How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-10-05 · 6 min read · Independent comparison
• MAcnas Clip-on Earbuds Open — biggest strength: Bluetooth 5.4 with auto-pairing, dual sonic directional transmission and ENC noise cancellation, rated at 5 hours of battery life with a 1.5-hour charge time.
• MAcnas Clip-on Earbuds Open — biggest trade-off: It uses a bone conduction driver and a 39.2 g overall weight, so it is the heavier, more "gadget-like" of the two rather than a featherweight accessory.
• ASHATA Earbuds Open Ear — biggest strength: A clamp-on design with a detachable rhinestone bowknot, V6.0 connectivity, a 1-hour quick charge, 4 hours of playback, and a Health Ears algorithm that adjusts volume automatically.
• ASHATA Earbuds Open Ear — biggest trade-off: Shorter 4-hour playtime and a 25 mAh earbud battery, so it suits shorter sessions rather than all-day wear.
• Who each pick is for: MAcnas for people with small ears who want long sessions, clearer calls and a discreet look; ASHATA for women who want a light, stylish pair for workouts, travel and short gym blocks.
MAcnas built this pair around a clip-on design made from high-resilience materials, which means the shape is meant to hold up over time instead of loosening after a few weeks of use. The silicone body and open-ear structure keep the ear canal clear, and the ergonomic surround plus streamlined sinking design is what keeps the buds on your ear when you run, dance, or wear glasses. That last point matters more than people expect — glasses arms and ear clips fight each other on cheap designs, and MAcnas specifically calls out glasses wearers as a fit case.
On the tech side, it runs Bluetooth 5.4 with auto-pairing: take a bud out of the case and it connects, and the case lid opening triggers reconnection after the first setup. Dual sonic directional transmission cuts sound leakage, and ENC noise cancellation is aimed squarely at call clarity rather than music isolation. Touch controls cover play/pause, volume, calls and voice assistant, and it works with iOS, Android, Macs and laptops. The driver is a bone conduction type with a 20Hz–20,000Hz range, 32 ohm impedance and 115 dB sensitivity. Battery is rated at 5 hours with a 1.5-hour charge.
Who should buy it: someone with small ears who finds standard buds slip out, anyone who wants one pair to move between phone and laptop, and gym-goers who want a longer single-charge window and clearer phone calls between sets. Who should skip it: if you want the lightest possible thing on your ear, or you specifically want a decorative look, this isn't that product. Also skip it if you need a wired 3.5mm option — there's no jack here, it's Bluetooth only, with a 10-meter range.
ASHATA goes a different direction: this is a clamp-on pair that rests gently on the ear without blocking the canal, and the headline feature is the detachable rhinestone bowknot that clips on or off depending on your mood. That's a clear style-first play, and it's aimed at women who want their gym earbuds to look like an accessory rather than a piece of tech. The color is listed as #111, a deep black, so the bowknot is doing the visual work.
Functionally, it uses a "V6.0" version with a 10–15 meter range, quick charging in about 1 hour, and up to 4 hours of playback. The earbuds carry 25 mAh batteries and the charging case carries 180 mAh. It also uses dual reverse sound transfer technology, which ASHATA says minimizes sound leakage, and a Health Ears algorithm that automatically adjusts volume during extended listening — a genuinely useful, less common feature if you tend to crank things up without noticing.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for battery life → MAcnas Clip-on Earbuds Open. 5 hours rated playtime versus 4 hours, and with 1.5-hour charging you can top up between gym sessions.
• Best for fast charging → ASHATA Earbuds Open Ear. Roughly 1 hour to charge, versus 1.5 hours for the MAcnas pair.
• Best for small ears → MAcnas Clip-on Earbuds Open. The listing is explicitly built around small ears, with soft silicone and a high-resilience clip that's meant to keep its shape.
• Best for gym style → ASHATA Earbuds Open Ear. The detachable rhinestone bowknot is the only decorative element in this comparison, and it comes off when you want a plainer look.
• Best for call quality → MAcnas Clip-on Earbuds Open. ENC noise cancellation and dual sonic directional transmission are the call-focused features here.
• Best for hearing-protection features → ASHATA Earbuds Open Ear. The Health Ears algorithm auto-adjusts volume during long listening sessions.
• Best for mixed devices → MAcnas Clip-on Earbuds Open. It's listed as compatible with iOS, Android, Macs, computers and laptops, with Bluetooth 5.4 and auto-pairing.
• Best for lighter wear → ASHATA Earbuds Open Ear. A clamp-on fit that rests on the ear without canal pressure, aimed at workouts and travel.
For gym use, I'd buy the MAcnas Clip-on Earbuds Open. In my opinion, the longer 5-hour battery, Bluetooth 5.4 with auto-pairing, ENC call clarity and the small-ear, glasses-friendly clip design make it the more practical training partner for most people. The ASHATA pair is a solid, lighter alternative — and if style is a real priority for you, the detachable bowknot plus the Health Ears volume protection are genuinely appealing. But when I weigh the specs for the gym specifically, MAcnas wins on the things that matter between sets.
For most gym sessions I'd take the MAcnas pair, mainly because of the longer rated battery life and ENC call handling. The ASHATA is lighter and charges faster, so it's a fine pick if your workouts are short.
Both come with a charging case and a charging cable, and both are rechargeable. Check the current connector details on the Amazon listing before you buy if USB-C specifically matters to you, since the spec sheets don't state the connector type.
Both brands claim to reduce leakage — MAcnas via dual sonic directional transmission, ASHATA via dual reverse sound transfer technology. In practice, open-ear designs always let some sound out, so treat these as leakage-reducing rather than leakage-proof.
The MAcnas Clip-on Earbuds Open is the one to look at first, since it's designed around small ears with soft silicone and a shape-holding clip. The ASHATA clamp-on fit is also light and non-pressuring, but it doesn't make the same small-ear claim.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: Keewonda Bulk Earbuds Headphones vs Bulktech 10, wireless future charger Airpod Charger vs MWRPCRDN Earbuds, AONKE Hard Headphones Case vs Luhaomisky Retro 2, Skullcandy Hesh Evo vs TOZO HT3: Foldable Headphones