Second Stage
Off Broadway | 15 January 2008 (Final Dress Rehearsal)
Brian d'Arcy James (Dan), Alice Ripley (Diana), Aaron Tveit (Gabe), Jennifer Damiano (Natalie), Adam Chanler-Berat (Henry)
Note: Incomplete, Ends after The Break.
Off Broadway | 16 January 2008 (First Preview)
Brian d'Arcy James (Dan), Alice Ripley (Diana), Aaron Tveit (Gabe), Jennifer Damiano (Natalie), Adam Chanler-Berat (Henry), Asa Somers (Dr. Madden/Dr. Fine)
Off Broadway | 17 January 2008 (Soundboard, 10 tracks only)
Alice Ripley (Diana), Brian D'Arcy James (Dan), Jenn Damiano (Natalie), Aaron Tveit (Gabriel), Asa Somers (Dr. Madden), Adam Chanler-Berat (Henry)
Off Broadway | 19 January 2008
Alice Ripley (Diana), Brian D'Arcy James (Dan), Aaron Tveit (Gabe), Jennifer Damiano (Natalie), Adam Chanler-Berat (Henry), Asa Somers (Dr. Fine/Dr. Madden)
Off Broadway | 2 February 2008 Evening
Alice Ripley (Diana), Brian D'Arcy James (Dan), Aaron Tveit (Gabe), Morgan Weed (u/s Natalie), Adam Chanler-Berat (Henry), Louis Hobson (Dr. Fine/Dr. Madden)
Off-Broadway | 8 March 2008 (Matinee)
Alice Ripley (Diana), Brian D'Arcy James (Dan), Aaron Tveit (Gabe), Jennifer Damiano (Natalie), Adam Chanler-Berat (Henry), Asa Somers (Dr. Fine/Dr. Madden)
Arena Stage
Arena Stage | 21 November 2008
Alice Ripley (Diana Goodman), J. Robert Spencer (Dan Goodman), Jennifer Damiano (Natalie Goodman), Aaron Tveit (Gabriel Goodman), Adam Chanler-Berat (Henry), Louis Hobson (Dr. Fine/Dr. Madden)
Arena Stage | 26 November 2008
Alice Ripley (Diana), J. Robert Spencer (Dan), Aaron Tveit (Gabe), Jennifer Damiano (Natalie), Adam Chanler-Berat (Henry), Louis Hobson (Dr. Madden/Dr. Fine)
Arena Stage | 27 December 2008
Alice Ripley (Diana), J. Robert Spencer (Dan), Aaron Tveit (Gabe), Jennifer Damiano (Natalie), Adam Chanler Berat (Henry), Michael Berry (u/s Dr. Fine/Dr. Madden)
Arena Stage | 28 December 2008
Alice Ripley (Diana), J. Robert Spencer (Dan), Jennifer Damiano (Natalie), Aaron Tveit (Gabe), Adam Chanler-Berat (Henry), Michael Berry (u/s Dr. Madden/Dr. Fine)
Arena Stage | 4 January 2009 Matinee
Alice Ripley (Diana Goodman), J. Robert Spencer (Dan Goodman), Jennifer Damiano (Natalie Goodman), Timothy Young (u/s Gabriel Goodman), Adam Chanler-Berat (Henry), Louis Hobson (Dr. Fine/Dr. Madden)
Arena Stage | 10 January 2009
Alice Ripley (Diana), J. Robert Spencer (Dan), Jennifer Damiano (Natalie), Timothy Young (u/s Gabe), Adam Chanler-Berat (Henry), Louis Hobson (Dr. Madden/Dr. Fine)
Arena Stage | 18 January 2009 (Matinee, Final Performance)
Alice Ripley (Diana), J. Robert Spencer (Dan), Aaron Tveit (Gabe), Jennifer Damiano (Natalie), Adam Chanler-Berat (Henry), Louis Hobson (Dr. Fine/Dr. Madden)
Broadway
Broadway | 27 March 2009 (First Preview)
Alice Ripley (Diana), J. Robert Spencer (Dan), Aaron Tveit (Gabe), Jennifer Damiano (Natalie), Adam Chanler-Berat (Henry), Louis Hobson (Dr. Madden/Dr. Fine)
Broadway | 5 April 2009
Alice Ripley (Diana), J. Robert Spencer (Dan), Aaron Tveit (Gabe), Jennifer Damiano (Natalie), Adam Chanler-Berat (Henry), Louis Hobson (Dr. Madden/Dr. Fine)
Broadway | 10 April 2009
Alice Ripley (Diana), J. Robert Spencer (Dan), Aaron Tveit (Gabe), Jennifer Damiano (Natalie), Adam Chanler-Berat (Henry), Louis Hobson (Dr. Madden/Dr. Fine)
