The question arises: “So, if I’m trying to create the ‘illusion’ of a live big band performance (as just one example,) what’s the difference between what I do and using AI?”
That’s a fair question. I have to ask myself ethically, is creating music using AI prompts any more or less commendable than what I am creating.
What really is the difference?
To answer that, I will address the question:
For me, music is a pursuit, and includes three critical components:
They really are all tied together. But to address them individually –
I create my music because I am genuinely interested in music of all kinds. I have been fascinated by the process of writing, arranging and performing music for decades. A piece of music, a performance, a recording, elicits a visceral, palpable response. I have witnessed some truly remarkable moments in music, and I have participated in truly memorable moments as well.
Music can make time stand still, or it can transport you directly back to a moment in the past, or the distant future. It can elicit a memory, a feeling, or a mood. Music has been one of my all-time favorite endeavors. It begins with listening, but goes so much deeper into the creative process and performance.
I have always wanted to create music that impacts people like the music that has impacted me in so many ways over the years; to give others a glimpse of the delight music has given me.
One of the things that has compelled me to pursue music has been curiosity: Why does music affect us the way it does? What makes a piece of music impactful? Why does that performance resonate with me?
As an example, in the process of creating a particular saxophone solo section, I spent literally hours listening to a broad variety of saxophone performances, ensembles, and solos. What makes a saxophone sound different than, say a trumpet, trombone, or flute? Why does a keyboard with a sampled saxophone instrument still sound like a keyboard? And that leads to: What makes a ‘good’ saxophone solo – or more accurately – one that I like?
The same thing goes for all the other instruments: woodwinds, brass, strings, percussion, as well as guitar, bass, drums, piano, keys, synthesizers…
And the bottom line – what is it that moves me about this particular instrument? What do I like the most, what do I not like as much?
That translates into: “how can I make this (performance, recording, etc.) have the ‘vibe’ – the feel, the impact, of an actual live performance on acoustic instruments? How can I give the feeling that you are right there in the room as a band, ensemble, or orchestra is performing?"
But in the end, it all comes down to one thing…
Music has been one of my all-time great loves, and continues to this day. And it only gets better over time. After more than half a century, I am still writing, arranging, recording, and performing music.
And I am having more fun than ever.
That is the true gift of music. It continues to fascinate, inspire, amuse, and move me, and never ceases to be fun. The ways in which music delights and fulfills is never-ending.
One song came about because of a drum beat that was taught to me in junior high that still excites me to this day.
One time I heard a weird groove that got stuck in my head. As I ruminated over several days, it morphed and changed and evolved into a whole song.
(That is something human music does that an algorithm cannot do - change, grow, evolve, and take on a life of its own. )
I saw a video clip from an old TV cop show and remembered how much I loved the music from that era. I imagined a whole scenario, and envisioned a complete animated scene in my head, from the thief being exposed, the chase through a crowded city street, to wiping out over a street vendor and the final bust with the cop getting in the last word with a witty remark.
There was a piece of music from Stiffwater that I had always perceived as being orchestral, even though it was a rock instrumental – so I decided to turn it into an actual orchestral piece.
I stumbled across an old recording of myself on acoustic guitar and decided to develop it into a full ensemble piece.
There was In The Mood, a tune from the Big Band era that I grew up playing in jazz ensembles, and which we had worked up for four guitars in Stiffwater during the ‘One That No One Knows’ era. I thought it was a great treatment and deserved to be recorded and preserved.
A fragment of a melody from an obscure old song got stuck in my head, but in a completely different genre. It morphed and evolved into its own song.
Some songs have been stuck in my head for decades, and I finally decided to get them out into the real world.
I have continued to study music, to develop my knowledge, skills, and abilities in all areas of music. And as I do so, my appreciation for music continues to deepen and become more and more fulfilling.
Those are things that no AI prompt can ever replace. No algorithm has an actual interest in what it spits out. No prompt has a genuine curiosity about what it generates. No computer program actually loves what it is doing.
No software program has a song inside of it, never letting go – haunting its thoughts for years or even decades, just begging to be brought out into the real world.
But I do. So I guess that’s the difference.
And I have actual experience. I know what it's like to be in the middle of an award-winning performance with an amazingly talented group of musicians. It is magical.
AI has no actual experience.
And finally, it’s about choice. Every note, every inflection and articulation, was a deliberate choice that I made. I did not let an algorithm make the choices for me. I do not outsource the creative process.
The music was created, not generated.
Creation is what I enjoy about music. I’ll do that myself, thank you. 😉
Music drives me, inspires me and compels me to create; whether it is alone with my guitar, in a room with other musicians, on a stage in front of one or two, a dozen, or a thousand people… or alone in my studio room with my computer and an idea ‘tickling my ear’ that just won’t let go.