The germ theory of disease was widely accepted by the 1890s, yet infectious diseases remained among the leading causes of death in U.S. cities decades later. I show that the modern understanding of person-to-person disease transmission and corresponding preventive hygiene guidance did not diffuse widely until the mid-1910s, immediately preceding (and vastly accelerated by) the influenza pandemic of 1918. Using detailed household expenditure data collected around pandemic onset, I document that households responded to the pandemic shock by consuming more goods associated with modern hygiene (e.g., soap) relative to goods associated with outdated prevention practices. Moreover, I find that post-pandemic hygiene expenditures were higher among households with indoor running water and related fixtures that reduced the cost of handwashing, despite no detectable gradient beforehand. To test whether these differences contributed to health, I combine a new city-level measure of household hygiene infrastructure access with cause-specific mortality for 86 U.S. cities from 1910–1937 and compare their mortality trajectories before and after the pandemic shock. I find that a 10 percentage point increase in baseline access is associated with a persistent 4–6 percent decline in respiratory disease mortality in the years following the pandemic. This gradient remains even among cities whose public water systems served the entire population, speaking to contemporary debates about the merits of private relative to shared water access. More broadly, these results show how the returns to new health knowledge can depend on earlier infrastructure investments that lower the cost of adoption.
Workers’ compensation was the first widespread social insurance program in the United States, but its long-run effects on injured workers and their families are not well understood. We examine this by leveraging quasi-random variation in both work accidents and access to workers’ compensation for families in the early-20th-century United States. Prior to the program, few families carried life insurance and more than half of work accident widows remarried within three years. We build a new data set describing over 220,000 work accidents and match it with linked Census data to follow the spouses and children of work accident victims over the following 10 to 30 years. Exploiting the quasi-random timing of fatal accidents relative to program implementation in a stacked difference-in-differences approach, we estimate that access to workers' compensation substantially decreased remarriage among women widowed by a work accident. Reductions in remarriage are larger in states where widows lost benefits upon remarriage, suggesting that policy incentives may have played a role, but still large (12 percentage points) in states with no such policy incentive. Taken together, the evidence suggests that remarriage was a highly-used form of informal insurance but that a significant share of women shifted toward social insurance once it became available.
The prominent decline in urban mortality rates during the late 19th and early 20th centuries in the United States is primarily attributed to reductions in deaths caused by infectious and food- and waterborne diseases. While existing literature has explored the role of public health initiatives in explaining this decline from the latter of these types, this paper focuses on the contribution of innovations in and provision of hygienic technologies and their role in eradication of the former. Specifically, we investigate the health impact of the rapid adoption and utilization of bathhouses in urban working-class neighborhoods following the technological advancement of what we recognize today as the modern-day shower. By exploiting differential timing of bathhouse openings beginning around 1890 and utilizing city-level mortality data for U.S. urban areas, we estimate the mortality effects of these facilities introduced prior to the widespread adoption of modern household sanitation infrastructure and critical implications generated by the germ theory of disease. This paper highlights the role that hygienic infrastructure and behavior may have played in improving public health, shedding light on mechanisms policy makers can utilize when designing interventions aimed at encouraging behavioral take-up today.
Available as NBER Working Paper 30063