Mammals are one of the most exciting taxa, but often most elusive groups of animals found in the UK. Many people do not often, or ever, get to see mammals for themselves. To try and monitor mammals in the UK our research group is taking a slightly alternative approach by looking for mammals in the water. By taking water samples we are hoping to extract DNA that has been left behind by mammals (which is defined as environmental DNA - eDNA) in our lab back at the university which we can later match to specific species.
This flowchart shows how we collect DNA from the water in bottles. We then extract the DNA back at the lab and amplify it. Lastly, we can identify species with their unique 'barcode'. This is a very simplified version of the steps we take.
To research and monitor mammals methods such as camera traps, visual surveys and other types of humane traps are generally used to gather information on their communities. The main disadvantage with camera traps is that they are time and cost consuming with a limited photographic range. Ideally eDNA will be able to tell us about an entire community from one bottle of water, including rare or elusive species which can be missed by camera traps. Whilst the process is still being defined, it is a very exciting new field.
With this in mind the McDevitt Lab research group has now been exploring the use of eDNA in detecting mammal species in the Scottish Highlands. In this study we are trying to detect water voles, Arvicola amphibius, a species that is under threat from the invasive american mink, Neovison vison, and habitat loss.
In December of 2019 we (Jenna and Polly) drove 8 hours up to a northern region of Scotland, called Assynt, to spend the next 5 days gathering over 75 litres of river water to try and build an idea of the community of mammals living in the highland.
On the first day we met up with Emma Bryce from the University of Aberdeen. For over 20 years data on water vole metapopulations has been collected by employing camera, live traps and conducting latrine surveys. To make this study comparable we were going to be sampling at 30 camera trap locations.
At each site we took pH levels, temperature and 5 water samples. As this is a temporal study the pH and temperature levels are important to see if the changes have any effect on species detection.
Each day we prepared all of our equipment and labelled our sample collection bottles before we set off into the field. On arrival at each site one person would take the water samples, 2 upstream from the camera, 1 at the camera and 2 downstream, whilst the other person would record the time, date, pH and temperature. We had to be careful to prevent any contamination from site to site, wearing new sterile gloves at each sampling point and before using any equipment. We also had to ensure we never came in contact with the water, only our gloved hand and bottle where allowed to to prevent contamination.
At the end of each day we would spend the next few hours filtering each bottle of water. To do this we would pour part of the bottled river water in to a 60ml syringe with a filter on the end and push the water through. A membrane in the filter collects all the DNA whilst letting the rest of the water pass through, the membrane is the only part we will need for our DNA extractions back in the lab. This was the most exhausting part of the trip as we realised that as there were only two of us collecting all of the samples and filtering it would take us a lot longer than the previous field trip in the summer. We powered through during the days getting as many samples as we could and then stayed up till late getting through all the filtering.
We stored our samples in a cool box in the fridge for preservation until we got back to the University where they were then frozen.
"This was my second time eDNA sampling in Assynt, i had previously been the summer before training with Naiara and Sam from our research team. It was completely different this time around, I was teaching Jenna the sampling protocol and the landscape had changed drastically. Instead of bright green hills and warm weather it was brown, and grey and miserably cold. Everyday it rained and rained, and the winds where painfully fast. Luckily I love a challenge and the outdoors and really enjoyed my week sampling with Jenna. I was even lucky enough to spend my birthday here.
The highlands were absolutely beautiful and I’m excited to see what species we are able to detect."
Polly taking water samples next to one of the camera traps
Jenna taking a pH reading from one of the sampling points
"On the second day of our fieldwork we had a little hiccup with our GPS unexpectedly having a low battery about halfway through the day. We still had five sample points to collect and we wouldn’t be able to navigate without the GPS so we frantically found what direction each GPS point was in and ran as fast as we could to the next sampling point whilst turning the GPS off to save battery. Bearing in mind the weather was treacherous and we couldn’t feel our toes, running across the highlands didn’t seem like a bad idea. Miraculously we managed to find the remaining five points without our GPS losing full battery!
Our trip to Assynt was great, I carried out my first eDNA sampling, visited Scotland for the first time, learnt the ins and outs of the sampling technique and got the chance to explore the Scottish highlands. The best bit about out research is conducting the field work and getting hands on experience in the species habitat."
Although we did not see any voles almost every day we had deer right outside our window
Polly and Jenna highland selfie
One of the camera traps set up by the river
After the Christmas break we were back in the eDNA lab to start the long process of DNA extractions. Although we managed to finish all the DNA extraction, by the time we were able to move on to the next step towards species identification the Covid-19 outbreak happened so all work has halted. As soon as it is safe to return to our labs and Scotland work will be continued on this project.
At the end of this study, alongside other eDNA mammal studies currently being conducted within this research group, we would like to validate eDNA as a reliable detection method for different mammal species. Specifically we want to target elusive and invasive species that may be missed by camera traps. We have two more sampling seasons to conduct so hold this space to see any updates from the field and lab from Holly Broadhurst.
Here it a little video of the field conditions we had in December, we can't wait for the next sampling in the summer.
Polly Bolton | MRes Student | @PollyLBolton Jenna Lavin | MRes Student | @JennaLavin