How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
If you want one pair of earplugs that dials its own noise reduction up and down with a twist, choose Loop Switch 2; if you need Bluetooth audio and certified jobsite-grade hearing protection in the same unit, choose Elgin Rumble Gen 2. These two products get compared constantly because they both promise "less noise, more control" — but they solve completely different problems. One is a passive, battery-free earplug with three mechanical modes. The other is a wireless earbud built to survive construction sites. Here's how to tell which one belongs in your pocket.
• Loop Switch 2 biggest strength: three levels of noise reduction (20–26 dB SNR) in a single passive earplug, changed instantly with an in-ear dial — no batteries, no charging, no electronics.
• Loop Switch 2 biggest trade-off: it's a hearing-protection tool, not an audio device. No Bluetooth, no music, no calls.
• Elgin Rumble Gen 2 biggest strength: Bluetooth 5.3 audio plus real certified protection — 31 dB NRR with the Fusion tips, IP67 ruggedized, up to 20 hours per charge.
• Elgin Rumble Gen 2 biggest trade-off: it's bulkier and more involved — a neckband, a cable, charging, pairing — and you can't dial the attenuation down for a quiet café conversation.
• Who Loop Switch 2 is for: commuters, focus-seekers, concert-goers and anyone who wants adjustable quiet on demand without a charging cable.
• Who Elgin Rumble Gen 2 is for: tradespeople and loud-workplace users who want music, calls and OSHA-compliant protection at the same time.
Loop Switch 2 is the "one earplug, three jobs" idea taken about as far as it goes. Instead of swapping between different plugs for different environments, you twist an in-ear dial and move between Quiet, Engage and Experience modes. Quiet is the strongest attenuation in the set, Engage is tuned for holding a conversation without pulling the plugs out, and Experience is meant for live music — cutting the harshness while keeping the detail. Across the range you're getting 20–26 dB SNR of passive noise reduction. That's a genuinely useful spread, and the fact that it's mechanical means nothing to charge, nothing to pair, and nothing to fail on a firmware update.
The second-generation changes are mostly about comfort and control. The body is slimmer and the nozzle is shorter and angled, which matters more than it sounds — deeper, bulkier plugs get uncomfortable fast and start working their way loose. Loop ships four ear tip sizes (XS, S, M, L) with medium pre-installed, so you can actually chase a proper seal rather than settling for "close enough." The redesigned dial has more grip, which is the unglamorous detail that makes one-handed mode changes possible when you're standing on a train platform.
Who should skip it? Anyone whose main goal is listening to something. There's no Bluetooth, no drivers, no microphone — Loop is explicit that Switch 2 is passive hearing protection with no electronics. If you want music and noise reduction together, this isn't the product, no matter how good the dial feels.
Elgin Rumble Gen 2: Who It's For
Elgin Rumble Gen 2 answers a different question: how do I listen to music and take calls on a job site without destroying my hearing? The headline number is 31 dB NRR with the included Fusion tips (27 dB if you switch to the silicone tips), and it's ANSI certified and OSHA compliant — the kind of paperwork that matters when hearing protection is part of how you're expected to work, not just a personal preference.
Around that core, Elgin has built a real audio product. Bluetooth 5.3 pairs fast and holds a stable connection out to about 50 feet, which is handy when your phone is on a bench and you're moving around. Dual custom-tuned drivers cover a 20 Hz–20,000 Hz range, and a noise-canceling microphone is there so callers can hear you over equipment. Battery life is quoted at up to 20 hours from twin rechargeable batteries with a 1.5-hour charge time — enough for the longest shift in the set.
The durability story is where it separates from ordinary earbuds. IP67 means dust, sweat and water resistance, which covers rain, sawdust and a lot of sweat. The housing is double-molded, the cable is Kevlar reinforced, and the flush-mount design with memory wire is clearly meant to sit under a hard hat or safety glasses without snagging. Magnetic earbuds snap together for storage so the cable doesn't tangle in a tool bag.
Comfort gets its own kit: a thicker, soft-touch silicone neckband, plus three Fusion tip sets (one pre-installed), two silicone sets and two comfort sets. That's a lot of fit permutations, and it's the right call — a helmet-compatible earbud only works if you can get a seal that holds while you're moving.
Who should buy it? Construction, landscaping, fabrication and warehouse workers. Anyone who spends the day around loud machinery and wants their ears protected while still being reachable by phone. Also a solid choice for DIYers running power tools in a garage.
Who should skip it? Anyone who wants discreet, battery-free, instantly adjustable quiet. The Rumble is a neckband device with a cable and a charging routine, and you can't drop it to a low-attenuation mode for a normal conversation the way you can with a dial. It's also overkill if your noise problem is a noisy office rather than a loud site.
• Best for adjustable noise reduction → Loop Switch 2. Three distinct modes (Quiet, Engage, Experience) in one passive plug, changed by hand in a second.
• Best for certified workplace protection → Elgin Rumble Gen 2. 31 dB NRR with Fusion tips, ANSI certified and OSHA compliant.
• Best for listening to music or taking calls → Elgin Rumble Gen 2. Bluetooth 5.3, dual drivers and a noise-canceling mic; Loop has no electronics at all.
• Best for zero maintenance → Loop Switch 2. No batteries, no charging, no pairing, no firmware.
• Best for battery life → Elgin Rumble Gen 2. Up to 20 hours per charge with a 1.5-hour recharge; Loop's runtime is effectively unlimited because it doesn't use power.
• Best for tough, wet, dusty environments → Elgin Rumble Gen 2. IP67, Kevlar-reinforced cable, double-molded housing, hard-hat-friendly flush mount.
• Best for concerts, travel and social settings → Loop Switch 2. Experience mode for live sound, Engage for talking, Quiet for shutting the world out.
• Best for maximum seal customization → tie. Loop gives four tip sizes (XS–L); Elgin gives three Fusion sets, two silicone sets and two comfort sets — different approaches, both generous.
If I had to pick one for myself, I'd buy the Loop Switch 2. In my opinion, the three-mode dial is the single most useful feature in this comparison, because most people's noise problem changes hour by hour — loud train, then a meeting, then a gig — and being able to adapt without charging anything is worth more than audio playback to me. I'd recommend the Elgin Rumble Gen 2 without hesitation to anyone who works in loud environments, needs certified protection on paper, and wants music and calls on the clock. Different jobs, different tools — but if your day isn't spent on a job site, Loop is the one I'd reach for.
For loud workplaces, Elgin Rumble Gen 2. It's ANSI certified and OSHA compliant with 31 dB NRR using the Fusion tips, plus IP67 durability and a hard-hat-friendly design. Loop Switch 2 offers 20–26 dB SNR of passive protection, which suits commuting, focus and events rather than industrial noise.
No. Loop Switch 2 is passive hearing protection with no batteries and no electronics — the modes are changed with a manual in-ear dial. If you need wireless audio, the Elgin Rumble Gen 2 is the Bluetooth option here.
Loop Switch 2 reduces noise by 20–26 dB SNR depending on the mode and fit. Elgin Rumble Gen 2 is rated at 31 dB NRR with Fusion tips or 27 dB with silicone tips. Both depend heavily on getting a good seal, which is why both brands include multiple ear tip sizes.
It depends on what you're buying it for — check the current price on Amazon for both before deciding. If you want a passive, charge-free earplug with three modes, Loop Switch 2 covers that need. If you want one device that does protection plus Bluetooth audio, calls and 20-hour battery, Elgin Rumble Gen 2 replaces two products at once.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.