Let’s Replay Game Achievement List
Strong Starter: If the game has a great beginning
Slow Starter: If the game has a bad beginning
Under Control: If the game has great controls or mechanics
Out of Control: If the game has difficult or poor controls or mechanics
Hey, Listen!: For an annoying character or aspect of the game
Bad Battler: If the game has poor combat
Best Battler: If the game has good combat
Tedious Trophy: For an extremely tedious part of the game
Controller Thrown: For an extremely frustrating part of the game
Artist’s Choice: If the game has strong graphics or art direction
Eyesore: If the game has bad graphics or art direction
Second Home: For a dungeon, level, or area you really loved
Fixer Upper: For a dungeon, level, or area you didn’t like
Lasting Legacy: For a game that you believe had a big impact on the industry/medium
Stuck the Landing: If the game has a great ending
Stumbled the Landing: If the game has an unsatisfying ending
Completionist’s Choice: If you think the game is worth getting 100% completion
Stud Alert: For a standout character in the game
Scrub Alert: For a bad character in the game
Thinking Cap: For a game that makes you think and learn
Mindless: For a game that needs no thinking
Overpowered: For an item in the game you think is clearly the best
Underpowered: For an item in the game you think is clearly the most disappointing
Earworm: For a game with great music
Mute Button: For a game with music that adds nothing or annoying sounds
Quality: For a game that’s really well made and has no design flaws/glitches
Not Enough: For a game that left you wanting more
Overfull: For a game that had too much to do
Goldilocks: For a game that you felt was the right length
Author’s Choice: For a game with a great story
Author’s Junk: For a game with a bad story
Antagonizer: For a game with a great villain
Protagonizer: For a game with a great main character
Thriller: For a game that leaves you exhilarated
Snoozer: For a game that is super boring
Chuckler: For a game that’s very funny
Stuff of Nightmares: For a game that’s legitimately horrifying
Unquality: For a game that is poorly made or has many design flaws/glitches
Multiplayer Masterpiece: For a game that is great for multiplayer
Multiplayer Misfire: For a game that has poor multiplayer
Wanderer’s Dream: For a game that has lots to explore and is nonlinear
Straight to the Point: For a game that is very story driven and linear
Cakewalk: For a game that’s really easy
Playthrough of Pain: For a game that’s very tough
Again!: For a game that holds replay value
Creator’s Choice: For a game that lets you create or make things in a satisfying way
Graceful Aging: For a retro game that still holds up
Washed Up: For a retro game that has aged poorly and needs to be sent to the farm upstate
Timesink: For a game that you can play for hundreds of hours
Short but Sweet: For a game that can be beaten very quickly
Brilliant Bosses: For a game with great bosses
Bad Bosses: For a game with disappointing bosses
Zen: For a game that is very peaceful
Competitor’s Choice: For a game that is great for competitive players
Customizer’s Choice: For a game that has many customizable options
Speedrunner’s Choice: For a game that is ideally suited for speedrunners
Once is Enough: For a game that you have no desire to play again
Innovator: For a game that pioneered something new in the industry
Unimaginative: For a game that pioneered on absolutely nothing
Cha-Ching!: For a game that’s riddled with microtransactions
Menu Minefield: For a game that has a lot of menu screens
Platinum Pick: For your favorite game - you can only use this on one episode
Collaborator's Choice: For a game that encourages teamwork
Perfect Pacing: For a game with a great sense of pace
Poor Pacing: For a game that drags on, moves too quickly, or both
Ad-dicted: For a game that's riddle with ads