Titleholders Throughout the Years

MISS LANCASTER COUNTY TITLEHOLDERS

Miss Lancaster County

1947 Mary Lou Wilmer

1948 Lucille Wright

1949 Joanne Weiler (Top 5)

1950 Senta von Ehrenfried

1951 Betsy Ettinger

1953 Evelyn Ay (Miss Pennsylvania, Miss America)

1958 Dorothy Ann Fletcher (Non-Finalist Talent Winner)

1959 Gini Heine (Top 5)

1960 Eleanor Johnson (1st Runner Up)

1961 Barbara Keener

1962 Mary Hill

1963 Donna Loar (Miss Pennsylvania)

1964 Gay Weiches

1965 Londa Boyd

1966 Stephanie Fauber

1967 Doris Lausch (Miss Pennsylvania)

1968 Gail Rabold (4th Runner Up)

1969 Pamela Nies (Top 10)

1970 Krista L. Burdock

1971 Gail Burnagord (Top 10)

1972 Joan Kling

1973 Tina Thomas (Miss Pennsylvania)

1974 Brenda Landis

1975 Marlene Frank (1st Runner Up)

1976 Gloria Longenecker (1st Runner Up)

1977 Lynn Carol Grote (Miss Pennsylvania)

1978 Jill Brown (Top 10)

1979 Carolyn Black (Miss Pennsylvania)

1980 Cyndi Taylor (4th Runner Up)

1981 Diane Boomsma (3rd Runner Up)

1982 Wendy Geesey

1983 Kathleen Ward (2nd Runner Up)

1984 Victoria Louise Boomsma (Top 10)

1985 Leisa Jacqueline Brown (Top 10)

1986 Kathy Lynn Keith

1987 Carla Jenkins (1st Runner Up)

1988 Rachel Farmer (3rd Runner Up)

1989 Raysa Acosta (Top 10)

1990 Jennifer Ann Graeber

1991 Danette Louise Caffrey

1992 Patricia Ann Ford (Top 10)

1993 Brenda Kaye Blevins

1994 Amy Louvise Renner (1st Runner Up)

1997 Leslie Shirk

1998 Catherine Elizabeth Walker

1999 Kathryn Elizabeth Zeager (3rd Runner Up)

2000 Erika Suzanne Smith

2016 Kayla Schneider

2017 Page Weinstein

2018 Marissa Witmer

2019 Courtney Armstrong (Non-Finalist Talent Winner)

2020 Kayla Myers* (Top 10)

2022 Miranda Moore (4th Runner Up)

2023 Victoria Vespico (2nd Runner Up)

2024 Noelle Schneider (Top 10)

2025 Madelyn Whitcraft (Non-Finalist Interview Award)

* - Title held for two years

Miss Lancaster

1947 Mary Ellen Long

1948 Corinne Clemenceau

Miss Red Rose City

2016 Tiffany Shrom

2017 Marla Peifer (1st Runner Up)

2018 Jenna Martorana

2019 Brianna Kubishin

2021 Jenna Martorana

2022 Samantha Bretz (Top 10)

2023 AmandaGrace Krier (Top 10)

2024 Julianna Billings

2025 Samantha Roth

Miss Commonwealth

2020 Lexi Bryant*

* - Title held for two years

Miss Heart of Lancaster

2021 Breanne Sensenig

2023 Elaine Ficarra

2024 AmandaGrace Krier

2025 Christina Herman (1st Runner Up)

MISS LANCASTER COUNTY TEEN TITLEHOLDERS

Miss Lancaster County Teen

2016 Kayla Hostetter

2017 Noelle Schneider (Top 10)

2018 Sierra Anastasi (3rd Runner Up)

2019 Annie Mowery (Top 10)

2020 Mahisha Tanna * (2nd Runner Up)

2022 Kari Ann Leventopoulos (Non-Finalist Interview & Fitness)

2023 Emilee Koch (Top 8)

2024 Kathryn Davis (Top 8)

2025 Ksenya Wong (Top 8)

* - Title held for two Years

Miss Red Rose City Teen

2019 Allison Gress

2020 Lizzie Plakans* (3rd Runner Up)

2022 Madelyn Sheffel (Top 8)

2023 Maille McNicholas (2nd Runner Up)

2024 Whitney Ridler

2025 Ayanalis Cordero

* - Title held for two years 

Miss Heart of Lancaster Teen

2023 Kristin Griffiths

2024 Maggie Roe

2025 Maille McNicholas (4th Runner Up)