11/30/2023 (WIP):
It is a generally unwritten rule of society and culture that of anyone notable or of prominence, unless there's a only couple pictures of them available, there will seemingly be only one or two pictures that are the most used for reference. Which they're most recognizable by. Maestro-warbler Will Osborne was no different to this. Over his 76 confirmed years of life (but very likely as many as 80), Osborne's face and torso has been captured by over 70 cameras in a variety of different settings between at least 1927 to 1967 for public eyes, not to mention the doubtless hundreds more in his family's collection, as well as ones he took as his hobby of photography.
Frustratingly few of these times ever showing him with his orchestras, which makes research all the more difficult. Will once explained the reasoning to a reported in 1933:
"Though he has taken some pictures with his orchestra, none of these are recent photograph [Sic.] For a long period of time Osborne has steadfastly refused to pose with his music makers. He claims that every time he has done so, the orchestra has experienced a change." The Brooklyn Times Union Brooklyn, NY. 5/14/33 pp 14.
However, through this time, he had a fair amount of pictures with his friends in the industry, sidemen, as well as a dozen different "Publicity Stills". If one is unfamiliar with what these are, they are encouraged to think of their favorite celebrity taking a picture for multiple public uses. Usually one in which they're posed to look either at the camera or off to the side, etc. Hundreds of copies would be made. These would be signed in droves and sent out to adoring fans of the airwaves, or at many an engagement, through Will's management office. As well as used by the press anytime they needed to report on Osborne and having enough room to put in a picture, or by music publishers to note that the crooner introduced and crooned their song over the airwaves and/or record. Also for plenty of promotional material.
Will's first publicity still--as well as the youngest picture we have of his, goes back to the year 1927. For the limited info on Will we have at the time, other than rough engagement and radio dates, it was around this time that he first started to have a chance of notoriety with his small orchestra. So sometime that year, the following publicity still was taken, probably due to him getting his first manager.
Although this picture was taken in 1927, the earliest known appearance of it comes from 1929. It comes in all different variations, many with far less contrast, many where it's only his shoulders and head present, and rarely showing his full pose. This still appears to mostly be used for official purposes--as in no signed copies for fans seem to have appeared as of yet. It's seen in many newspaper articles for Osborne coming to a town or theater engagement, occasionally on sheet music--with the lighter colors usually being in shades of pink or yellow--too. A cleaner copy of it, although cropped drastically, is seen on page 166 in Leo Walker's 1966 book The Wonderful Era Of The Great Dance Bands. It would be used every once in a while as late as 1934.
1929 would be Will's first big year of success, in which many pictures would be taken of the crooner as he became sensational. Starting his rivalry with Rudy Vallee, obtaining his first major radio contracts over the Columbia Broadcasting System (CBS), having his earliest confirmed records being over Columbia Records, and publishing a handful of songs with his pianist Paul Denniker, as well as several other partners like Charles O'Flynn, Al Hoffman, and Al Woods. There would be too many pictures to cover here. But one of the most well known of this period was one taken in sometime between probably late 1929 and mid 1930. Original occurrences of it is quite rare. Knowledge of it the photo is also quite hard to come across. Other than it was first appearing in a Feature Piece of Rudy Vallee, Will Osborne, and Guy Lombardo in Radio Digest magazine from May, 1930. The article is quite extensive and has the fairest and most accurate period account of the rivalry, as well as equally crediting the three of them for their undeniable responsibility for creating the slower, more romantic melodies that crooning was really meant for, that went on to shape the industry. The author Rosemary Drachman and others at the time labeled it as "Slow Motion Rhythms". The following photo would be featured at the bottom right of the second of four pages, with a picture of the Lombardo Trio in the middle (Carmen, Guy, and Lebert), and at the top left Vallee. The picture used for Vallee is one seen in various newspapers from the time as a common picture going back to 1929. We can reasonably assume this is the case for the Lombardos and Will too. Very few, if any other examples of this photo has been reprinted throughout Osborne's career.
So why then is the above picture so well known today? That being because when Osborne's Wikipedia page was made (which as it stands now in the fall of 2023, has been a unacceptable state of regurgitated information with practically no context behind anything, as well as most recently audacious statements that insinuate there never was a Vallee-Osborne rivalry.) in February of 2016, the users captured this picture from this mentioned article. Frustratingly however, the amount of Information about Osborne in this one May, 1930 article not only dwarfs the size of the Wikipedia article at it's current state, but also clears up many of the falsehoods regurgitated and oversimplified from the other sources all throughout the Wikipedia. Behavior unfortunately all too familiar through the decades of people discussing Will.
