How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-24 · 7 min read · Independent comparison
• OPENICE Air Fryer Basket — biggest strength: A big 15.3 x 11.0 inch stainless steel basket plus a drip tray, so you can cook a full family-sized batch at once and let the tray catch the grease and crumbs.
• OPENICE Air Fryer Basket — biggest trade-off: It's an oven accessory, not a countertop air fryer insert. If you own a small basket-style air fryer rather than a full oven, it simply won't fit.
• GWYSY Air fryer Accessories — biggest strength: It's a complete 5-quart kit — grill plate, four fiberglass liners, rubber bumpers and a cleaning cloth — sized to drop straight into a Ninja AF141 or AF142 basket.
• GWYSY Air fryer Accessories — biggest trade-off: The 8.5 x 8.5 inch plate is sized for a specific family of air fryers. On anything much bigger or smaller it either rattles around or doesn't seat properly.
• Who each pick is for: OPENICE for oven owners who cook in volume; GWYSY for Ninja 5-quart owners who want to keep their existing basket cleaner and more versatile.
This one is built around size. At 15.3 x 11.0 inches, the basket is genuinely large — the kind of footprint that changes how you cook. Instead of running three rounds of fries to feed four people, you load it once. If you've ever stood over a cramped air fryer basket rotating chicken wings in shifts, that number is the entire pitch.
The design itself is a mesh basket sitting over a solid tray. The mesh is what allows 360-degree air circulation, which is why OPENICE says you don't need to flip your food — hot air moves around it from all sides rather than just blasting the top. The tray underneath does the unglamorous but important work: it catches oil, fat and crumbs so your oven doesn't end up coated in grease. The non-stick surface means you're not adding butter or oil just to stop things sticking, and any fat that renders out drips away instead of pooling around the food. That's the "less oil" claim, and mechanically it holds up.
Buy it if you're cooking for a family or entertaining, you want one big batch instead of several small ones, and you're working with a full oven rather than a countertop air fryer. Skip it if you own a small basket-style air fryer, or if you mostly cook single portions — this thing is deliberately oversized, and that's a downside in a small kitchen with a small oven.
GWYSY Air fryer Accessories: Who It's For
GWYSY takes the opposite approach. Instead of a big new vessel, this is a kit that upgrades the basket you already own. The centerpiece is an 8.5 x 8.5 inch non-stick grill plate with a handle, tailored to the Ninja AF141 Air Fryer Pro 4-in-1 and AF142 Air Fry Max 5-in-1 5-quart models, plus other air fryers that use an 8.5 x 8.5 inch crisper plate.
The handle is the detail I like most here. Air fryer baskets get hot, and pulling a bare plate out with tongs is exactly the kind of thing that ends with a burn. A built-in handle means you lift the whole plate out cleanly. The coating is an enameled, double-layer non-stick finish — GWYSY notes it's dishwasher safe but warns against abrasive cloths or metal scouring balls, which is standard advice for any coated surface and worth following if you want it to last.
The four fiberglass liners measure 8.27 inches and are designed to sit securely in place during cooking, so they don't curl up and get blown around by the fan. The plate is aluminium with a ceramic non-stick inner material, and GWYSY states the materials are food grade, BPA-free, non-toxic and tasteless, meeting FDA standards. The kit also includes seven rubber bumpers — handy for stopping the plate from sliding or rattling — and a magic cleaning cloth. Recommended uses cover baking, grilling and roasting: pizza, fries, steak, wings, vegetables.
Buy it if you own a Ninja 5-quart air fryer and want a crisper plate that lifts out easily, plus liners that keep the basket itself clean. Skip it if your air fryer uses a different basket size — this kit is genuinely size-specific, and that's its main limitation.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for cooking large batches → OPENICE Air Fryer Basket. 15.3 x 11.0 inches versus an 8.5 x 8.5 inch plate is not a close call on capacity.
• Best for oven cooking → OPENICE. It's a basket-and-tray system designed to sit in an oven, with the tray catching drips.
• Best for keeping your existing air fryer clean → GWYSY. The fiberglass liners and grill plate mean food rarely touches the basket itself.
• Best for less oil without flipping → OPENICE. The mesh basket promotes 360-degree air circulation, so you're not turning food halfway through.
• Best all-in-one starter kit → GWYSY. Plate, four liners, seven bumpers and a cleaning cloth in one package is a lot of small annoyances solved at once.
• Best for dishwasher cleanup in both cases. Both sets are dishwasher safe — OPENICE's stainless basket and tray, and GWYSY's coated plate and liners.
• Best for versatility across cooking methods → OPENICE. Air frying, baking, roasting and en papillote, all in a full-oven format.
In my opinion, the deciding factor isn't quality — it's what's already sitting on your counter. If you own a Ninja AF141 or AF142, I'd buy the GWYSY Air fryer Accessories, because a plate and liners sized exactly to your basket will get used every single day, and the handle alone makes it worth having. If you're cooking in a full oven and regularly feeding a family, I'd buy the OPENICE Air Fryer Basket instead — the capacity and the drip tray do more for you than any insert possibly could. Buy for the appliance you actually own, not the one you might upgrade to later.
what is the best air fryer consumer reports
I can't speak for any testing organization, and I'd be careful with anyone who claims to. What I can tell you is that the right pick depends on format: a large oven basket like the OPENICE set suits high-volume cooking, while a fitted crisper plate kit like GWYSY's suits a 5-quart Ninja. Match the accessory to your appliance and you'll get more out of it than chasing a generic "best" label.
what is the best air fryer nz consumer reports
which is the best air fryer consumer reports
If you mean which of these two accessories I'd recommend, it comes down to fit. Ninja 5-quart owner? GWYSY. Full-oven cook who wants big batches? OPENICE. Neither is universally better — they solve different problems, and buying the wrong one for your setup is the only real mistake here.
Do I need to worry about the coating wearing off?
Both products use non-stick surfaces and both are dishwasher safe, but GWYSY specifically warns against rough abrasive cloths or metal scouring balls on its enameled coating. That's good advice for the OPENICE stainless basket too. Use soft sponges, and both should hold up far better over time. As for price, check the current price on Amazon using the button on this page.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: OPENICE Air Fryer Basket vs Leonyo 11.8x9IN: Air Fryer Fried, Allstare Air Fryer Basket vs GWYSY Toaster Oven Air, YEPATER Air Fryer Basket vs COOK WITH COLOR Colorful 1200W