A denied claim doesn't fix itself. Somebody has to read the remittance, figure out what the payer wants, and push the claim toward payment before a deadline closes the door. In most US billing offices, that somebody is the AR caller. Denial management in AR calling is the part of accounts receivable follow-up that focuses specifically on denied claims: diagnosing why the payer refused payment, confirming the details with the payer, choosing the right fix, and tracking the claim until it is paid or properly closed. Whether the work is done in-house or through outsourced denial management services, the process follows the same logic, and small mistakes at any step can turn a recoverable claim into a write-off. This guide explains how AR callers work denials, what they ask payers, how they choose between a corrected claim, a reopening, and an appeal, and how to measure results.
AR calling is the follow-up side of accounts receivable. After claims are submitted, AR callers check on unpaid and underpaid claims by calling payer representatives, using interactive voice response (IVR) systems, and checking payer portals. Their job is to find out where each claim stands and move it forward.
A typical claim moves through charge entry, coding, claim submission, adjudication, and payment posting. AR calling picks up after submission, when a claim has either gone unanswered for too long or come back with a problem. Most practices sort open claims into aging buckets (0–30, 31–60, 61–90, 91–120, and 120+ days), and AR callers work those buckets based on age, dollar value, and approaching deadlines.
Not every open claim is a denial. Some are simply "no response" claims the payer never received or hasn't processed. Others were paid at the wrong amount. Denials are the subset where the payer processed the claim and refused some or all of the payment.
General AR follow-up asks, "Where is my money?" Denial management asks, "Why did the payer say no, and what will make them say yes?" That second question requires more skill. The caller has to interpret Claim Adjustment Reason Codes (CARCs) and Remittance Advice Remark Codes (RARCs), understand basic coding and payer rules, and know which fix each payer accepts.
Strong denial management also looks forward. A good AR caller doesn't just resolve the claim in front of them. They flag patterns, such as the same authorization denial from the same payer every week, so the front desk or coding team can stop the problem at its source.
The exact workflow varies by practice management system and payer, but most teams follow a sequence like this:
Review the remittance. Pull the ERA or EOB and note the group code (CO, PR, or OA), the CARC, and any RARC. Together they tell you who is responsible and why the line was adjusted.
Check the claim history. Look for prior calls, corrected claims, or appeals already filed so you don't duplicate work or miss a deadline.
Try self-service first. Many payer portals and IVR systems show claim status, denial details, and eligibility.
Call the payer when needed. Calls are worth it when the denial reason is unclear, the portal shows conflicting information, or you need the payer to reprocess a claim.
Confirm the fix. Ask exactly what the payer needs: a corrected claim, medical records, a reopening, or a formal appeal.
Take action and document it. Submit the correction or appeal, then record what was done, when, and the call reference number.
Set a follow-up date. Every worked denial needs a next touch date so it doesn't slip back into the aging buckets unnoticed.
Payer representatives verify identity before they discuss a claim, and an unprepared caller wastes the whole hold time. Have the provider's NPI and Tax ID, the patient's name, date of birth, and member ID, the date of service, billed amount, claim number, and the denial codes from the remittance.
A productive denial call is specific. Useful questions include:
What is the exact denial reason, and does it apply to the full claim or specific lines?
Can the claim be reprocessed over the phone, or does it need a corrected claim or appeal?
If a corrected claim is needed, what should change, and what is the filing deadline?
If an appeal is needed, what is the appeal deadline, the address or fax, and what documentation is required?
Is there a reference number for this call?
Notes should let any teammate pick up the claim without calling again. Record the date, representative's name, call reference number, what the payer said, the action taken, and the follow-up date.
Most denials fall into a handful of patterns. The codes below are standard X12 CARCs; the fixes describe common practice, but payer requirements vary, so always confirm with the specific payer.
A CO-27 denial (expenses incurred after coverage terminated) means the payer shows the patient's coverage ended before the date of service. The caller confirms coverage dates, checks whether the patient has new insurance, and bills the correct payer. A CARC 22 denial (care may be covered by another payer per coordination of benefits) usually means the payer believes another plan is primary. The fix often involves the patient updating their COB information with the plan, then rebilling in the correct order.
CO-197 (precertification/authorization/notification absent) is one of the most frustrating denials because it's usually preventable. The caller checks whether an authorization exists but wasn't on the claim, which can often be fixed with a corrected claim. If none was obtained, some payers allow retro-authorization in limited cases, but many don't, and the claim may become a write-off under the provider's contract.
CO-97 means the payer considers the service included in another service already paid. For Medicare, these denials often trace back to the National Correct Coding Initiative procedure-to-procedure edits, which identify code pairs that shouldn't be reported together. The AR caller reviews whether a modifier such as 59 or XS was appropriate and supported by documentation. If it was, a corrected claim or appeal with records may resolve it. If it wasn't, the denial is valid and should be closed out.
CO-50 means the payer didn't consider the service medically necessary. These rarely get fixed over the phone. The caller confirms the denial reason, checks that the diagnosis codes on the claim match the documentation, and routes the claim for an appeal with clinical records. For Medicare claims, the relevant Local Coverage Determination often lists the covered diagnoses and documentation requirements.
CO-16 (claim lacks information or has billing errors) is usually paired with a RARC that points to the missing element, such as a referring provider NPI. CO-18 (exact duplicate claim) often means the original claim is still processing or was already paid, so the caller checks before resubmitting. CO-29 (time limit for filing has expired) is the hardest to overturn. For Medicare, claims must be filed within 12 months of the date of service, and a timely filing denial isn't appealable unless the provider qualifies for a specific exception. For commercial plans, the caller needs proof of timely submission, such as a clearinghouse acceptance report.