Throughout the 30s, plenty more Publicity Stills would appear. Most of which coming from 1929 - 1931. But as the early 30s turned into the mid 30s, Osborne had changed his music, his appearance, his clothes, as well as his values. Although he was always seen as a gentlemen of pure respect for others and high class and selflessness, in late 1932 he publicly "quit crooning", which inspired a change in his music. No longer was it the higher pitched croons over a musical arrangements nestled in Hot Jazz and Dance Band melodies of strings and woodwinds, now there was a solid brass section, and near constant effort to make one arrangement better than the last. He was more of a figure of Ballroom Society music, high class, intense modesty, as well as undeniable intellect flooding his music. So by August of 1933, Will went in for another photo shoot of stills. Now wearing a white, double-breasted suit, and a new modest, calm smile and haircut parted similarly to that of Roger Wolfe Kahn. This photo session resulted in several pictures being released.
This is the standard Publicity Still seen of Will mostly throughout the 30s, and true to it's purpose, Will has signed this to one "Pete", saying he's Will's best friend. This specific copy I obtained back in December of 2019, and unfortunately do not have any more information on it. That signature in the bottom lefthand corner being "Talbot, NY" likely refers to the studio in which the picture was taken. Rarely--if ever will one see this image without that bottom signature. Perhaps it could've been the building in which Osborne's publicity management was at the time. This picture has alternatives like shown below:
The differences are subtle, and one can be forgiven for not seeing the differences easily, but notice the lighting differences on the right side of Will, his tie and undershirt as shifted a bit, and he smirks instead of smiles. This was taken from a December 10th, 1933 page of The Baltimore Sun, showing that Will would be appearing at a local theatre. It's one of the few known times this picture has appeared. Once in a while you will see a full picture of this one appear on sheet music--usually with pink or red instead of white. Then lastly there would be one more picture taken about this time:
This picture is one of the oldest photos we have of Will in a live scenario. First appearing in Newspapers in late August of 1933, with varying degrees of cropping. Sometimes it would just be showing Will himself in shot, or sometimes just a thumbnail shot of Will's neck to hair, often flipped. Perhaps the most well known usage of this picture was by Radio Guide magazine in their January, 1936 issue for a Feature Story on Will. "S-L-I-D-E" being the feature's name, by Marvin W. Strate. Strate or the editorial staff decided the best way to use the picture was to crop and reverse the image it seems, as well as publish it in black & green, rather than black & white. Looking similarly to pictures of artists in late 10s-early 20s sheet music. The caption underneath the picture in that instance said: "Note the easy grace which Will uses when leading his orchestra". The whole feature is freely accessible online, and has held up for the most part to be factually truthful today.
Notably, in this picture, Will is shown with three sidemen out of focus in the background. Two violinists up front, and it looks like a trombonist in back. Who these sidemen are, are currently unidentified, but if the date of Fall, 1933 is the true origin of this picture is true, then the violinists are two of: Bruce Yantis (violin), Elliott Russel (violin; if so, the left violin), Jack Small (violin), and Andy Russo (trombone). The only areas Will was playing in that's documented to have radio link-up in August of 1933 is the Longue-Vue Country Club, which was under an NBC wire, all other known radio broadcasting happened in WABC and WOR Columbia Broadcasting System studios by this time--but could likely just be one CBS studio but broadcasted over both remotely per days necessary pertaining to his 'commercial' scheduling. Although if this is the case, it goes to show then how vastly decorative CBS was taking things for their in-house audiences to see each band, if there's chandeliers and ornate designs on the walls and ceilings. Another notable factor is the suits that Will and his boys wear. Vaudeville and Theatre engagement reviews at this time describe Osborne and his band since September of 1932 to be dressed in white, or in "white palm-beach suits" as said prior. If this photo isn't simply indicative that Osborne and his orchestra didn't wear these during radio engagements, then it's likely that this picture could predate 1933 even, however It's not found anywhere before then. Only time will tell.
The picture was used in the print throughout the mid-30s regularly in papers, but seem to disappear by 1937. Every now and then under the right circumstances, you can find this picture out in the internet. Osborne's stepson has spoken to me about a picture in the family possession of "Will in a radio studio with a CBS Microphone" before, and it's likely it's a print of this. Time will tell here as well, if it will be retrieved. It would be nice to find it in better quality, and learn more of it's secrets. Clearly there is a story here, for the photograph overall, that has yet to be explored.