How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-24 · 7 min read · Independent comparison
• OPENICE Air Fryer Basket — Biggest strength: a genuinely large 15.3 x 11.0 inch stainless steel basket-and-tray set that fits a family-sized batch and catches drips underneath. Biggest trade-off: it only works if your oven has room for those dimensions, and it does nothing to tell you how long to cook anything.
• Empowered Cooks Cathy Yoder's Air — Biggest strength: an 8 x 10 inch magnetic cheat sheet covering cook times, temperatures and internal food temps for 80+ foods. Biggest trade-off: it's a reference chart, not cookware — it does nothing on its own.
• Who OPENICE is for: anyone who wants the physical hardware to air-fry, bake, roast or cook en papillote in a regular oven, in larger quantities.
• Who Empowered Cooks is for: anyone who already owns an air fryer and keeps guessing at times and temperatures.
• In my opinion: these are two different categories of product. One is the tool, the other is the instruction manual your air fryer never shipped with.
The OPENICE set is, at its core, a stainless steel mesh basket paired with a solid tray, plus 30 pre-cut parchment papers in the box. The headline number is the size: 15.3 by 11.0 inches across, with an overall height around 2.2 inches. That's the kind of footprint that makes a real difference when you're cooking for four or more people, because you're not stacking food in two or three cramped rounds. You lay it out, it fits, and dinner happens once.
The design logic is straightforward and it's the part I actually like. The mesh basket promotes 360-degree air circulation, which is what gives you crisping without standing over the oven flipping every piece. Because the surface is non-stick, you don't need to add butter or oil, and the tray underneath does double duty: it catches oil and fat dripping off the food, and it catches crumbs so your oven doesn't end up a mess. That second job is the one people underestimate. A lot of air fryer accessories leave you scrubbing the oven floor afterward.
It's also dishwasher-safe, and the included parchment papers mean some meals need no cleanup at all. Beyond air frying, the same set handles baking, roasting, and cooking en papillote — french fries, hash browns, roasted vegetables, steaks. It's a multi-purpose oven insert, not a single-trick gadget.
Empowered Cooks Cathy Yoder's Air: Who It's For
Empowered Cooks Cathy Yoder's Air is a completely different kind of product, and it's worth being blunt about that. It's a magnetic cheat sheet — an 8 by 10 inch black magnet that sticks to your fridge or to the air fryer itself — and it exists to answer one question fast: how long, and how hot?
It covers 80+ everyday foods with cook times, temperatures, and internal food temperatures. That last part matters more than it sounds. Internal temps are the food-safety piece — the difference between chicken that's actually done and chicken that just looks done. Having that on the same chart as the cook time means a beginner can work from one reference instead of juggling a phone, a recipe, and a thermometer app.
The magnet format is the whole point. Mid-cook, your hands are messy, your phone is across the room, and unlocking it with greasy fingers is exactly the annoyance this solves. It sticks where you're standing. The layout is deliberately large and uncluttered so you can read it at a glance. The guide is organized by category — meats, frozen foods, vegetables, snacks — which is how people actually cook on a weeknight.
Two honest caveats. First, this is a cook-times guide, not a recipe book; if you want ingredient lists and technique, this isn't it. Second, it's designed to work with most air fryers, which means it's a general reference, not a calibration for your specific model — your particular machine may run a little hotter or cooler, so treat the numbers as a strong starting point and adjust.
Who should buy it: air fryer owners who are tired of burnt edges and raw centers, beginners who want food-safety temps right there in front of them, and anyone who cooks the same 20 meals on rotation and wants faster answers. Who should skip it: anyone who doesn't own an air fryer, anyone who already knows their times cold, and anyone expecting recipes rather than a reference chart.
• Best for cooking large batches at once → OPENICE Air Fryer Basket. The 15.3 x 11.0 inch size is built for family portions and entertaining.
• Best for knowing how long to cook something → Empowered Cooks Cathy Yoder's Air. 80+ foods with times, temperatures and internal temps.
• Best for less oil and healthier cooking → OPENICE Air Fryer Basket. The non-stick mesh surface and drip tray let fat drain away instead of sitting in the food.
• Best for food safety confidence → Empowered Cooks Cathy Yoder's Air. Built-in internal food temperatures take the guesswork out of doneness.
• Best for easy cleanup → OPENICE Air Fryer Basket. Dishwasher-safe stainless steel plus 30 included parchment papers, with the tray catching grease and crumbs.
• Best for hands-free convenience while cooking → Empowered Cooks Cathy Yoder's Air. It sticks to the fridge or air fryer so you're not unlocking a phone with messy hands.
• Best for someone who owns no air fryer at all → OPENICE Air Fryer Basket. It works in a conventional oven, so it needs no countertop appliance.
• Best for gifting an air fryer owner → Empowered Cooks Cathy Yoder's Air. It's a low-commitment accessory for a device they already have.
Notice that almost none of these overlap. That's the real story here: you're not choosing between two versions of the same thing. You're choosing between the cooking vessel and the cooking knowledge. If you own an oven and want to air-fry in it, OPENICE is your answer. If you own an air fryer and keep guessing, the cheat sheet is your answer. Plenty of people would sensibly want both — one to cook the food, one to tell them when it's done.
If you put me on the spot, I'd buy the OPENICE Air Fryer Basket, and the reason is scope. It's the product that actually does something: it air-fries, bakes, roasts and steams en papillote, it holds a family-sized batch, it drains fat away, and it cleans up in the dishwasher. The Empowered Cooks cheat sheet is genuinely useful, but it only helps someone who already has an air fryer and only until they've memorized their regular meals. That said, if you already own an air fryer and your problem is undercooked chicken rather than cookware, the magnet is the smarter buy. Check the current price on Amazon before you commit to either — and measure your oven first if you go with OPENICE.
FAQ
It's designed to work with most air fryers, and it's a magnetic chart rather than an electronic device, so there's nothing to pair or plug in. Just treat the times as a good starting point and adjust for your own machine.
They're different categories, so compare them against what you're missing. If you lack the hardware, OPENICE gives you a full stainless steel basket, tray and 30 parchment papers. If you already have an air fryer and keep guessing at times, the cheat sheet solves your actual problem for far less. Check current pricing on Amazon for both.
Yes, and that's arguably the ideal setup. The cheat sheet gives you times and internal temperatures, and the OPENICE basket gives you the large, dishwasher-safe vessel to cook in. They complement each other rather than compete.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: BOXOB Air Fryer Magnetic vs Empowered Cooks Cathy Yoder's Air, OPENICE Air Fryer Basket vs Leonyo 11.8x9IN: Air Fryer Fried, OPENICE Air Fryer Basket vs GWYSY Air fryer Accessories