How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
If you want a wireless, noise-cancelling pair of over-ear headphones for music, shows and calls, choose Microsoft Surface Headphones 2; if you need a wired, plug-and-play office headset for clear voice calls on Microsoft Teams, choose Amazon Renewed Jabra Evolve 40.
• Microsoft Surface Headphones 2 — biggest strength: wireless Bluetooth 5 freedom with active noise cancellation, touch controls, and up to 20 hours of battery life.
• Microsoft Surface Headphones 2 — biggest trade-off: it's a Bluetooth-first design, so it leans on charging and pairing rather than a simple plug-in connection.
• Amazon Renewed Jabra Evolve 40 — biggest strength: a corded USB-A / 3.5 mm mono headset built for voice, with three-microphone call tech and a visibility-first busylight.
• Amazon Renewed Jabra Evolve 40 — biggest trade-off: it's a renewed unit with wired-only connectivity, passive noise cancellation, and a shorter limited warranty.
• Pick the Surface Headphones 2 if you want one pair for commuting, travel and music as well as meetings.
• Pick the Jabra Evolve 40 if you live at a desk and just want a dependable wired call headset.
The Surface Headphones 2 is a wireless, over-ear pair aimed at people who want one set of headphones to do a lot. It runs Bluetooth 5 and also has a 3.5 mm jack, so you can go cordless the vast majority of the time and still plug in when you want. The headline feature is Omnisonic sound paired with 13 levels of adjustable active noise cancellation — a rare thing to be able to dial in rather than just toggle on or off. If you work in a noisy space or commute, that adjustability matters, because you can decide how much of the outside world you let in.
Battery is the other big story. Microsoft rates it at up to 18.5 hours of music listening or up to 20 hours on a full charge, plus up to 15 hours of voice calling on Microsoft Teams. The five-minute charge that gets you almost an hour of playback is the kind of detail that saves you on the way out the door. Controls are touch-based on the earcups — skip tracks, answer or end calls, and pull up hands-free assistance without hunting for buttons. The over-ear pads are described as breathable and lightweight, which is what you want if you plan to wear them for hours.
Who should buy it: commuters, students, remote workers and travelers who want strong sound, adjustable noise cancellation and real battery life in a single wireless package. Who should skip it: anyone who wants nothing to do with charging or Bluetooth pairing, or who only needs a basic wired mic headset for calls. For desk-only voice work, this is more headphone than you strictly need.
The Amazon Renewed Jabra Evolve 40 is a different animal entirely — a wired, on-ear professional headset built for talking. It connects over USB-A with a 3.5 mm jack option, so there's no pairing, no battery and no charging ritual. You plug it in and it works. Jabra's three-microphone call technology is pitched at cutting background conversation noise on your calls, which is exactly the problem a busy office or home workspace creates. The 40 mm speakers are tuned to handle both calls and music, so it isn't purely a voice device.
The detail I like most here is the busylight. It's designed to be visible from any direction and can be activated automatically or manually, which is a genuinely useful signal in an open-plan office or a shared room — people can see you're on a call before they interrupt you. Comfort is handled with memory foam cushions, and the headset is optimized for Microsoft Teams as a plug-and-play experience, while also working with other unified communications platforms.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for wireless freedom → Microsoft Surface Headphones 2. Bluetooth 5 with touch controls and no cable to snag on your desk.
• Best for battery life → Microsoft Surface Headphones 2. Up to 20 hours on a charge, plus roughly an hour of playback from a five-minute top-up.
• Best for active noise cancellation → Microsoft Surface Headphones 2. 13 adjustable levels of ANC versus the Jabra's passive approach.
• Best for plug-and-play calls → Amazon Renewed Jabra Evolve 40. USB-A connection, no pairing, optimized for Microsoft Teams.
• Best for clear voice pickup in a noisy room → Amazon Renewed Jabra Evolve 40. Three-microphone call tech aimed at cutting background chatter.
• Best for open-plan offices → Amazon Renewed Jabra Evolve 40. The multidirectional busylight tells colleagues you're busy.
• Best for music and media → Microsoft Surface Headphones 2. Omnisonic sound, 20 Hz–20 kHz dynamic drivers and an over-ear fit built for listening.
• Best for a single do-everything pair → Microsoft Surface Headphones 2. It covers calls, music and travel; the Jabra stays at the desk.
In my opinion, the Microsoft Surface Headphones 2 is the pick for most people, because it does more jobs well — wireless listening, adjustable active noise cancellation, long battery life and touch controls in one pair. The Jabra Evolve 40 is the smarter choice only if your world is a desk and a headset that never needs charging or pairing, and if you're comfortable with a renewed unit and its shorter limited warranty. If you want one device to carry between work and life, I'd go Surface. If you want a dedicated wired call headset, go Jabra.
It's primarily wireless over Bluetooth 5, and it also includes a 3.5 mm jack so you can use it wired. The Jabra Evolve 40, by contrast, is wired-only.
Both are built with Teams in mind. The Surface Headphones 2 is rated for up to 15 hours of voice calling on Teams, while the Jabra Evolve 40 is optimized for Teams as a plug-and-play wired experience with a dedicated call-control remote.
It uses passive noise cancellation, not active. The Surface Headphones 2 offers 13 levels of adjustable active noise cancellation, which is a meaningful difference if blocking sound is a priority.
It's been inspected and tested by Amazon-qualified suppliers to work and look like new, and it's covered by a 90-day limited warranty. Microsoft, by comparison, includes a one-year manufacturer warranty on the Surface Headphones 2. Either way, check the current price on Amazon before you decide.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: WIVTAK Earbuds vs ERDU Magnetic Ear Cuff: Open Ear TWS, LORELEI X8 vs LXQFNSG Compatible, Xmenha Red True vs WUNIAK Case, ElloGear OEM Earbuds vs TECKNET Headset: Headphones for All