District: Treme - Full Control
Owner: Ryan Fearn
Rating: Contributing
Applicant: Ryan Fearn
Description: Renovation and camelback addition of existing building and new construction of a 980 SF second primary structure at a Contributing rated, one-story, single-family residential building.
Previous ARC Recommendations:
12/20/22: The ARC voted to defer your application for additional review. The ARC agreed that:
The first scheme presented is preferable to the two stand alone buildings.
Renovating a single story, single bay shotgun to a 3 story building is overwhelming.
Multiple building/addition massing iterations should be explored to address neighboring buildings.
A meeting with you and HDLC Staff should occur prior to the next ARC submission.
11/15/22: The ARC voted to defer your application for additional review. The ARC agreed that:
The massing of the 3 story addition is not appropriate contextually with respect to the existing 1 story shotgun.
The camel back should be at least 2 rooms back at the existing building.
Three stories may not be appropriate for the size of the lot.
A 3D model with street views will help show design and intent.