How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-22 · 6 min read · Independent comparison
• OOTDAY's biggest strength: 100 unbleached parchment sheets in one set — zero washing, zero scrubbing, just lift the paper and the mess goes with it.
• OOTDAY's biggest trade-off: Disposable by design and sized for small baskets (6.5-inch round, 2–4 QT), so it's an ongoing consumable rather than a one-time purchase.
• FENMORE's biggest strength: Three reusable 8-inch silicone mats in red, blue and black, dishwasher safe, rated up to 430°F — you buy once and keep rotating.
• FENMORE's biggest trade-off: You still have to wash them, and the solid silicone disc blocks some airflow compared to an open basket unless you rely on its perforations.
• Who OOTDAY is for: Small-air-fryer owners who hate cleanup and cook in bursts, parties or big families.
• Who FENMORE is for: Ninja, Instant Pot Duo, Power XL and Foodi owners who want a durable, multi-mat setup and don't mind a quick wash.
OOTDAY solves one problem very well: cleanup. These are round parchment sheets with a 6.5-inch base, an 8-inch top and a 1.77-inch raised rim, so they sit inside the basket and catch the crumbs, oil and stuck-on bits before they ever touch the non-stick coating. Because the sheet count is 100 per set, one purchase covers a long stretch of everyday cooking — that's the whole appeal.
The material story matters too. They're made from virgin wood pulp, unbleached and fluorescent-agent-free, then coated with food-grade silicone oil. That's what makes them water-proof, oil-proof and non-stick, and it's why they hold up to 428°F (220°C). The brand also states they're BPA-free. In practice, that means fries, nuggets, fish fillets, roasted vegetables and reheated leftovers all lift straight off without sticking.
Who should buy it? Anyone with a 2–4 quart air fryer who genuinely hates washing up, and anyone cooking for family dinners or birthday parties where you're going through basket after basket. The design doesn't affect the taste or color of your food, so you're not sacrificing results for convenience.
FENMORE Air Fryer Liners: Who It's For
FENMORE takes the opposite approach. Instead of paper you throw away, you get three 8-inch round silicone mats — one red, one blue, one black — made from 100% BPA-free food-grade silicone. The set weighs 3.2 ounces total, and each mat is built to survive air frying, steamer steaming, pressure cooking and oven baking up to 430°F (220°C). The three-pack is deliberate: rotate one while another is drying, and the brand points out you can wash after three meals a day without ever being stuck without a liner.
The perforated design is the detail I'd focus on if you're comparing these to a solid silicone disc. Holes let air circulate underneath and around your food, which is what gives you the crisp, even browning an air fryer is supposed to deliver. A solid mat traps steam and can leave the underside of your food soft. FENMORE also positions these as basket protectors — they shield the non-stick coating on the bottom of your fryer, which is where most wear and scratching happens.
Cleanup is easy rather than non-existent. They're non-stick, so food releases without scraping, and they're dishwasher safe or hand washable. The 8-inch diameter is sized to fit common models including Ninja, Instant Pot Duo, Power XL and Foodi, so it's a safer bet for mid-size and larger baskets than the smaller OOTDAY round.
Who should buy it? Daily air fryer users with a standard-size basket who want one purchase that keeps working, and anyone who wants to protect the coating on an expensive fryer. Who should skip it? If your basket is genuinely tiny, an 8-inch mat may sit awkwardly, and if you truly refuse to wash anything, the reusable route will annoy you.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for long-term value → FENMORE Air Fryer Liners. Three reusable mats replace an endless supply of disposable sheets; check the current price on Amazon for both and compare over a year of use.
• Best for small 2–4 QT air fryers → OOTDAY Air Fryer Liners. The 6.5-inch base and 1.77-inch rim are sized exactly for that range.
• Best for bigger baskets (Ninja, Instant Pot Duo, Power XL, Foodi) → FENMORE Air Fryer Liners. The 8-inch round fits a wider set of popular models.
• Best for crispness and airflow → FENMORE Air Fryer Liners. Perforations keep air moving instead of trapping steam under your food.
• Best for parties, batch cooking and family dinners → OOTDAY Air Fryer Liners. 100 sheets means you never run out mid-session.
• Best for protecting your basket's non-stick coating → FENMORE Air Fryer Liners. The mats are designed as a shield layer you keep in rotation.
• Best for people who hate washing dishes → OOTDAY Air Fryer Liners. Simple as that.
In my opinion, I'd buy FENMORE Air Fryer Liners for a typical kitchen. Three mats you can rotate, dishwasher-safe, 430°F rated, and perforated so your food actually crisps — that's the setup I'd want sitting in the drawer every day, and it fits the air fryers most people own.
That said, I'd genuinely choose OOTDAY if my air fryer were a 2–4 quart model and my priority was never touching a sponge. It's the cleaner, simpler answer to a messy basket — just remember the no-liquid rule and the 428°F ceiling.
FAQ
how to clean air fryer silicone liner
Rinse it in warm soapy water and wipe with a soft sponge, or put it straight in the dishwasher. FENMORE's mats are non-stick and dishwasher safe, so food releases without scrubbing. Avoid abrasive pads, which can dull the silicone surface over time.
how to use air fryer silicone liners
how to use air fryer silicone liners ninja
FENMORE lists Ninja among the compatible brands, and the 8-inch diameter is intended to sit inside common round Ninja baskets. Place it on the basket floor before adding food, and keep it below 430°F. If your Ninja basket is very small, check the 8-inch size against your basket first — or use OOTDAY's 6.5-inch parchment instead.
how to clean air fryer silicone liner with baking soda
Make a paste from baking soda and a little water, rub it over any stained or greasy spots, let it sit a few minutes, then rinse and wash normally. It's a gentle option for silicone and won't scratch the surface. For routine cleaning, plain warm soapy water or the dishwasher is usually enough.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: FENMORE Air Fryer Liners vs ailifeer 150PCS: Air Fryer, ReLuien Air Fryer Liners vs KESYOO Air Fryer Rotisserie, TeamFar Cooling Rack vs LYHOLKEER Loaf Pan Liners: Air Fryer