How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-10-07 · 7 min read · Independent comparison
• Logitech G335 biggest strength: Very light at 240 g (8.5 oz) with a suspension headband and memory foam earpads, so long sessions stay comfortable.
• Logitech G335 biggest trade-off: On-ear oval earpieces with a plastic build and no noise control, so it isolates less than a closed-back over-ear design.
• Amazon Renewed ASTRO Gaming Astro biggest strength: Over-ear closed-back construction with replaceable ear cushions and a replaceable headband pad, plus in-line volume control.
• Amazon Renewed ASTRO Gaming Astro biggest trade-off: It is a renewed product with a 90-day limited warranty, and it is heavier at 1.2 pounds.
• Who Logitech G335 is for: Gamers who want a light, colorful, plug-and-play headset for PC and consoles.
• Who Amazon Renewed ASTRO Gaming Astro is for: Gamers who want a durable over-ear headset and don't mind a renewed unit.
The G335 is built around comfort first. At 240 g, it is light, and the suspension headband is designed to spread that weight instead of pressing it into one spot on your head. The soft elastic headband is adjustable, reversible and washable, so you can swap it and keep it fresh. The earpads are memory foam with sports mesh, which is the kind of material that stays tolerable through a long evening of play.
Sound comes from 40 mm neodymium drivers with a 20 Hz – 20,000 Hz frequency range and 36 ohm impedance. In practice that means it is easy to drive from a normal 3.5 mm jack — PC, laptop, PlayStation 5, PlayStation 4, Xbox One, Xbox Series X|S, Nintendo Switch/Switch 2 and select mobile devices. There is no battery and no pairing; you plug in and you are playing.
The controls are the part I like most for everyday use. There is a volume roller right on the ear cup, so you never have to leave the game to change level, and the mic flips up to mute and swings out of the way. It is also Discord Certified for voice and audio clarity, which matters if you spend your nights in a party chat.
Who should buy it: someone who wants a light, comfortable, genuinely plug-and-play wired headset in a fun colorway and plays on a mix of PC and console. Who should skip it: anyone who wants strong isolation, a closed-back over-ear feel, or a headset with replaceable earpads. The G335 is on-ear with oval earpieces, and its pads are not listed as replaceable, so if you want that kind of longevity, look at the other option.
The ASTRO A10 Gen 2 is a different philosophy. It is an over-ear, circumaural, closed-back headset, which means the cups surround your ears rather than rest on them. That closed-back design is the reason it is often picked for long sessions — it blocks more of the room around you than an on-ear design does, and it keeps your audio from leaking out as much.
The drivers are custom-tuned 32 mm dynamic units, also rated 20 Hz – 20,000 Hz, with 14 ohm impedance. That low impedance makes it very easy to drive from a phone, controller or laptop jack. The mic is a 6.0 mm unidirectional boom that flips up to mute and down to talk. Volume lives on an in-line control on the removable cable, so you adjust without pausing.
The durability story is where the A10 Gen 2 stands apart. It uses an ultra-durable headband and sturdy construction, and — importantly — the ear cushions and headband pad are replaceable. That means when the pads eventually wear flat, you replace the pads, not the whole headset. For a headset you plan to keep for years, that is a real practical advantage.
The catch is the "Renewed" part. This is a pre-owned or refurbished unit that has been professionally inspected and tested to work and look like new by Amazon-qualified suppliers, and it is covered by the Amazon Renewed Guarantee, which makes it eligible for replacement or refund if you are not satisfied. The warranty is 90 days limited, which is shorter than the 1-year limited hardware warranty on the G335. It is also heavier at 1.2 pounds, so it presses more than the Logitech does.
Who should buy it: a gamer who wants a closed-back over-ear headset, replaceable pads, in-line volume and a durable frame, and who is comfortable buying renewed. Who should skip it: anyone who wants a brand-new unit with a longer warranty, or who prioritizes the lightest possible weight.
• Best for all-day light comfort → Logitech G335. 240 g with a suspension headband and memory foam pads.
• Best for isolation and a closed-back feel → Amazon Renewed ASTRO Gaming Astro. Circumaural over-ear cups with a closed back.
• Best for easy volume changes mid-game → Amazon Renewed ASTRO Gaming Astro. In-line volume control on the cable; the G335 puts its roller on the ear cup instead.
• Best for longevity of the pads → Amazon Renewed ASTRO Gaming Astro. Replaceable ear cushions and headband pad.
• Best for the lightest possible setup → Logitech G335. Nearly half the weight of the A10 Gen 2.
• Best for a longer warranty → Logitech G335. 1-year limited hardware warranty versus 90 days limited on the renewed unit.
• Best for color and style choices → Logitech G335. Multiple colorways with matching reversible, washable headbands.
• Best for buyers who want a brand-new unit → Logitech G335. The ASTRO is a renewed product by definition.
• Best for voice clarity in party chat → Logitech G335. Discord Certified for voice and audio clarity.
In my opinion, I would buy the Logitech G335 if comfort, light weight and a simple plug-and-play wired setup are what you care about most, and I would buy the Amazon Renewed ASTRO Gaming Astro if you want a closed-back over-ear headset with replaceable pads and in-line volume and you are fine with a renewed unit and a 90-day warranty. For most people reading a "gaming headset" comparison, the G335 is the safer pick. Just remember again: neither of these is a toddler product, so if you are actually hunting for anc open ear headphones for toddlers, head phones for toddlers, or the best noise cancelling head phones for toddlers, skip both and shop that category instead. Whichever you lean toward, check the current price on Amazon before you commit.
FAQ
how to buy a gaming headset
Start with connection and fit. Both of these use a wired 3.5 mm jack, so they work with PC, PlayStation, Xbox and Switch without pairing or charging. Then decide on-ear versus over-ear: the G335 is on-ear and light, the ASTRO is over-ear and closed-back with replaceable pads.
I can't quote prices here — the page doesn't display them. What I can tell you is that value depends on what you get: the G335 gives you a 1-year limited warranty and a lighter build, while the renewed ASTRO gives you replaceable pads and a closed-back design but a 90-day limited warranty. Check the current price on Amazon for both.
what makes a headset good for gaming
For gaming, fit and mic usability matter as much as drivers. Both headsets use dynamic drivers with a 20 Hz – 20,000 Hz range, both have a flip-to-mute mic, and both are wired for zero latency. The G335 adds Discord Certification; the ASTRO adds a removable cable with in-line volume.
how do gaming headsets work
A wired headset like either of these takes stereo audio over a single 3.5 mm jack and sends your voice back through the boom mic. Volume is handled either on the ear cup (G335) or on the cable (ASTRO), and flipping the mic up mutes you instantly on both.
• Razer Hammerhead True vs EPOS Adapt E1 comparison
• Picun B8 vs SQERO Airplane Headphone Jack
• LAISANIM Mini vs ZyvermontX Earphones Clip-On TF
• ENVYCLOUD CD Player vs MUSICOZY Sleep Mask: Bluetooth Stereo
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.