How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-24 · 6 min read · Independent comparison
• Makidar's biggest strength: a copper-colored non-stick crisper tray and basket that needs no butter, oil or spray and lets air move around the food for crisp results without flipping.
• Makidar's biggest trade-off: it's one 18 x 13 inch unit with a non-stick coating, so you're relying on that coating holding up over time and you get a single footprint rather than a nesting set.
• Zquilabon's biggest strength: two complete basket-and-base sets in 430 stainless steel, with raised feet that hold food above the tray so fat and moisture drain away.
• Zquilabon's biggest trade-off: no non-stick surface — stainless needs a wipe or a wash to release stuck-on residue, and the set is smaller in footprint than a full sheet tray.
• Pick Makidar if you mostly roast, bake and crisp on a large flat surface and hate scrubbing.
• Pick Zquilabon if you drain, filter, rinse and cool as often as you cook, and want one set that does all four.
Makidar's tray is built around one idea: cook without adding fat and without babysitting the food. The crisper tray and basket combination is designed so air circulates around whatever you're cooking — fries, chicken, vegetables, even cookies — and the result is meant to come out crisp without you turning anything halfway through. The surface is fully non-stick, so the pitch is no butter, no oil, no cooking spray at all. If you've ever wrestled a stuck chicken thigh off a bare pan, that's the problem this tray is aimed at.
The second thing it does is catch mess. The tray is designed to collect crumbs, flakes, drips and splatters, which matters more than it sounds if you roast often. It's dishwasher safe and oven safe up to 536°F, so it can go from a hot oven to the dishwasher without a special handling ritual. The 18 x 13 inch size is the real story here — that's a genuinely large working surface, big enough for a full batch of fries or a tray of vegetables for a family rather than a single portion. At 1.3 pounds it's light enough to move around one-handed.
Who should buy it: anyone who wants a big, flat, non-stick surface for oven roasting and air-crisp style cooking, and who values easy cleanup over everything else. Who should skip it: if you specifically want stainless steel because you don't trust non-stick coatings, or if you need a draining or filtering function — this tray collects drips, it doesn't separate food from them. A single 18 x 13 inch tray also takes up real cabinet space.
Zquilabon takes the opposite approach. Instead of one big non-stick surface, you get two nested sets — a large 10.23-inch and a medium 9.45-inch — each made of a dual-handled mesh basket sitting inside a matching deep base pan. The whole thing is 430 stainless steel, chosen for high-temperature tolerance and corrosion resistance, and it's dishwasher safe and oven friendly. The overall unit measures about 10.2 inches long, 3.3 inches wide and 10.8 inches high, and you're getting four pieces in the box: two stainless trays and two filter screens.
The design detail that actually matters is the three raised feet on the mesh basket. They physically lift your food off the collection tray below, so oil, fat and moisture drip down and away instead of pooling under what you're cooking. That's the difference between crisp food and soggy food, and it's the reason this set works as an air fryer and convection oven accessory rather than just a pan. The mesh also acts as an oil filter tray, a cooling rack for baked goods, and a colander for rinsing fruit and vegetables — morning prep to evening cooking with the same two pieces.
Handling is clearly thought through: permanently attached dual handles on the mesh pan give you a secure grip moving from counter to table, edges are smooth and burr-free, and the construction is light enough to carry outside. That makes it a genuinely good fit for barbecues, patio grilling and picnics, not just the kitchen. When you're done, the two sets nest together to save cabinet space.
Who should buy it: anyone who drains, filters, rinses and cools regularly, wants stainless instead of a coating, and likes the idea of a set that covers several jobs. Who should skip it: if you want one large flat surface for baking cookies or a big tray of vegetables, the mesh baskets won't give you that, and stainless will never be as effortlessly release-friendly as a non-stick coating.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for draining fat away from food → Zquilabon Stainless Steel Air. The raised feet hold food above the base pan so grease and moisture drip off instead of soaking back in.
• Best for a large flat baking surface → Makidar. 18 x 13 inches versus a 10.23-inch and a 9.45-inch basket.
• Best for multi-use versatility → Zquilabon. Oil filter, cooling rack and colander in one set, plus it's rated for air fryers, convection ovens and outdoor grilling.
• Best for coating-free durability → Zquilabon. 430 stainless steel with corrosion resistance and no non-stick layer to wear.
• Best for high-heat oven work → Makidar, which is rated oven safe up to 536°F if you need that ceiling.
• Best for small kitchens → Zquilabon. The two sets nest together for storage; Makidar's single large tray doesn't collapse.
• Best for easy cleanup → Makidar. Non-stick plus dishwasher safe means crumbs and splatter wipe out fast.
In my opinion, the right pick comes down to whether you're a baker-roaster or a drainer-rinser. If most of your cooking is trays of vegetables, fries, chicken and cookies, and you want the least possible scrubbing, I'd buy the Makidar Non-Stick Baking Tray — the size and the non-stick surface do exactly what that kind of cooking needs. If your kitchen runs on draining, filtering, rinsing and cooling, and you'd rather own stainless than a coating, I'd buy the Zquilabon Stainless Steel Air set instead. Both are honest tools for different jobs; the Zquilabon covers more tasks, the Makidar covers one task very well.
FAQ
Yes. It's made from 430 stainless steel with high-temperature tolerance and corrosion resistance, and it's listed as dishwasher safe and oven friendly.
A non-stick tray gives you a large flat surface that releases food easily. A stainless mesh set lifts food on raised feet so fat and liquid drain away, and it doubles as a filter, rack and colander.
The Zquilabon set nests together for compact storage, which helps if cabinet space is tight. The Makidar tray is one large 18 x 13 inch piece that won't collapse down. If price matters to you, check the current price on Amazon for each before deciding.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: Boxiki Kitchen Non-Stick Steel 6 vs EUSOAR Black Cupcake Liners, jojofuny 1pc vs Amosfun Stainless Steel Air: Air Fryer, DOITOOL Stainless Steel Air vs Grilldent Rotisserie Meat Forks