The construction of the Todaiji Temple sheds light on a broader phenomenon that Japanese power holders employed Buddhism as instruments of ruling tactics. Buddhism as political might take a plethora of forms, and the manifestations varied wildly, from muscle-flexing to spiritual indoctrination. Let's take a close look at how Buddhism was utilized by Japanese monarchs for political legitimacies throughout the course of pre-modern history.
Prince Shotoku was a regent who served under Empress Suiko during the Asuka period. One of the most common political legitimacies stemmed from the notion of ‘dharma king’. The term refers to the king of law, with a suggestion that a monarch advocates justice and order. This semi-sacred title was bestowed to Dokyo when he swore the Imperial Office of the Dharma King, or hoo kyushiki. Dokyo, a monk in the Nara period amid Shotoku's reign, represented the political endowment of monastics which even posed threat to the ruling aristocracy (Deal and Ruppert 2015, 65). Dokyo’s dominance in the court reached an apex when Shotoku elevated him to be the daijin zenji, or Buddhist Minister of the State. Ostensibly as a court bureaucrat, the de facto function of the position is a distinguished monastic serving the court. As Deal and Ruppert (2015, 65) addressed, Shotoku blurred the binary between imperial and Buddhist sphere of power.
Portrait of Prince Shotoku. The physical appearance indicates continental traits.
Ashikaga Takauji was the first shongun in Ashikaga period. After the Gempei war (1180-1185) , Ashikaga Takauji commissioned a full-scale memorial campaign for whom sacrificed their precious lives in the battles. As a devout Buddhist, he commenced his religious building project with constructing a 'temple of peace in the realm' (ankokuji) and a 'pagoda of Buddha's favour' (rishoto) in each province (Turnbull 2011, 186).
The proliferation of ankokuji and rishoto, as headquarters of the Zen and Shingon Buddhism respectively, were considered to be a panacea to mourn for the deceased souls. The proliferation of the temple network was reminiscent of the kokubunji system by Shomu that it created a Bakufu-connected nationwide network of political calculation and indoctrination (Mass 1997, 287). Despite the ostensible religious impulse, the temple network also embodied political ambition since it demonstrated 'territorial control by patron' (Mass 1997, 288). Namely, central authority permeated to the provincial level with the integration of them into official gozan network of official temples. The political implication stemmed from the claim that Ashikaga shogunate's benevolence would empower their monarchy (Mass 1997, 288). Also, as Zen Buddhism was an emblem of cultural capital, or an important form of high-taste knowledge, engaging in Buddhist patronage would undoubtedly gentrify the Ashikaga Shogun and consolidate their reputation.
With portraying the Ashikaga shogun as a virtuous monarch, he claimed that he executed power based on consensual approaches instead of coercion, which adds up to his political legitimacy.
Portrait of Ashikaga Takauji
Ashikaga Yoshimitsu was the third shongun in Ashikaga period. Another analogous concept --'universal monarch' was iterated by kūkai, a politically savvy monk who claimed that Shingon had the powers necessary to transform the emperor into a universal monarch (cakravartin) who was capable of adjudicating the entirety of the universe. The temple complex was a context of monumentalism created by Yoshimitsu through which his status was empowered and sacralised.
The concept of dharma king was elaborated by Ashikaga Yoshimitsu who built Shokokuji pagoda so as to forge an anthropo-cosmic connection, or claiming his supreme competency to govern both the secular and the sacred realms (Stavros & Tomishima 2018, 12). The pagoda, quite identical to the stupas in Southeast Asia, are all testimonies to the notion that Buddhist kinship sits at the centre of both the cosmo and the secular regimes.
According to Donald Swearer,
'The stupa in its structural form suggests that the ruler is empowered or legitimated by his association with the creative-ordering-liberating forces of the universe ... and that through his association, the ruler himself, becomes an active agent in maintaining the order of the universe. ' (Swearer 2010, 81 in Stavros and Tomishima 2018, 132)
In this sense, the pagoda in the Shokokuji complex is a savvy tactic adopted by Yoshimitsu to forge an anthropocosmic connection to boost his political legitimacy.
Portrait of Ashikaga Yoshimitsu
Are you keen to get more insights into Ashikaga Yoshimitsu? Watch this short video and start at roughly 6:00. Ashikaga Yoshimitsu is not only an aspiring politician but also a connoisseur of cultural ideals, including fine arts, tea ceremony and elaborate gardens as well as temple complexes in the capital city of Kyoto. His patronage of high cultures was a weapon helping him to outmaneuver his enemies.
The interactive map covers a couple of UNESCO sites in Japan which are related to Buddhism and embody political mightiness. They are either masterpieces of monumental arts or testimonies to Japanese civilization.
I look particularly into the political aspects of each site, namely, how temples are anchored by political implications. Some rendered as political agents while others are exploited by monarchs as their panaceas for political legitimacy. In this sense, Buddhism is not only of spiritual significance, more significantly, from a functionalist perspective, its political implications could be just as substantial as its religious clout. You can click on the icons on the top left corner to view the layers. Each layer covers temples from different periods of times.
Page Reference:
Deal, W. E., & Ruppert, B. (2015). A Cultural History of Japanese Buddhism. John Wiley & Sons.
Mass, J. P. (1997). The origins of Japan's medieval world: courtiers, clerics, warriors, and peasants in the fourteenth century. Stanford University Press.
Stavros, M., & Tomishima, Y. (2018). The Shōkokuji Pagoda: Building the Infrastructure of Buddhist Kingship in Medieval Japan. Japanese Journal of Religious Studies, 45(1), 125-214
Turnbull, S. (2011). The Samurai and the Sacred: The Path of the Warrior. Bloomsbury Publishing.
http://www.cnn.com/travel/article/japan-17-stunning-temples/index.html?gallery=0