How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-24 · 7 min read · Independent comparison
• McCormick Air Fryer Buffalo — biggest strength: A seasoning blend developed specifically for air fryers, built around Frank's RedHot heat, so Buffalo wings and Buffalo fries come out crisp with far less oil than deep-frying.
• McCormick Air Fryer Buffalo — biggest trade-off: It's a consumable. You're buying flavor, not equipment, and it only works if you already own an air fryer (or are willing to use the oven method the package mentions).
• P&P CHEF 15.4 — biggest strength: Food-grade stainless steel with no chemical coating, a mesh design that circulates air 360 degrees, and 2-inch raised feet that let grease drip away — a durable, dishwasher-safe piece of gear.
• P&P CHEF 15.4 — biggest trade-off: It's sized at 15.4 x 11.4 inches for regular ovens, so it's not a countertop air fryer accessory, and it does nothing for flavor on its own.
• Who each is for: McCormick for anyone who already has an air fryer and wants game-day Buffalo wings fast; P&P CHEF for anyone with a standard oven who wants crispy wings without buying a whole new appliance.
This is a seasoning mix, and that framing matters. McCormick developed this line specifically for air fryers, and the Buffalo version leans on Frank's RedHot for its heat. The pitch is straightforward: wings and fries with the crunch you'd expect from deep-frying, but with less oil, less time, and less cleanup. The ingredient list is built on McCormick spices like garlic powder and paprika, with no artificial flavors.
The practical appeal is speed and mess. Deep-frying wings means a pot of oil, a thermometer, splatter, and a disposal problem afterward. A seasoning packet plus an air fryer skips all of that. The description also notes recipes are printed on the package, which matters if you've never seasoned wings before and don't want to guess at ratios.
Who should buy it: anyone who already owns an air fryer and wants Buffalo wings for a game-day spread or a weeknight dinner without hauling out the fryer. It's also a reasonable pick if you want a shelf-stable seasoning to keep on hand in a multi-pack format so you're not re-buying every time wings come up.
P&P CHEF 15.4: Who It's For
The P&P CHEF 15.4 is a completely different animal: a 15.4 x 11.4 inch stainless steel air fryer basket designed to sit inside a regular oven. No chemical coating, food-grade stainless, polished smooth with no burrs. That last point matters more than it sounds — bare metal racks with sharp edges are a genuine annoyance, and this one is finished for comfortable handling.
The design details are where it earns its place. The mesh basket and raised feet promote 360-degree air and heat circulation, which means you don't have to flip food partway through. The 2-inch-high feet lift the rack so grease drips off, and the fine wire grid is sized to let air through without food falling out. Four thicker wires reinforce the bottom so heavier items — a whole chicken, say — don't sag the grid. There's a 1.2-inch deep wall to hold more food, a widened top frame for grip, and two 180-degree rotatable handles that fold out of the way when you're not carrying it. Stable feet keep it from wobbling on a flat surface.
It's dishwasher safe, and the mirror finish reduces sticking, so cleanup after a wing night isn't a scrubbing session. It's rated for most regular ovens and the brand lists wings, fried chicken, bacon, meat, vegetables, cookies, and even washing produce as uses.
Who should buy it: anyone with a standard oven who wants crisp, browned exteriors on chicken wings without buying a countertop air fryer. It's also a good fit for larger batches — the size handles a family gathering or party spread better than a small countertop basket. And because it's stainless steel with no coating, it's the pick if you're avoiding nonstick surfaces in your kitchen.
Who should skip it: countertop-only cooks. If your kitchen is built around a small air fryer, this rack won't fit inside it. And if you want flavor out of the box, this gives you none — it's a tool, not a seasoning.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for flavor with zero prep → McCormick Air Fryer Buffalo. The Frank's RedHot base and McCormick spice blend do the work; you just apply and cook.
• Best for less oil and less cleanup → both, for different reasons. McCormick avoids the oil vat; P&P CHEF's drip design and dishwasher-safe build avoid the scrubbing.
• Best for large batches → P&P CHEF 15.4. A 15.4 x 11.4 inch rack holds far more than a typical countertop air fryer basket.
• Best for people who already own an air fryer → McCormick Air Fryer Buffalo. It's designed for exactly that appliance.
• Best for people without an air fryer → P&P CHEF 15.4. It turns your existing oven into the air-frying setup.
• Best for durability and long-term use → P&P CHEF 15.4. Heavy-duty stainless steel with no coating to wear off.
• Best for stocking the pantry → McCormick Air Fryer Buffalo. It's a shelf-stable multi-pack you can keep on hand.
If I had to pick one, I'd pick based on what's missing from your kitchen. If you own an air fryer and your goal is Buffalo wings that taste like Buffalo wings without a deep-fryer mess, McCormick Air Fryer Buffalo is the more direct answer — it solves the flavor problem that a bare rack can't. But if you don't own an air fryer and you're not planning to buy one, the P&P CHEF 15.4 is the more useful purchase, because it's a permanent piece of equipment that makes crispy wings possible in a regular oven and won't run out. In my opinion, the rack is the better long-term buy and the seasoning is the better quick win — and for most people reading this with wings on the mind, the rack outlasts the packet.
how to air fryer chicken wings
Pat the wings dry, season them, and arrange them in a single layer with space between each piece. In an air fryer, cook at a high temperature and shake the basket partway through; the McCormick Buffalo mix is formulated for this method and the package includes recipes. If you're using a regular oven, set the P&P CHEF 15.4 rack on a sheet pan and let the mesh circulate air around the wings so you don't have to flip them.
how to air fryer chicken wings crispy
Crispiness comes from dry surfaces and airflow. Dry the wings thoroughly before seasoning, don't crowd them, and use a setup where hot air can move all the way around each piece. That's exactly what the P&P CHEF 15.4's mesh basket and 2-inch raised feet are designed to do, and it's also why McCormick built its mix for air fryers — the appliance's circulating heat plus a light oil coating gets you a browned exterior without deep-frying.
how to air fryer chicken wings in the oven
You can get air-fryer-style results in a standard oven by using a mesh rack that lifts food off the pan so heat and air reach the underside. The P&P CHEF 15.4 is sized at 15.4 x 11.4 inches for most regular ovens, and its raised feet let grease drip away instead of pooling. If you don't have a rack, the McCormick Buffalo mix notes that its seasoning can also be used in the oven.
how to air fry chicken wings from frozen
Cook from frozen at a slightly lower temperature first so the inside thaws and cooks through, then raise the heat at the end to crisp the skin. Whatever you use, keep the wings in a single layer with room around them — the P&P CHEF 15.4's fine wire grid is spaced so food won't fall through while still allowing airflow, which helps frozen wings cook evenly without flipping.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: Turbokey 6.5 vs P&P CHEF Round Cooking Rack: Air Fryer, Plum chef Multifunctional Convection Toaster vs Beelicious Pro 28QT, P&P CHEF 7.5 vs LAKUMIQI 2: Air Fryer Steak