LIGHTS & SHADOWS

AN ASSESSMENT OF THE DUTERTE ADMINISTRATION THROUGH THE LENS OF CATHOLIC SOCIAL PRINCIPLES


JANUARY - JUNE 2021

Against so many odds in 2020, the administration of President Rodrigo Duterte was buoyed by the unprecedented popularity of the chief executive, who now enters his last year in office. He may leave his office as the most-positively evaluated president: despite the widely criticized government’s response to the COVID-19 pandemic, President Duterte fared quite well in public opinion surveys with a record 91% approval rating in September 2020.

But does popularity mean good governance and effective leadership? In his encyclical Fratelli Tutti, Pope Francis offers a hint to answering this question.

‘Popular’ leaders, those capable of interpreting the feelings and cultural dynamics of a people, and significant trends in society, do exist. The service they provide by their efforts to unite and lead can become the basis of an enduring vision of transformation and growth that would also include making room for others in the pursuit of the common good. But this can degenerate into an unhealthy 'populism' when individuals are able to exploit politically a people’s culture, under whatever ideological banner, for their own personal advantage or continuing grip on power. Or when, at other times, they seek popularity by appealing to the basest and most selfish inclinations of certain sectors of the population. This becomes all the more serious when, whether in cruder or more subtle forms, it leads to the usurpation of institutions and laws. (159)

In this issue of the Lights & Shadows, we at the John J Carroll Institute on Church and Social Issues (ICSI) continue to assess the Duterte administration with the hope that readers may arrive at an informed opinion on select issues concerning Philippine society. We use the principles of Catholic social teaching (CST), as espoused by the Second Plenary Council of the Philippines (PCP-II), to examine how the government has addressed issues in the first half of 2021 that affect human dignity and human rights, contribute to social justice and achievement of the common good, impact the environment, among others. Examining at least three newsworthy stories in each theme—the economy, human rights, urban poverty, rural development, children, environment, governance, and labor and employment, we present government pronouncements and actions that provide reasons to hope (the “lights”) and matters of concern (the “shadows”). In doing so, may we contribute to building a kind of politics that goes beyond popular personalities and is “truly at the service of the common good” (Fratelli Tutti 154).


THIS SITE IS BEST VIEWED ON A DESKTOP COMPUTER. IF VIEWED USING A TABLET OR MOBILE DEVICE, CLICK THE MENU BUTTON AT THE UPPER LEFT CORNER OF THE PAGE TO VIEW AND SELECT THE THEMES.

Applying THE PRINCIPLES OF CATHOLIC SOCIAL TEACHING in assessing public policy

Integral Development Based on Human Dignity and Solidarity

Public policy and government programs must promote development that not only fulfils the material needs of citizens, but also affirms human dignity and freedom, integrity in governance, national sovereignty, and the spiritual dimension of human beings.

Universal Purpose of Earthly Goods and Private Property

Public policy and government programs must reflect the conviction that all the goods of the earth are intended to fulfill the needs of all and to be shared fairly by all. It must recognize that private property has a social dimension, and that the rights of private ownership are limited by the urgent basic needs of others for food, safe and decent housing, and livelihood.

Social Justice and Love

Public policy and government programs must correct historical injustice to groups of the marginalized and must promote equality, within the context of love for one’s fellow human beings.

Love of Preference for the Poor

Public policy and government programs must be oriented toward meeting the needs of the most vulnerable and marginalized in society.

Value of Human Work

Public policy and government programs must affirm human labor as the most important element of production, establish fair compensation that allows workers to raise families within a decent standard of living, protect the rights of workers to self-organization, and create opportunities for employment and livelihood with dignity.

Peace and Active Non-violence

Public policy and government programs must promote peace not as the suppression of conflict, but as the result of constructive dialogue and holistic solutions which treat conflicting parties as human beings and address the root causes of conflict.

Integrity of Creation

Public policy and government programs must safeguard and conserve natural resources and promote production that does not destroy the environment.

People Empowerment

Public policy and government programs must enable people to become “active and responsible subjects of social life,” institutionalizing mechanisms for meaningful participation at all levels of governance and protecting the civil rights and freedoms which allow such participation. Public policy and government programs must nurture the development of strong civil society organizations and institutions and protect the autonomy of civil society from the state, recognizing the principle of subsidiarity which requires that decisions be made as much as possible at the level closest to the people.

READ OUR ASSESSMENT OF THE PREVIOUS YEAR

For comments, suggestions, and feedback, write us as jjcicsi@gmail.com, message us on Facebook at facebook.com/JJCICSI, or leave your message at the end of each assessment.