How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
If you want a moldable putty plug that seals to the exact shape of your ear for sleep, swimming and loud rooms, choose Mack's Pillow Soft Silicone; if you need reusable silicone earplugs with four tip sizes, two travel boxes and a higher stated noise-reduction figure, choose OEDOC Silicone Ear Plugs. Neither one is a Bluetooth headset, so if you landed here hunting the best bluetooth headset for vlogging, you're in the wrong aisle — but read on, because both of these are genuinely useful if you record voiceovers, edit late at night, or need to block a noisy room before you shoot.
• Mack's biggest strength: soft moldable silicone putty that you shape yourself, so it conforms to the unique contours of any ear and forms an airtight, watertight seal. It's also the only one of the two with a stated Noise Reduction Rating of 22 decibels.
• Mack's biggest trade-off: because it's putty, it's a shaped-by-you product rather than a fixed-tip design — there's no assortment of tip sizes, and the pack is 2 pair (4 count), so you're not getting a big stash of spares.
• OEDOC biggest strength: 16 ear tips across XS, S, M and L, reusable soft silicone, and a stated reduction of up to 33 decibels, plus two travel boxes.
• OEDOC biggest trade-off: it's a multi-size, multi-part kit, so you have to find your tip size and keep track of the rest — more pieces to manage than a single lump of putty.
• Pick Mack's if you want one product that molds to you, that you can wear in water, and that you'll happily use for sleep, flying and concerts.
• Pick OEDOC if you want reusable plugs you can wash and re-wear, with size options for two different people in one house, and a stated noise reduction figure that's higher on paper.
Mack's Pillow Soft Silicone is the original moldable silicone putty earplug, and the design logic is simple: instead of asking your ear to fit the plug, the plug fits your ear. You warm the putty, press it over the opening of the ear canal and shape it until it seals. That's why the brand can claim a better, more comfortable fit and seal than custom molded ear plugs — there's no rigid stem, no tip to size, and nothing pressing on the inside of the canal. For side sleepers, that's the whole point: there's no hard plastic poking you when you roll over.
Buy Mack's if you want one simple, moldable product for sleep plus water plus noise, and you like the idea of a plug with no parts to lose. Skip it if you want a reusable plug you can rinse and re-wear indefinitely, or if you need multiple sizes for multiple people, or if you specifically want a higher stated decibel reduction.
OEDOC Silicone Ear Plugs: Who It's For
OEDOC takes the opposite approach: a fixed soft silicone plug that comes with a range of tips so you can match your ear rather than mold the plug. You get 16 ear tips in XS, S, M and L, plus two travel boxes, and there's no assembly required — you pick a tip, fit it, and go. The brand describes an ultra-small, ultra-thin design with a right-sized center shaped around the pinna, and states the plugs are stable enough that they don't slip out when you lie on your side or turn over. That's the real-world worry for anyone who sleeps on their side, and it's the thing this design is clearly aimed at.
The stated noise reduction is up to 33 decibels, which is the higher figure of the two products here. It's reusable soft silicone, so you can wash it, and the brand lists sleeping, snoring, studying, work, travel, concerts, relaxation and flying discomfort as intended uses. The 4-size tip range is genuinely the standout feature: one purchase can cover a small-eared teenager and a large-eared adult, and the spare tips live in the travel boxes so you're not hunting for them in a drawer.
Buy OEDOC if you want reusable plugs you can wash and re-wear, you're not sure what size your ears are, or you're buying for more than one person. Skip it if you want a single moldable piece with no parts, or if you specifically need a plug you can wear in the pool — the putty approach is the one designed for water.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for matching an unknown ear size → OEDOC Silicone Ear Plugs, with 16 tips across XS, S, M and L.
• Best for swimming and water protection → Mack's, since the moldable putty is the one marketed for a watertight seal, swimmer's ear and Surfer's Ear.
• Best for flying and ear pressure → Mack's, which states its plugs are lab tested to help relieve airplane ear pressure and pain.
• Best for higher stated noise reduction → OEDOC, at up to 33 decibels versus Mack's stated NRR of 22 decibels.
• Best for reusability and washing → OEDOC, a washable reusable silicone plug with travel boxes.
• Best for a one-piece, nothing-to-lose product → Mack's, a 2-pair pack of putty with no tips or stems.
• Best for a household with different ear sizes → OEDOC, because the four tip sizes cover more than one wearer.
In my opinion, Mack's Pillow Soft Silicone is the one I'd buy first, and it's the one I'd recommend to most people reading this. The moldable putty design solves the two problems that actually make people give up on earplugs — pressure and fit — and it's the only one of the two built for water, flying and sleep in one product. I'd steer you to OEDOC instead if the size range matters more to you than the putty approach, or if a higher stated decibel reduction is your priority. And to be clear about the vlogging angle: if what you actually want is a headphone for vlogging or volume limiting sports earbuds for vlogging, these are passive plugs, not audio gear — they'll quiet a noisy room before a take, not record one.
how to put on silicone earbuds
With Mack's, warm and soften the putty, then press and shape it over the ear canal opening until it seals — no insertion into the canal. With OEDOC, choose the tip size that fits, fit it to the plug and seat it in the ear. OEDOC states no assembly is required.
what are the best earbuds to sleep in
These aren't earbuds — they're passive earplugs. For sleep, the deciding factor is pressure against the pillow. Mack's moldable putty flattens and has no hard parts, and OEDOC states its plugs are stable when you lie on your side or turn over.
are there earbuds for sleeping
Yes, in the sense of sleep earplugs. Mack's is designed for extended wear and lists sleeping, snoring, travel and flying among its uses. OEDOC is reusable soft silicone with 16 tips in XS/S/M/L and two travel boxes, and it lists sleeping and snoring as intended uses.
which one blocks more noise
On the stated figures, OEDOC is higher: up to 33 decibels versus Mack's Noise Reduction Rating of 22 decibels. In practice, Mack's seal depends on how well you shape the putty, while OEDOC depends on picking the right tip size. Both are worth checking the current price on Amazon before you commit.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: ATUAT AirPods Max Headphones vs Oplp Headphones Insulated Lunch, GEEKRIA Silicone Case Cover vs Inesore 1 comparison, Audio-Technica AT2005USBPK vs BASNLIFE BmasterX 6-Driver, ZIHNIC Active Noise Cancelling vs TREBLAB C7-Pro