Working Papers

This theoretical paper investigates mandated interoperability between messaging services.  We consider a situation in which a high-privacy paid niche app competes with a low-privacy free app with a large installed user base. Consumers vary in privacy concerns and can multi-home across different apps. We find that niche app users may end up being harmed by partial privacy-preserving interoperability relative to no interoperability. Moreover, full interoperability may not necessarily promote market contestability, especially when privacy concerns significantly outweigh network benefits. We find a mismatch between the low-privacy app's incentives for interoperability and the surplus of niche app users, suggesting that mandating a specific level of interoperability is essential for policy. Our results remain robust even in an interoperability setting which leads to privacy loss simply by opting in to it. 

Keywords: Interoperability, Compatibility, Multi-homing, Messaging Apps, Network Effects, Privacy, Regulation, Digital Markets Act

Numerical Analysis in R