One of the most important judgment calls in AR calling is picking the correct fix. Sending an appeal when a corrected claim would do slows payment, and sending a new claim when the payer wanted a replacement can trigger a duplicate denial.
When the denial results from a fixable billing error, such as a wrong modifier, units, or missing information, a corrected claim is often the fastest route. On professional claims, a replacement claim is typically identified with frequency code 7 and the original claim number, while code 8 voids a claim. Commercial payers set their own corrected-claim rules and deadlines, so check each payer's policy.
Medicare handles simple errors differently. Under the Medicare Claims Processing Manual, Chapter 34, clerical errors such as math mistakes or incorrect data entry are corrected through a reopening rather than an appeal. A reopening can generally be requested within one year of the initial determination for any reason. Many Medicare Administrative Contractors accept telephone reopenings for minor fixes like units, dates of service, or certain modifiers, but CMS notes that phone reopenings aren't appropriate for medical necessity denials or reviews that require clinical records.
When the payer's decision itself is disputed, an appeal is the right path. For Medicare Part A and Part B, the first level of appeal is a redetermination by the Medicare Administrative Contractor, which must be filed within 120 days of receiving the initial determination. A strong appeal letter identifies the claim, states clearly why the denial is wrong, cites the payer policy or coding guideline that supports payment, and attaches the relevant records. Commercial and Medicare Advantage appeal windows are set by the plan, so the caller should confirm the deadline on every call.
A hard denial, such as a valid timely filing denial or a non-covered service with no patient waiver on file, may need to be adjusted off under the provider's contract. The key is documenting why, using the correct adjustment code, so the write-off shows up in denial reports rather than disappearing into a generic bucket.
AR callers rarely have time to work every claim in order. Effective teams sort their worklist using a few simple rules:
Deadline first. Claims close to an appeal or timely filing deadline go to the top, regardless of dollar value.
Dollar value next. A $4,000 surgical denial deserves attention before a $35 office visit, as long as neither deadline is at risk.
Winnability. Claims with a clear fix, like a missing modifier, should be resolved quickly instead of sitting behind complex appeals.
Here is a simple hypothetical example. An AR caller starts the day with three denials: a $2,800 knee arthroscopy denied CO-197 with an appeal deadline in 10 days, a $1,900 MRI denied CO-50 with 90 days left, and twelve $120 office visits denied CO-16 for the same missing referring provider NPI. A sensible order is the arthroscopy first because of the deadline, then the twelve office visits because one corrected batch fixes $1,440 at once, then the MRI appeal, which needs clinical records and time.
AR callers discuss protected health information constantly, so privacy rules matter. Under HIPAA, providers may share patient information with health plans for payment purposes, but the Privacy Rule's minimum necessary standard still applies to those disclosures. The HHS guidance on uses and disclosures for treatment, payment, and health care operations explains how payment disclosures work.
In practice, that means sharing only what the representative needs to identify and resolve the claim, verifying that you're speaking with the payer before discussing details, and keeping call notes inside the practice management system rather than on personal devices or loose paper. Offshore or outsourced AR teams should work under a business associate agreement with the practice.
Denial management in AR calling should be judged by outcomes, not activity. These metrics tell you much more:
Denial resolution rate: the share of denied claims that end up paid.
Appeal overturn rate: the share of appealed claims the payer reverses.
Average days to resolve a denial: how long it takes from denial to final outcome.
AR over 90 or 120 days: whether denied claims are aging past the point of easy recovery.
Repeat denial rate: how often the same reason code from the same payer comes back.
The last metric is where denial management connects to prevention. If AR callers keep seeing CO-197 from one commercial plan, the fix belongs at scheduling, not on the phone. Practices that don't have the staff to run both the daily call queue and the root-cause analysis sometimes work with an outside team. Dr Biller RCM is one example of a revenue cycle firm that handles AR follow-up and denial tracking for practices, though many groups do this successfully in-house with a dedicated denials lead and clear reporting.
An AR caller reviews denied claims, contacts payers by phone or portal to confirm the denial reason, and takes the right corrective action. That action might be a corrected claim, a Medicare reopening, or a formal appeal, followed by documented follow-up until the claim is resolved.
Not exactly. AR calling covers all unpaid and underpaid claims, including claims with no response from the payer, while denial management focuses specifically on claims the payer processed and refused. In many billing offices the same team handles both.
A call reference number is an identifier the payer representative assigns to your call. It proves what the payer told you and when, which is valuable if the payer fails to reprocess a claim or if you need to support an appeal later.
It depends on the payer. For Medicare Part A and Part B, a redetermination must be requested within 120 days of receiving the initial determination. Commercial and Medicare Advantage plans set their own deadlines, so confirm the window for each claim.
Sometimes. Some payers will reprocess a claim during the call, and many Medicare contractors accept telephone reopenings for minor clerical errors. Medical necessity denials and issues needing clinical records generally require a written appeal.
Denial management in AR calling is detailed, deadline-driven work. AR callers have to read remittance codes accurately, prepare before every payer call, choose between a corrected claim, reopening, or appeal, and document each step so nothing is lost. The practices that recover the most revenue pair that daily follow-up with prioritization and a feedback loop that stops repeat denials at the front end. If your team is stretched thin or denials are aging faster than they're being resolved, reviewing your workflow against the steps in this guide is a practical first move, and partnering with a provider of experienced Medical Billing Services can help you build the capacity and reporting to keep denied claims moving toward payment.