A full breakdown of the thinking behind both projects, including a candid look at what could be improved, and what this pair shows about designing deliberately for different audiences.
This project was designed for a mixed-ability group during a less formally structured instructional block. With no standards requirement attached and a wide range of student independence levels in the room, the project was built around heavy, explicit scaffolding: a specific list of required facts, exact search-phrase examples (“type this into your search: state bird of ____”), and a dedicated resource link for state symbols. The goal wasn’t just content coverage; it was teaching students how to construct an effective search query, a transferable research skill many hadn’t been taught directly before.
A finished exemplar was built for this project, using Colorado (excluded from the student choice list for that reason) to model exactly what a complete, well-supported slide looks like. The exemplar was deliberately built as a reference model, not a template to copy into, since part of the goal was to let students explore what Google Slides could do rather than fill in a fixed structure. For many students, this was their first real chance to explore the program independently.
One slide in the exemplar, meant to cover “interesting facts about the state’s history” and what the state is known for, is noticeably thinner than the rest. It includes a brief note on Colorado’s mining history and its popularity for outdoor tourism, but doesn’t develop either point further. And the Native American tribes list beside it has no images or context of its own. Since the exemplar was built quickly as a working model rather than a finished showpiece, it fell short of the depth that section was meant to have. A stronger version would expand on what’s already there, with more detail on the mining history, what draws tourists specifically, and 3-5 well-chosen historical facts overall, with images where possible, and the underlying project directions could be revised to explicitly ask for that same depth rather than leaving “history” open to a thin interpretation. A map showing where Colorado’s Native American tribes lived has since been added as a partial fix, alongside this broader note on what a fuller revision would include. Finding an appropriately scaled map for a 4th-grade audience wasn’t straightforward; most available maps are either historically detailed reference materials or oversimplified in ways that risk flattening real history. That search became its own useful teaching moment: research doesn’t always turn up the exact resource you’re looking for, and part of doing it well is deciding what’s close enough, while being honest about that limitation rather than presenting an imperfect source as definitive.
The Earthquakes & Tsunamis Project
This project connects directly to the geology unit in Amplify CKLA 4th grade, the literacy curriculum used in the regular classroom. It was built for a mixed-ability homeroom class, with students' reading levels ranging from a kindergarten/1st-grade to above grade level. Where the State Project leans on heavy scaffolding, this one is built around open research questions: students choose their own event (with teacher approval) from a list of real historical earthquakes and tsunamis, then answer questions like “what was the most destructive force involved” and “is this plate boundary still active today,” rather than filling in a fixed list of facts. Designing an open-inquiry format for a group with that wide a skill range meant building in enough structure to keep the project accessible, without flattening the challenge for students who could push further.
Two things were deliberately built into this project beyond content coverage. First, an information-literacy component: students are pointed toward a specific set of kid-friendly research sites (Ducksters, Time for Kids, and others) instead of Wikipedia, since Wikipedia’s reading level is often a barrier at this age. Second, a paraphrasing requirement: students must write information in their own words and list sources. Paraphrasing, including the term itself, is explicitly taught throughout 4th grade CKLA, so this project gave students a real, applied opportunity to practice a skill they’d already been introduced to, rather than learning it from scratch.
No exemplar was built for this project, unlike the State Project. It’s presented here as directions and a rubric alone, an equally legitimate way to hand off a project once the expectations are clearly spelled out.
These two projects represent two different, equally valid instructional design choices, not one “correct” approach. The State Project shows how to scaffold heavily for a mixed-ability group during a loosely structured block of time, modeling a transferable skill through an exemplar. The Earthquakes project shows how to design more open-ended, standards-connected inquiry for a full class with a wide skill range, embedding information literacy and paraphrasing practice directly into the research process. Read together, they demonstrate the ability to make a deliberate scaffolding decision based on the actual audience and context, rather than defaulting to one approach regardless of who’s in the room.
The underlying process- analyzing an audience, choosing a scaffolding approach deliberately, and building in a way to evaluate whether it worked- is the same process behind The Power of Yet. Only the audience changes.
Michael Parker • K-6 Instructional Design