We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-25 · 7 min read · Independent comparison
If you want liners custom-shaped for a CHEFMAN 6-quart dual-basket air fryer with a taller protective rim and a 200-sheet supply, choose mutvle Rectangle Air Fryer; if you need a much larger 420-sheet stash of slightly wider 8" x 5.5" rectangles with silicone-coated non-stick surfaces, choose ctizne 420PCS.
• mutvle Rectangle Air Fryer — biggest strength: A pre-formed 8" x 5" rectangle with a raised 4.5 cm (1.8") edge, made from unbleached wood pulp treated with plant-based oil, 12% thicker than ordinary parchment, BPA-free and PFA-free, heat resistant to 450°F/230°C, in a 200-sheet pack.
• mutvle Rectangle Air Fryer — biggest trade-off: It ships 200 sheets versus ctizne's 420, so heavy daily cooks will run out sooner, and its 8" x 5" footprint is narrower than ctizne's.
• ctizne 420PCS — biggest strength: A 420-sheet count in an 8" x 5.5" rectangle, made from raw wood pulp with a silicone coating that's bleach-free, BPA-free and PFA-free, packed in a transparent box so you can see how many are left.
• ctizne 420PCS — biggest trade-off: The sheets are flat rectangles without mutvle's raised rim, so they rely on food weight to stay put rather than a formed edge, and the material is thinner in profile than mutvle's thicker parchment.
• Who each pick is for: mutvle for CHEFMAN, Ninja, TurboFry Touch and COSORI dual-basket owners who want a bowl-shaped liner with a rim; ctizne for anyone who wants a bigger stash of slightly wider flat liners and doesn't mind that they aren't custom-fitted to one machine.
The mutvle Rectangle Air Fryer is, at heart, a fit-first product. It's designed around the CHEFMAN 6 Quart Dual Basket Air Fryer Oven, and the brand also lists compatibility with Ninja 6-quart dual-basket models, the TurboFry Touch dual air fryer and the COSORI 9Qt Dual air fryer. That's a specific set of machines, and it matters: a liner only does its job if it actually sits in the basket the way it's supposed to.
What stands out in the specs is the shape. Each sheet is a pre-formed 8" x 5" rectangle with a 4.5 cm (1.8") raised edge, so it functions more like a shallow paper bowl than a flat sheet. That edge is the whole point — it guards the sides of the basket, keeps food from touching the walls, and helps contain oil and crumbs instead of letting them run underneath. Because it's pre-cut, there's no tearing, folding, cutting or bending before you cook. You drop it in and go.
The material choices are worth noting too. It's unbleached natural wood pulp with a plant-based oil treatment, no fluorescent agent, BPA-free and PFA-free, and it's heat resistant up to 450°F/230°C. The brand says it's 12% thicker than ordinary parchment, which is the kind of detail that shows up in practice when you lift a loaded liner out of the basket — thin paper tears, thicker paper doesn't. You get 200 sheets per pack, and each one is single-use, so you lift it out and throw it away instead of scrubbing the basket.
So who should buy it? I'd point to anyone with one of the listed dual-basket machines who is tired of soaking and hand-washing two baskets after every dinner, and who values a liner that stays put because it's shaped for the compartment. Who should skip it? If you own an air fryer outside that compatibility list, or you want the largest possible sheet count per pack, or you prefer a flat liner you can use across several different pans and trays, this isn't the one I'd hand you.
The ctizne 420PCS is built around volume and convenience. The headline number is in the name: 420 sheets. If you cook in your air fryer most days, that's a supply that lasts a long time, and the count is the single biggest practical difference between these two products.
The sheets measure 8" x 5.5" — a touch wider than mutvle's 8" x 5" — and they're designed for Ninja Dual Zone machines. They're flat rectangles rather than formed bowls, which cuts both ways. The upside is flexibility: a flat sheet slides under food in more kinds of baskets and trays, and there's no specific rim geometry that has to line up with a specific compartment. The downside is that there's no raised edge to hold the paper against the basket wall, so keeping it in place comes down to putting enough food on top of it.
