We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-25 · 6 min read · Independent comparison
If you want a pair of smaller round liners that let you cook two things at once or keep a spare ready while one soaks, choose Macoota 2Pcs; if you need one large liner that fits a big 5–8 QT basket and folds flat between uses, choose Generic Silicone Air Fryer.
• Macoota 2Pcs — biggest strength: you get two 6.5-inch round silicone liners with a 428°F heat ceiling, so you can run back-to-back batches or use one in the air fryer while the other drains.
• Macoota 2Pcs — biggest trade-off: each liner is only 6.5 inches across, so a single one will not cover the full floor of a large basket, and the pair is aimed at 3–5 QT machines.
• Generic Silicone Air Fryer — biggest strength: one wide 8.6-inch round liner built for 5–8 QT fryers, heat-resistant to 446°F, dishwasher safe, and collapsible so it stores flat.
• Generic Silicone Air Fryer — biggest trade-off: it is a single liner in one size, so if you own a small 3 QT fryer it will be too big, and there is no second liner in the box.
• Pick Macoota 2Pcs if you cook in a 3–5 QT air fryer and want two liners for rotation, smaller portions, or multi-appliance use.
• Pick Generic Silicone Air Fryer if you own a 5–8 QT round fryer and want one big, foldable, dishwasher-friendly liner with a raised-ridge base.
Macoota's set is built around the idea that one liner is never quite enough. You get two round silicone liners measuring 6.5 inches by 6.5 inches, sized for 3–5 QT air fryers. The silicone is oil-resistant, waterproof and non-stick, rated heat-resistant up to 428°F, and the brand specifically notes it will not tear when you lift it out of the basket. That last point matters more than it sounds — a floppy liner full of hot food is exactly when cheap silicone fails you.
The second liner is the real story here. In practice, one liner is in the fryer while the other is in the sink or drying on the rack, so you are never stuck waiting on cleanup before the next batch. If you cook small portions, reheat leftovers, or like to keep wet and dry foods separated across two short cooks, the pair covers that without you buying anything extra. Because the material is also fine in microwave ovens, ovens, steamers and baking boxes, these liners follow you around the kitchen rather than living only in the air fryer.
Who should skip it: anyone with a large 5–8 QT basket. A 6.5-inch liner will not span that floor, and you would be lining only the middle of a big fryer. If you regularly cook a full basket of wings or a family-sized tray of vegetables, this set is the wrong scale — go bigger, not more.
Generic Silicone Air Fryer: Who It's For
The design details are where it earns its place. Thick, food-grade LFGB-certified silicone, BPA-free, heat-resistant to 446°F — a higher ceiling than the Macoota pair. The base has raised ridges, which the brand says are there to keep air moving under the food for crisper results rather than letting everything sit in its own steam. And it is collapsible: fold it flat, tuck it in a drawer, and it pops back into shape in seconds. It is also dishwasher safe, so cleanup can be as simple as a rinse or a trip through the machine.
Two practical notes. It ships as a single liner, no divider version in this listing, in gray. And it is explicitly not for open flame, so keep it inside the appliance. A bonus QR code unlocks a short recipe and cleaning guide, which is a nice touch if you are new to silicone liners.
Who should skip it: owners of compact 3–5 QT fryers. In an 8.6-inch liner, a small basket leaves you with silicone bunched up the sides and less usable cooking floor. Buy down in size instead of trying to make it fit.
• Best for small air fryers (3–5 QT) → Macoota 2Pcs. The 6.5-inch round size is matched to that basket class.
• Best for large air fryers (5–8 QT) → Generic Silicone Air Fryer. The 8.6-inch liner is built for that range.
• Best for cooking two things at once → Macoota 2Pcs. Two liners in the box means you can separate foods or run batches back to back.
• Best for storage in a tight kitchen → Generic Silicone Air Fryer. The collapsible design folds flat; the Macoota pair takes up two round spots.
• Best for crisper results in a big basket → Generic Silicone Air Fryer. The raised-ridge base is designed to lift food and let hot air circulate underneath.
• Best for cleanup convenience → Generic Silicone Air Fryer. It is dishwasher safe by spec; the Macoota liners are non-stick and rinse easily but are not listed as dishwasher safe.
• Best for using beyond the air fryer → Macoota 2Pcs. The brand lists ovens, microwaves, steamers, baking boxes and camping use.
• Best for a higher heat ceiling → Generic Silicone Air Fryer. 446°F versus 428°F.
If I were buying for myself, I would take the Generic Silicone Air Fryer — but only because I cook in a 5–8 QT round basket. The combination of a genuinely large 8.6-inch footprint, a 446°F rating, the airflow ridges and the fold-flat dishwasher-safe build is the more complete package for that appliance. In my opinion, the Macoota 2Pcs is the smarter buy for anyone in a 3–5 QT fryer who wants two liners and the flexibility to keep cooking while one is drying. Match the liner to your basket size and you will be happy with either.
how to use air fryer silicone liners
Place the liner flat in the air fryer basket, add your food in a single layer, and cook as you normally would. Both liners here are non-stick, so little or no extra oil is needed. Leave a little clearance around the edges so air can still move — the Generic liner's raised ridges are designed to help with exactly that.
how to clean air fryer silicone liner
Rinse with warm water and dish soap, then wipe with a soft sponge. The Generic liner is dishwasher safe by spec, so it can go straight in the machine. The Macoota liners are non-stick and heat-resistant to 428°F, which makes hand washing quick, but they are not listed as dishwasher safe, so I would keep those by hand.
how to clean air fryer silicone liner with baking soda
Make a paste from baking soda and a little water, work it onto stubborn spots with a soft sponge, let it sit briefly, then rinse thoroughly. It is a gentle option that suits silicone. Avoid abrasive scrubbers, and never use it on a liner that is still hot.
how to use air fryer silicone liners ninja
The Generic liner is designed to fit most 5–8 QT round air fryers, and the brand names Ninja among the popular models it suits. Measure your basket's inner diameter first — the liner is about 8.46 inches across. If your Ninja is a compact 3–5 QT model, the 6.5-inch Macoota liners are the better match.
One last thing worth checking before you commit: liner sizing is the single biggest reason people end up disappointed, so measure your basket floor first. And since both options are sold on Amazon, check the current price on Amazon using the button on this page rather than assuming — the numbers move around.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: PRETYZOOM Silicone Baking Tray vs Garneck 2pcs: Air Fryer, rhsaae Air Fryer Silicone vs BTOBI 2Pcs: Air Fryer Silicone, Szyeequoo Silicone Air Fryer vs Generic Silicone Air Fryer