Broadway | 6 June 2009 Evening
Alice Ripley (Diana), J. Robert Spencer (Dan), Aaron Tveit (Gabe), Jennifer Damiano (Natalie), Adam Chanler-Berat (Henry), Louis Hobson (Dr. Madden/Dr. Fine)
Broadway | 25 June 2009
Alice Ripley (Diana), J. Robert Spencer (Dan), Meghann Fahy (u/s Natalie), Kyle Dean Massey (temporary Gabe), Adam Chanler-Berat (Henry), Louis Hobson (Dr. Madden/Dr. Fine)
Broadway | 28 June 2009
Alice Ripley (Diana), J. Robert Spencer (Dan), Tim Young (u/s Gabe), Jennifer Damiano/Meghann Fahy (Natalie/u/s Natalie), Adam Chanler Berat (Henry), Louis Hobson (Dr. Madden/Dr. Fine)
Broadway | 29 August 2009
Alice Ripley, J. Robert Spencer, Kyle Dean Massey (t/r Gabe), Meghann Fahy (u/s Natalie), Adam Chanler-Berat, Louis Hobson
Broadway | 1 September 2009
Alice Ripley (Diana), J. Robert Spencer (Dan), Jennifer Damiano (Natalie), Tim Young (Henry u/s), Kyle Dean Massey (Gabe t/r), Louis Hobson (Dr. Madden/Dr. Fine)
Broadway | 27 September 2009 Evening
Alice Ripley (Diana), J. Robert Spencer (Dan) - 1st Act, Michael Berry (u/s Dan) - 2nd Act, Aaron Tveit (Gabe), Jennifer Damiano (Natalie), Adam Chanler-Berat (Henry), Louis Hobson (Dr. Madden/Dr. Fine)
Broadway | 6 December 2009
Alice Ripley (Diana), Michael Berry (u/s Dan), Jennifer Damiano (Natalie), Tim Young (u/s Gabe), Adam Chanler-Berat (Henry), Louis Hobson (Dr. Madden/Dr. Fine)
Broadway | 3 January 2010
Alice Ripley (Diana), J Robert Spencer (Dan), Aaron Tveit (Gabe), Jennifer Damiano (Natalie), Adam Chanler-Berat (Henry), Louis Hobson (Dr. Madden)
Note: Aaron Tveit's final performance
Broadway | 24 January 2010 Evening
Jessica Phillips (u/s Diana), J. Robert Spencer (Dan), Kyle Dean Massey (Gabe), Jennifer Damiano (Natalie), Adam Chanler-Berat (Henry), Louis Hobson (Dr. Madden/Dr. Fine)
Broadway | 25 January 2010 Evening
Jessica Phillips (Diana u/s), J. Robert Spencer (Dan), Kyle Dean Massey (Gabe), Jennifer Damiano (Natalie), Adam Chanler-Berat (Henry), Louis Hobson (Dr. Fine/Dr. Madden)
Broadway | 19 February 2010
Sarah Uriarte-Berry (u/s Diana), Michael Berry (u/s Dan), Jennifer Damiano (Natalie), Kyle Dean Massey (Gabe), Adam Chanler-Berat (Henry), Louis Hobson (Dr. Fine/Dr.Madden)
Tour
Regional
Pioneer Theatre | 1 October 2011 Evening
Judy McLane (Diana), Jonathan Rayson (Dan), Ephie Aardema (Natalie), Alex Brightman (Henry), Matt Dengler (Gabe), Ben Crawford (Dr. Fine/Dr. Madden)
Weston Playhouse | 13 July 2013
Heidi Blickenstaff (Diana), Aaron Ramey (Dan), Margo Seibert (Natalie), Etai Benshlomo (Henry), Dan DeLuca (Gabe), David Ayers (Dr. Fine/Dr. Madden)
Weston Playhouse | 17 July 2013 Matinee (magicshowsandmiracles master)
Heidi Blickenstaff (Diana), Aaron Ramey (Dan), Margo Seibert (Natalie), Etai Benshlomo (Henry), Dan DeLuca (Gabe), David Ayers (Dr. Fine/Dr. Madden)
Weston Playhouse | 24 July 2013 Matinee (magicshowsandmiracles master)
Heidi Blickenstaff (Diana), Aaron Ramey (Dan), Margo Seibert (Natalie), Etai Benshlomo (Henry), Dan DeLuca (Gabe), David Ayers (Dr. Fine/Dr. Madden)
La Mirada | 2 June 2013
Keith A. Bearden (Dr. Fine/Dr. Madden), Eddie Egan (Gabe), Tessa Grady (Natalie), Bets Malone (Diana), Alex Mendoza (Henry), Robert J Townsend (Dan).
