2025-2026
Questions from Past Years
1. I met a resident of Mirkwood who said "I am an elf or I am sane". Exactly what type was he?
A: The statement is either true or false. If it is false, then he is neither an elf nor sane. So he must be an insane man. But then the statement must be true. This is a contradiction so the statement is true. In that case, he is either an elf or he is sane. If he is not an elf, then he must be a sane man. But sane men do not tell the truth, so he must be an elf. In that case, he must be a sane elf.
2. Another resident said, "I am not a sane elf". What type was he?
A: The statement is either true or false. If it is false, then he is either an insane elf or a sane man. In either case, the statement is true. This is a contradiction. Therefore, the statement is true. Hence, he must be an insane man.
3. Another resident said, "I am an insane elf". Is he the same type as the previous resident?
A: Again, the statement is either true or false. If the statement is true, then he would be an insane elf. But then the statement would be false. This is a contradiction. So the statement must be false. If it is false, then he is one of (sane elf/sane man/insane man). If he is a sane elf or an insane man, then the statement could not be false, so he must be a sane man.
4. I once asked a resident, "Are you an insane man?". He answered "Yes" or "No" and I knew what he was. What was he?
A: A sane elf would have answered "No" to the question and all other types would have said "Yes". If he had said "Yes", then I would not know what he was. Since I knew what he was, he must have answered "No". So he was a sane elf.
5. I once met a resident of Mirkwood who said "I am a man." Can it be inferred whether he is an elf or a man? Can it be inferred whether he is sane or not?
A: A sane elf would not say that he is a vampire, and a sane man would lie about him being a man. Therefore, the resident is insane. However, we cannot determine whether he is an insane elf or an insane man.
1. I asked a resident of Mirkwood if Sauron was alive or dead. He said, "If I am an elf, then Sauron is still alive." Could it be determined if Sauron is alive?
A: No, it cannot. If he is an insane vampire, then the statement is true. Since he is not an elf, it is vacuously true, so the statement "Sauron is still alive" could be either true or false.
2. Suppose a resident said, "If I am either a sane elf or an insane man, then Sauron is still alive." Could it be determined if Sauron is alive?
A: Yes, it can be determined if Sauron is still alive. If he is sane elf, then the statement is true so Sauron is alive. If he is an insane elf, then the statement is false. The only way this is possible is if Sauron is dead. If he is a sane man, once again the statement is false so Sauron is dead. If he is an insane man, then the statement is true, so Sauron is alive.
3. Can I ask a single question and find out from a resident of Mirkwood whether or not he is an elf?
A: Ask him "Are you sane?". If the answer is "Yes", then he is an elf. If he answers "No", then he is a man.
4. Can I ask a single question and find out from a resident of Mirkwood whether or not he is sane?
A: Ask him "Are you an elf?". A sane resident will say "Yes" (regardless of whether he is an elf or a man), and an insane resident will say "No".
5. Can I ask a single question and find out from a resident of Mirkwood if Sauron is still alive?
A: There are many such questions. For instance, you could ask "Is the statement 'You are a sane elf or an insane man' equivalent to the statement 'Sauron is alive'?"
If the answer is "Yes", then Sauron is alive. If it is "No", then Sauron is dead.
Explanation:
If the answer is "Yes", consider the following possibilities:
a) If he is a sane elf, then Sauron is alive.
b) If he is an insane elf, then the two statements are not equivalent. Since he is neither a sane elf nor an insane human, the first statement is false. Therefore, Sauron must be alive.
c) If he is a sane man, then the two statements are not equivalent. As in (b), Sauron must be alive.
d) If he is an insane man, then the two statements are equivalent, so Sauron is alive.
If the answer is "No", consider the following possibilities:
a) If he is a sane elf, then the two statements are not equivalent. Since he is a sane elf, the first statement is true. So Sauron must be dead.
b) If he is an insane elf, then the two statements are equivalent. Since he is neither a sane elf nor an insane human, the first statement is false. Therefore, Sauron is dead.
c) If he is a sane man, then the two statements are equivalent. Again, this means that Sauron is dead.
d) If he is an insane man, then the two statements are not equivalent. Again, this means that Sauron is dead.
Question 1
S S Hanuram Vikash 22272
Bhumika Upadhyay 22080
Question 2
Bhumika Upadhyay 22080 solved 2A and 2B correctly.
Question 3
Almost to the right answer.
Hrishit Gupta 22152
Ujjivan Mitra 230405
Correct answer
Soumyadeep Gope 22329