company's Broadway's Best Marvelous Musical Mondays series. This version is missing some of the songs and only has 13 tracks.
Format: Tracked, mp3.
[Theatre Aspen | Preview at Hurst Theatre in Aspen, CO, 8-7-07]
Paige Price (Cathy), Hadley Fraser (Jamie)
Notes: First performance.
Format: Tracked, mp3.
[Preview at Hudson Backstage Theatre in Los Angeles, CA, 8-1-08] - juniper47's master
Morgan Weitz (Cathy), Jon Paul Burkhart (Jamie)
Notes: First performance.
Format: Tracked, mp3.
[Berkshire Theatre Group | Fitzpatrick Main Stage in Stockbridge, MA, 6-22-10] - juniper47's master
Julie Reiber (Cathy), Paul Anthony Stewart (Jamie)
Notes: First performance.
Format: Tracked, mp3.
[Virginia Stage Company | Wells Theatre in Norfolk, VA, 3-16-11]
Summer Broyhill (Cathy), Colin Israel (Jamie)
Format: Untracked, m4a.
[The Reginald Theatre at the Seymour Centre in Sydney, Australia, 7-30-11]
Marika Aubrey (Cathy), Rob Mills (Jamie)
Notes: Final performance.
Format: Untracked, wma.
[Concert | Virginia Wimberly Theatre at the Calderwood Pavilion at the Boston Center of the Arts in Boston, MA, 11-23-13]
Betsy Wolfe (Cathy), Adam Kantor (Jamie)
Format: Tracked, mp3.
[Long Wharf Theatre in New Haven, CT, 5-27-14] - euphorianger's master
Katie Rose Clarke (Cathy), Adam Halpin (Jamie)
Format: Tracked, mp3.
[Pamela Brown Auditorium at the Actors Theatre of Louisville in Louisville, KY, 10-11-14e]
Autumn Hurlbert (Cathy), Jed Resnick (Jamie)
Format: Tracked, m4a.
[Judy Bayley Theatre in Las Vegas, NV, 11-7-14]
Betsy Wolfe (Cathy), Adam Kantor (Jamie)
Format: Tracked, m4a.
[Lyric Theatre in Belfast, Northern Ireland, 7-4-15e]
Amy Lennox (Cathy), Fra Fee (Jamie)
Notes: Final performance.
Format: Untracked, mp3.
[American Conservatory Theater | Geary Theater in San Francisco, CA, 5-24-16]
Margo Seibert (Cathy), Zak Resnick (Jamie)
Format: Tracked, mp3.
[Benefit concert | Town Hall in New York, 9-12-16]
Cynthia Erivo (Cathy), Joshua Henry (Jamie)
Notes: This concert supported the Brady Campaign to Prevent Gun Violence.
Format: Tracked, mp3.
[La Mirada Theatre for the Performing Arts in La Mirada, CA, 1-25-17]
Natalie Storrs (Cathy), Devin Archer (Jamie)
Format: Untracked, mp3.
[Concert | Second Stage Theater’s Tony Kiser Theater in New York, 3-4-19]
Shoshana Bean (Cathy), Jason Robert Brown (Jamie)
Notes: A one-night performance as part of Second Stage's Musical Mondays series.
Format: Untracked, m4a.