Tom Kitt & Friends | 14 July 2015 Evening
Jennifer Damiano, Alice Ripley, Louis Hobson, Amy Spanger, Joe Cassaidy, Ben Schrader, Jonathan Dokuchitz and Adrienne Warren
Note: Missing some of the beginning.
Hartford | 1 April 2017 (euphorianger master)
Christiane Noll (Diana), David Harris (Dan), Maya Keleher (Natalie), John Cardoza (Gabe), Nick Sacks (Henry), J.D. Daw (Dr. Madden/Dr. Fine)
Benefit Concert | 1 February 2018 NFT
Krystina Alabado (Natalie Goodman), F Michael Haynie (Henry), Brandon Uranowitz (Dr Fine/Madden), Devin Ilaw (Gabe Goodman), Christiane Noll (Diana Goodman), Darius de Haas (Dan Goodman)
Barrington Stage Company | 18 August 2024 (magicshowsandmiracles master)
Natalie Joy Johnson (Diana), Alan H Green (Dan), Madison McBride (Natalie), Adante Carter (Gabe), Ben Clark (Henry), Joseph Morales (Dr Fine/Madden)
International
Netherlands | 23 May 2012
Simone Kleinsma (Diana), Wim van den Driessche (Dan), Michelle van de Ven (Natalie), Freek Bartels (Gabe), Jonathan Demoor (Henry), René van Kooten (Dr Madden/Fine)
Buenos Aires | 07 June 2013
Laura Conforte (Diana), Alejandro Parker (Dan), Manuela del Campo (Natalie), Matias Mayer (Gabe), Fernando Dente (Henry), Mariano Chiesa (Dr Madden/Fine)
Donmar Warehouse/West End
Off-West End | 16 September 2023 (shoeroom's Master)
Caissie Levy (Diana), Jamie Parker (Dan), Jack Wolfe (Gabe), Eleanor Worthington-Cox (Natalie), Joshua Gannon (u/s Henry), Trevor Dion Nicholas (Dr. Fine/Dr. Madden)
Notes: Joshua's last minute debut as Henry. Includes pre show announcement, and a show stop after My Psychopharmacologist and I to clean up smashed crockery.
West End | 20 June 2024 (Very Theatrical Trades' Master)
Caissie Levy (Diana Goodman), Jamie Parker (Dan), Jack Wolfe (Gabe), Eleanor Worthington Cox (Natalie), Jake Reynolds (u/s Henry), Trevor Dion Nicholas (Dr. Madden/Dr. Fine)
Notes: 3rd Preview and Jake Reynolds first show as Henry.
West End. | 3 August 2024 (LikeABoulevard's Master)
Caissie Levy (Diana), Jamie Parker (Dan), Jack Wolfe (Gabe), Lizzy Parker (s/b Natalie), Trevor Dion Nicholas (Dr Madden / Dr Fine), Jack Ofrecio (Henry)