Initial Guiding Question: How does Uruguay teach multiple perspectives in a culturally competent way?
Evolved Guiding Question: How do we determine what is "right" or "the right way" to educate our students?
While I have been in Uruguay, my guiding question has evolved and changed altogether. There have been a few reasons for this, and one reason was due to the fact that I didn’t have a lot of context or knowledge about the Uruguayan school system before coming to Uruguay. If I had known that schools were so vastly different, I would have been a little more intentional about how I worded my question. Another reason is that I was unable to observe a class similar to what I teach at home, and this did not allow me to see any perspectives shared between students.
Therefore, I adjusted my question to fit my experience more broadly and focus on something I have been turning over in my mind since arriving here.
While this might seem like a question that doesn’t have a “right” answer, it delves more deeply into how our two education systems are both varied and vastly different. It feels almost insane to try and compare them as they are not in sync in many ways. However, if the end goal of any education system is to create well-rounded global citizens who contribute to the workforce and the betterment of their world, then both the U.S. and Uruguay do have things they can learn from each other.
I will not be able to answer the question of who is right in their education system, but I can point to some of the challenges that both systems face and what can be shared between them to better accommodate students in our 21st-century world.
One of the ways that students learn best is with a teacher who can present material at their level, engage with them with care and understanding, and find ways to make learning relevant to their lives. In the United States, our education system theoretically is used to teach all students a certain number of required courses, use standardized tests to measure this learning, and ultimately graduate those students who have mastered the required learning.
As a teacher who has worked in the education of the United States for 18 years, I know that students vary greatly in their understanding of core concepts per grade level. Our system in Oregon is designed differently than our neighboring states and even within other states throughout the country. Standards aren’t aligned throughout the United States, and state funding is also divided. Therefore, not everyone’s learning experience in school throughout the United States is equal.
In Uruguay, the number of students is roughly 700-750,000 students countrywide. In the United States, that number jumps to 79 million. We have hundreds of universities with degrees in Education, while Uruguay has one teaching program that is used for all pre-service teachers. When a teacher graduates from college, they have a bachelor’s degree that can take them into the classroom or into a plethora of other jobs. In Uruguay, teachers graduate as teachers–and without a degree. They can only teach because their four-year courses have centered around the pedagogy of teaching students.
Is this the correct way to prepare teachers to teach? In the United States, pre-service teachers have a variety of program requirements for student teaching. At Western Oregon University in 2006, I had an entire year of student teaching. A previous student teacher of mine had only a month of observation, and then she could be licensed (doing her other student teaching in 6 months at another classroom). In Uruguay, you spend four years taking classes on pedagogy and didactics, while also student teaching. You could have hours of classes in the morning and student teaching until 7 PM at night. Not to mention the student teachers we met who had to travel two hours to their schools each day (and two hours home).
Another difference between our school systems is the number of hours that students are in the classroom. In the United States, most students spend approximately 7 hours a day at school, 5 days a week, 9 months out of the year. The average amount of school hours required by the state of Oregon is around 165 days. My district in Hillsboro has 172 school days. In contrast, Uruguay has buildings that cannot house all the students at one time. Therefore, most schools throughout the country are only 4 hours a day, with an AM and PM shift. What do students do when they aren’t in school? Most are home or go to activities in their community.
The final difference is the responsibility of who repairs buildings. In the United States, local taxes pay for building upgrades, and school districts are responsible for the upkeep and fixing of any school building. In contrast, Uruguay's government builds a school, and then it is the responsibility of the school to maintain its building. When I visited one elementary school in Maldonado, they were fundraising to pay for a new roof. Another school was slowly exchanging all their old TVs in the classroom for flat-screen TVs. They also needed each classroom to be painted, as there were scuff marks and peeling paint on the walls. What happens when a teacher needs supplies for their students? In Uruguay, they must buy the supplies themselves. In the United States, this is a similar situation, although our salaries are greater than those of Uruguayan teachers.
Overall, I have pointed out several differences between the United States and the Uruguayan school system. The question still remains: which system is the right system? Should students in the United States have fewer hours in the classroom, or should Uruguay increase the number of hours? How would their aging buildings be able to handle the increased load of students per day? Is the American school system requiring too much of its students? While there isn't one answer to any of these questions, it does bring up some talking points about how we can support and learn from our global classrooms beyond the United States.