On materials, ctizne uses raw wood pulp with a silicone coating. The brand states there's no bleach, no BPA and no PFAS, and that the silicone surface is naturally non-stick and waterproof, so nothing harmful migrates into your food during high-heat cooking. It also says the material is heat resistant and won't warp or release anything unpleasant at cooking temperatures. The non-stick surface is meant to help food cook evenly and slide out cleanly, which is the everyday reason most people buy liners in the first place.
One detail I actually like: the sheets come in a transparent plastic box. That sounds minor until you've had a loose stack of parchment on a shelf, getting dusty and impossible to count. A box keeps them waterproof and dust-free and lets you see at a glance how many are left, so you know when to reorder instead of discovering it mid-cook.
Who should buy it? Anyone with a Ninja Dual Zone who wants a long-lasting stash, wants a slightly roomier sheet, and doesn't need a custom-formed rim. Who should skip it? If your machine is one of the CHEFMAN or COSORI models mutvle names, or if you specifically want the taller raised edge to protect the basket sides, mutvle is the better-fitted choice.
• Best for CHEFMAN 6-quart dual-basket owners → mutvle Rectangle Air Fryer. It's custom-designed for that machine, and the 8" x 5" footprint is made to sit in the compartment.
• Best for the largest supply → ctizne 420PCS. 420 sheets versus 200 means roughly double the run time before you reorder.
• Best for basket-side protection → mutvle Rectangle Air Fryer. Its 4.5 cm raised edge shields the basket walls and keeps food from sticking to them.
• Best for slightly wider coverage → ctizne 420PCS. At 8" x 5.5", each sheet covers a bit more surface than mutvle's 8" x 5".
• Best for tear resistance when lifting → mutvle Rectangle Air Fryer. Its parchment is described as 12% thicker than ordinary parchment, which is the spec that matters when you lift a loaded liner out.
• Best for storage and counting sheets → ctizne 420PCS. The transparent box keeps them dust-free and shows you how many remain.
• Best for flat, flexible use across pans and trays → ctizne 420PCS. No formed rim means it isn't tied to one basket shape.
• Best for a formed, drop-in liner that needs no folding → mutvle Rectangle Air Fryer. Pre-cut and pre-shaped; nothing to tear or bend.
• Best for Ninja Dual Zone compatibility → ctizne 420PCS. It's explicitly sized for Ninja Dual Zone baskets at 8" x 5.5".
In my opinion, I'd buy the mutvle Rectangle Air Fryer if I owned a CHEFMAN 6-quart dual-basket air fryer or one of the other machines it names. The formed 8" x 5" bowl with the 4.5 cm rim is the difference between a liner that works with your basket and one that just sits in it, and the thicker unbleached parchment is the spec that decides whether it survives being lifted out. If I didn't own one of those machines, or if I mainly wanted to stop thinking about reordering, I'd take the ctizne 420PCS instead — 420 sheets, a slightly wider cut, and a box that tells you when you're running low. Both are single-use, both are BPA- and PFA-free, and both are heat resistant. The deciding question is fit versus volume. Check the current price on Amazon before you commit, then pick the one that matches your basket.
FAQ
It's custom-designed for the CHEFMAN 6 Quart Dual Basket Air Fryer Oven, and the brand also lists Ninja 6-quart dual-basket models, the TurboFry Touch dual air fryer and the COSORI 9Qt Dual air fryer. If your machine isn't on that list, measure your basket before buying.
mutvle includes 200 sheets; ctizne includes 420. Since both are single-use, ctizne lasts roughly twice as long if you cook at the same pace, which is the main reason to pick it over mutvle if supply matters more than fit.
mutvle states heat resistance up to 450°F/230°C, and both brands say their liners are free of bleach, BPA and PFAS. ctizne uses raw wood pulp with a silicone coating; mutvle uses unbleached wood pulp with a plant-based oil treatment.
No. mutvle's are pre-cut 8" x 5" rectangles with a 4.5 cm raised edge, so there's no tearing, folding or bending. ctizne's are flat 8" x 5.5" rectangles — just lay one under your food so it doesn't get blown around.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: Cabilock Air Fryer Rotisserie vs ctizne 420PCS: Air Fryer, ctizne Air Fryer Liners vs Glazeal Three Stackable Dehydrator, GWBSXM Air Fryer Rack vs mutvle Air Fryer Liners