We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-10-05 · 7 min read · Independent comparison
If you want replacement ear pads for Plantronics BackBeat Pro 2 or Voyager 8200 UC headphones — a quick, comfort-first fix for worn-out cushions on a headset your child already uses for school or music — choose Miruchertter Voyager 8200; if you need replacement cushions for a SteelSeries Arctis gaming headset (Arctis 1, 3, 5, 7, 7+, 9, or Pro) and you want them to feel and sound as close to the originals as possible, choose Fadmew Arctis 7/5/3/1. Both are ear pad replacements, not headphones, and neither is a set of true wireless earbuds — but if you're shopping around for children's audio gear and stumbled onto these listings, this breakdown will tell you exactly which pad fits your situation.
• Miruchertter Voyager 8200 — biggest strength: high-density noise-isolating memory foam that's built to hold its shape and stay comfortable through long listening sessions, plus a stated 1-year manufacturer warranty.
• Miruchertter Voyager 8200 — biggest trade-off: it fits exactly one family of headsets (Plantronics BackBeat Pro 2 / Voyager 8200 UC), so it's useless if your child's headset is a SteelSeries.
• Fadmew Arctis 7/5/3/1 — biggest strength: OEM-matched construction, size and color across a very wide list of Arctis models, with breathable heat-dissipating fiber to reduce sweat during long sessions.
• Fadmew Arctis 7/5/3/1 — biggest trade-off: compatibility is the whole story here — it only makes sense if you own one of the listed Arctis headsets, and it's sold as a pad pair, not a headset.
• For the Plantronics household → Miruchertter Voyager 8200.
• For the SteelSeries Arctis household → Fadmew Arctis 7/5/3/1.
The Miruchertter Voyager 8200 set is a pair of replacement ear cushions for two specific Plantronics headsets: the BackBeat Pro 2 and the Voyager 8200 UC. That's the entire scope. If your child's headset is one of those two, this is a direct, purpose-built fix for flattened, cracked, or peeling pads. If it isn't, stop reading this half of the article — it won't fit.
What it does best is comfort and isolation. The pads use high-density memory foam, which the listing describes as noise-isolating and durable — the foam is meant to return to its original shape when the headphones aren't in use, rather than staying compressed the way cheap pads do after a few months. For a kid who wears a headset through a long online class, a homework session, or a flight, that shape recovery matters more than it sounds: it's the difference between a pad that still seals around the ear in month six and one that's gone flat. Better sealing also means better passive noise isolation, which quietly helps in a noisy house.
Who should buy it: parents replacing the pads on a Plantronics BackBeat Pro 2 or Voyager 8200 UC that's otherwise working fine, and anyone who wants maximum cushioning and isolation back without replacing the whole headset. Who should skip it: anyone with a SteelSeries Arctis, anyone with a different Plantronics model not named here, and anyone whose headset problem is the electronics rather than the cushions.
Fadmew Arctis 7/5/3/1: Who It's For
The Fadmew set is the mirror image: it's built for the SteelSeries Arctis line and nothing else. The compatibility list is long — Arctis 7, 7+, 7P, 7P+, 7X, 7X+, 5, 3, 1, 9X, 9, Pro and Prime, wired and wireless. That breadth is the reason this listing keeps showing up in searches, and it's genuinely useful if your household has more than one Arctis headset, since a single spare pair can serve whichever one wears out first.
The pitch here is "same as OEM." Same construction, same size, same color as the stock cushions — close enough that, per the listing, you can't tell the difference side by side. That's a meaningful claim for a replacement part, because the most common complaint about third-party pads is that they subtly change the sound or break the seal. Fadmew's answer is slow-rebound dense memory foam that seals around the ear the same way the originals do, so sound quality and noise isolation stay put. For a gaming headset, that seal is doing real acoustic work — a loose pad leaks bass and lets room noise in.
The second design choice is breathability. The outer layer is a heat-conducting fiber meant to move heat away and evaporate sweat, which is the right priority for a kid in a multi-hour gaming session or a long video call. Sweaty ears are the main reason pads get gross and get replaced in the first place. Installation is a simple peel-and-tuck: pull the old pad off, push the new pad's rubber lip into the top groove, then work the rest of the lip around with your fingers — no tools, and the listing includes left and right pads plus instructions.
Who should buy it: anyone with a listed Arctis model whose pads are flat, flaking, or sweaty. Who should skip it: Plantronics owners, anyone with a non-Arctis headset, and anyone expecting a headset in the box — this is a pad pair only.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Your headset is a SteelSeries Arctis (1/3/5/7/7+/9/Pro/Prime) → Fadmew Arctis 7/5/3/1.
• You want to keep the original look and sound as close to stock as possible → Fadmew, since it's explicitly built to match OEM construction, size and color.
• You want maximum cushion and isolation for long, quiet listening → Miruchertter, with its high-density noise-isolating memory foam.
• Your kid sweats through pads during long gaming or class sessions → Fadmew, thanks to the breathable heat-dissipating outer fiber.
• Your child is rough on gear and you want a warranty behind the part → Miruchertter, which states a 1-year manufacturer warranty.
• You own several headsets of one brand and want one spare pair to cover them → Fadmew, given how many Arctis models a single set fits.
• You're not sure which headset you have → check the model printed on the headband before ordering. Fit is the only spec that actually matters here.
In my opinion, the right pick comes down to one question: what's on your kid's head? If it's a Plantronics BackBeat Pro 2 or Voyager 8200 UC, I'd buy the Miruchertter Voyager 8200 — the noise-isolating memory foam and the 1-year warranty make it the more reassuring choice for a part that gets worn every day. If it's any SteelSeries Arctis, I'd buy the Fadmew Arctis 7/5/3/1, because the OEM-matched fit and breathable fiber are exactly what a gaming headset needs. Neither is a set of true wireless earbuds and neither is a rotatable ear cups bone conduction or touch control neckband headphone — they're replacement cushions, and for children who already own one of these headsets, a fresh pair of pads is often the cheapest way to make an old headset feel new again. Check the current price on Amazon for whichever one matches your model.
FAQ
Neither is universally better — they fit different headsets. Miruchertter is for Plantronics BackBeat Pro 2 and Voyager 8200 UC; Fadmew is for SteelSeries Arctis models. Match the pad to your headset and the comparison resolves itself.
Fadmew states its cushions match the OEM in construction, size and color, and that sound and isolation are unchanged. Miruchertter emphasizes upgraded high-density memory foam and noise isolation rather than an exact OEM match. Both are designed as drop-in replacements.
No. Both are replacement ear cushions only — the headset is not included. Fadmew includes one pair (left and right) plus instructions; Miruchertter is a replacement pad set as well.
Check the model name on the headband. Plantronics BackBeat Pro 2 or Voyager 8200 UC means Miruchertter. Any SteelSeries Arctis 1/3/5/7/7+/9/Pro/Prime means Fadmew. If it's neither brand, neither of these will fit.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: ASHATA Charging Case Replacement vs ZRATFWLJMDK Earphones, bluetooth multipoint headphones, KTGEE Earbuds vs Niecase Bone Conduction Headphones, New Bee Earpiece V5.2 vs Fodsports FX-S Motorcycle