• [0:00] I'm Happy When You're Happy - Buddy Blue & His Texans (1931)

• [2:47] I'll Follow My Secret Heart - Smith Ballew with Eddie Jackson's Orchestra

• [5:44] I Love Louisa - Smith Ballew & His Orchestra (1931)

• [9:15] I'm Mad About You - Smith Ballew

• [12:03] In the Middle of a Kiss - Smith Ballew (1935)

• [15:13] I'm Forgetting Myself For You - Smith Ballew

• [18:19] I'm Throwing My Love Away - Smith Ballew

• [21:20] In My Hideaway - Ed Loyd (Ed Kirkeby) with Smith Ballew (1932)

• [24:25] Little Did I Dream - Smith Ballew & His Orchestra (1934)

• [27:33] A Little White Gardenia - Smith Ballew & His Orchestra (1935)

• [30:51] Living in Clover - Sleepy Hall & His Collegians with Smith Ballew (1932)

• [33:59] I'm For You A Hundred Percent - Smith Ballew

• [37:15] I'll Keep Warm All Winter (With My Sunny Summer Love) - Smith Ballew (1934) 

• [40:15] I'm With You - Adrien Schubert & His Orchestra with Smith Ballew (1931)

• [43:04] It's A Lonesome Old Town - Smith Ballew with Adrien Schubert's Orchestra

• [46:19] I Wouldn't Change You For The World - Smith Ballew with Don Bigelow's Orchestra

• [49:27] I Wouldn't Change You For The World - Smith Ballew with Don Bigelow's Orchestra

• [52:48] Kiss Me Goodnight Not Goodbye - Smith Ballew with Fred Rich's Orchestra

• [56:04] Just A Gigolo - Sleepy Hall with Smith Ballew (1931)

• [59:00] Let's Get Friendly (Seamos Amigos) - The New York Twelve (1931)

• [1:02:01] Kiss by Kiss - Smith Ballew

• [1:04:55] Lazy Day - Owen Fallon & His Californians (1932)

• [1:08:00] Let's Give Three Cheers For Love - Vincent Rose and His Orchestra with Smith Ballew (1934)

• [1:11:12] Let's Try Again - Smith Ballew & His Orchestra (1932)

• [1:14:21] Little Man You've Had A Busy Day - Smith Ballew

• [1:17:10] Living in Dreams - Victor Young & His Orchestra with Smith Ballew (1932)

• [1:20:07] Love and Kisses - Smith Ballew (1935)

• [1:23:17] Marta - Lou Gold & His Orchestra with Smith Ballew (1931)

• [1:26:19] Moonlight on the River - Smith Ballew & His Orchestra (1932)

• [1:29:19] Nevertheless (I'm In Love With You) - Adrian Schubert & His Orchestra with Smith Ballew (1931)

• [1:32:39] Love's Old Sweet Song - Morton Downey (1938)

• [1:35:09] Marta - Lou Gold & His Orchestra with Smith Ballew (1931)

• [1:38:12] Moonlight on the River - Smith Ballew & His Orchestra (1932)

• [1:40:47] (There Ought To Be A) Moonlight Saving Time - Smith Ballew (1931)

• [1:43:54] Music Makes Me - Smith Ballew

• [1:47:08] My Cradle Sweetheart - Smith Ballew

• [1:50:27] My Introduction to Love - Smith Ballew & His Orchestra (1935)

• [1:53:34] Lovely Lady - Morton Downey (1936)

• [1:56:45] I Idolize My Baby's Eyes - Bennie Krueger with Smith Ballew (1931)

• [2:00:20] I Live For Love - Smith Ballew

• [2:03:20] I'll Always Remember September - Peter Van Steeden & His Orchestra (1931)

• [2:06:40] Makin' Faces at the Man in the Moon - Smith Ballew (1931)

• [2:09:53] Repeats from the top

Songs that may have been on an older version of this stream!

• I've Got You On the Top of My List - Smith Ballew (1934)

• I'm Dancing With the Girl of My Dreams - Smith Ballew (1934)

• I'm Sorry Dear - Adrian Schubert (1931)

• I Thank You Mr. Moon - Smith Ballew (1931)

• I'll String Along with You - Smith Ballew (1934)

• I'm Just A Dancing Sweetheart - Fred Rich with Smith Ballew (1931)

• Let's Have Another Cup O' Coffee - Smith Ballew (as 'Buddy Blue') (1932)

• Autumn Concerto - Ted Heath (1956)

Special thanks to The 2nd Coming Of Layne Krusz on YouTube for this list and shoutout to Hans Klopek and Halcyon for their assistance!

Underlined songs are linked to either a YouTube video of the song or to a recording of the song from the Internet Archive. Question marks mean the song is unknown.