How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-22 · 7 min read · Independent comparison
• NewLuyer Air Fryer Rubbers — biggest strength: universal silicone bumpers that slip onto the metal tabs of a crisper plate and stop metal-on-metal scraping. Trade-off: they are a tiny replacement-part-style accessory, not a cooking surface, so they do nothing about grease or cleanup.
• PINTAUR Square Silicone Air — biggest strength: a 2-pack of square, food-grade silicone liners sized for 5–6.5QT baskets, dishwasher-safe and rated to 450°F. Trade-off: fit is specific — it is built for square fryers up to 8.9in and PINTAUR itself flags certain 6QT models as incompatible.
• NewLuyer is for you if you already like your crisper plate and just want to protect it.
• PINTAUR is for you if you want less scrubbing and less fat on your plate.
The NewLuyer Air Fryer Rubbers are the least glamorous product in this comparison, and that is exactly the point. These are small silicone covers designed to sit on the metal tab of an air fryer crisper plate. When you drop that plate into the basket or pull it back out, the bumpers take the contact instead of bare metal. That means fewer scratches on your components and less of that metallic scrape you feel when a tray shifts mid-cook. The manufacturer also frames them as adding stability, which matters if your plate tends to slide when you shake the basket.
The material is silicone, and the spec sheet calls out a few things I actually care about here: no strange smell, resistance to corrosion, and decent temperature resistance. Silicone is the right call for this job — it stays grippy, it does not rust, and it survives the heat cycles of an air fryer far better than a hard plastic or foam pad would. Installation is about as simple as it gets: you push the covers onto the metal tab. Cleaning is equally low-effort since they tolerate both cold and hot water, and the sheet notes oily residue washes off without a fight. At 0.317 ounces for the set, they are lightweight enough that you will forget they are there.
PINTAUR Square Silicone Air: Who It's For
The PINTAUR Square Silicone Air liners attack the cleanup problem head-on. This is a 2-pack of square silicone liners for 5–6.5QT air fryers, and the spec sheet is refreshingly specific about fit: they suit square baskets up to 8.9in (22.7cm), and the brand names Ninja AF181 and AF141, COSORI CAF-L501, and Cuisinart among compatible devices. It also explicitly rules out the COSORI CAF-DC601 (6QT) and the Instant Vortex Plus (6QT). I like that honesty — it tells me the seller would rather you measure than return it. Measure the top of your basket before you buy, because "6QT" clearly is not a universal size.
The material is food-grade silicone that the sheet describes as odorless, non-toxic, smoke-free and BPA-free, with a 450°F heat ceiling. That ceiling covers normal air frying, baking and roasting temperatures. The finish is non-stick, which is the whole reason a liner exists: food residue and grease land on the liner instead of baking onto your basket. It is fully dishwasher-safe, so the routine becomes "rinse, rack, done" rather than scrubbing a wire basket by hand.
The design details are where this one earns its keep. The walls are thick and sturdy, and the sheet says they resist deformation — important, because a floppy liner that collapses mid-cook is worse than no liner. The raised silicone strips on the bottom lift food out of the oil that renders off, which is how a liner can actually reduce the fat that ends up on your plate. Those same raised strips are described as improving airflow underneath the food, which the brand links to shorter cooking times. That is a plausible design argument, not a guarantee — airflow under food genuinely does help browning and even cooking, so I would expect it to help, but treat it as a design intent rather than a hard number.
At 8.5 x 8.5 x 2.36 inches with a 6.2-liter capacity and an 11.52-ounce weight for the pair, these are substantial, not flimsy. The gray square/rectangular shape is the only color or shape offered in the sheet, so no surprises there. Beyond the air fryer, the sheet lists toasters, steamers, ovens, electric pressure cookers and microwaves, which makes them useful for baking, roasting, frying or just serving. That is real added value — a liner that only works in one appliance is a drawer-clutter candidate; one that moves between the oven and the air fryer earns its cabinet space.
Who should buy it? Anyone with a compatible 5–6.5QT square basket who is tired of scrubbing, anyone cooking for two who wants a removable tray to serve straight from, and anyone trying to cut oil without giving up crispy food. Who should skip it? Owners of round baskets, owners of the explicitly incompatible 6QT models, and anyone who prefers the extra-crisp texture you get when food sits directly on the basket mesh. A liner does change browning slightly — that is the honest trade-off.
• Best for protecting your existing crisper plate → NewLuyer Air Fryer Rubbers. This is literally what they are for.
• Best for less scrubbing → PINTAUR Square Silicone Air. Grease and residue land on the liner, and it is dishwasher-safe.
• Best for cutting fat → PINTAUR Square Silicone Air. The raised bottom strips lift food out of rendered oil.
• Best for uncertain or mixed air fryer models → NewLuyer Air Fryer Rubbers. The bumpers are described as fitting most standard models, while the PINTAUR liners require a 5–6.5QT square basket up to 8.9in.
• Best for a specific known model → PINTAUR Square Silicone Air, provided your model is on the compatible list or matches the measured dimensions.
• Best for multifunction kitchens → PINTAUR Square Silicone Air. Oven, steamer, microwave and pressure cooker use are all listed.
• Best low-commitment, low-maintenance pick → NewLuyer Air Fryer Rubbers. They weigh 0.317 ounces and install in seconds.
• Best two-pack value for a household cooking regularly → PINTAUR Square Silicone Air, since you can cook in one while the other dries.
• Best if you hate measuring and want zero fit anxiety → NewLuyer Air Fryer Rubbers. No basket dimensions to check.
My Verdict
No. The NewLuyer bumpers are protective silicone covers that fit on the metal tab of a crisper plate to prevent scratches and add stability. The PINTAUR liners are full-size silicone cooking liners that sit in the basket to catch grease and food residue.
Only if you have a square 5–6.5QT basket measuring up to 8.9in across the top. PINTAUR lists Ninja AF181, AF141, COSORI CAF-L501 and Cuisinart as compatible, and explicitly says the COSORI CAF-DC601 (6QT) and Instant Vortex Plus (6QT) do not fit. Measure first.
Not necessarily, but they do different jobs. A liner handles cleanup and fat; bumpers handle wear and stability. If your crisper plate scratches the basket and you also hate scrubbing, buying both is a reasonable combo.
Both clean easily, but differently. The PINTAUR liners are dishwasher-safe and designed to keep mess off the basket entirely. The NewLuyer bumpers are small silicone pieces that rinse clean in cold or hot water, even when oily — but they do nothing to reduce the mess in the first place.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: GSZN Air Fryer Silicone vs NewLuyer Air Fryer Rubbers, TrendPlain vs PINTAUR Square Silicone Air, QCdeSoulBLV Square Airfryer Silicone vs Meyrwoy Airfryer Silicone Line