We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-21 · 7 min read · Independent comparison
If you want a direct-fit replacement cable for Astro A40, A40TR and A10 headsets with an inline volume wheel, choose LecLooc Replacement; if you need a flexible boom mic cable that adds a 360-degree adjustable mic and mute control to a wide range of 3.5mm headphones, choose MEIRIYFA Boom Mic Cable. These two cables get compared constantly because they both sit in the same search results, both end in a 3.5mm plug, and both promise "better audio for gaming." That's where the similarity stops. One is a purpose-built Astro replacement. The other is a general-purpose mic-and-audio cable with a rotating boom. If you buy the wrong one, you won't get a broken product — you'll get a cable that doesn't do the one job you actually bought it for.
• LecLooc Replacement — biggest strength: built specifically as an Astro A40/A40TR/A10 replacement, with a 5-pole connector to the headset and a 4-pole connector to your controller, MixAmp, PC splitter or phone.
• LecLooc Replacement — biggest trade-off: the inline wheel controls volume only. There is no mute button, so you'll mute at the console, PC or party chat level instead.
• MEIRIYFA Boom Mic Cable — biggest strength: a 360-degree adjustable boom mic plus an up/down volume and mute switch, so it turns ordinary 3.5mm headphones into a headset for calls, podcasts and voice chat.
• MEIRIYFA Boom Mic Cable — biggest trade-off: it's a general-purpose cable rather than a model-specific Astro replacement, and at 4.4 ft it's noticeably shorter than the LecLooc's 6.5 ft.
• Buy LecLooc Replacement if you already own an Astro A40, A40TR or A10 and just need the cable back.
• Buy MEIRIYFA Boom Mic Cable if you have a regular pair of 3.5mm headphones and want to add a microphone and inline mute.
The LecLooc Replacement is a single-purpose product, and that's its whole appeal. It's a 6.5-foot (2.0 m) braided cable designed to reconnect an Astro A40, A40TR or A10 headset to the rest of your setup. The connector layout is the part that matters: a 5-pole 3.5mm plug goes into the headset, and a 4-pole 3.5mm plug goes into your Xbox One controller, PlayStation 4, MixAmp, PC splitter, MP3 player or smartphone. That two-plug arrangement is exactly what Astro headsets expect, which is why this reads as a replacement rather than a generic cable.
There's one feature you need to understand before buying. The inline wheel adjusts headphone volume only — this cable has no mute button. If your routine is "reach down and mute myself instantly," you'll be doing that in software instead. Beyond that, it's plug-and-play with no drivers or setup.
Buy it if you own an Astro A40, A40TR or A10 and want the original-style connection back with a volume wheel and a longer, tougher cable. Skip it if you don't own an Astro headset, or if a mute button is non-negotiable for you.
MEIRIYFA Boom Mic Cable: Who It's For
The MEIRIYFA Boom Mic Cable solves a completely different problem. It's a 4.4-foot (136 cm) male-to-male 3.5mm cable with a boom microphone attached and an inline volume control switch you move up and down. The pitch is simple: take a normal pair of 3.5mm headphones and turn them into a proper headset. The boom mic rotates a full 360 degrees, so you can position it wherever it picks up your voice best, and the gold-plated 3.5mm plug is designed to seat securely in the headset so you're not fighting a loose connection mid-game.
Compatibility is deliberately broad. MEIRIYFA lists Mac, Windows PC, PlayStation 4, Xbox One, iPhone and Android as devices with a 3.5mm input port, and the cable is aimed at gaming voice chat, radio, Skype, podcasts, VOIP and live chat. The inline switch handles both volume and mute, which is the feature the LecLooc cable doesn't have — you can kill your mic with a flick instead of digging through menus.
The trade-offs are real, though. At 4.4 feet it's about two feet shorter than the LecLooc, which is fine at a desk or a controller in your lap but tight if you like to sit back from a TV. And because it's a universal cable rather than an Astro-specific replacement, it isn't the right pick if you're trying to restore an A40's original wiring — Astro headsets want that specific 5-pole/4-pole arrangement.
Buy it if you have standard 3.5mm headphones, want to add a microphone, and want mute and volume within thumb reach. Skip it if you need a genuine Astro replacement, or you need a longer run to a couch or TV.
• Best for Astro A40 / A40TR / A10 owners → LecLooc Replacement. It's built for that headset family, including the 5-pole headset connection.
• Best for adding a mic to ordinary headphones → MEIRIYFA Boom Mic Cable. The rotating boom mic is the entire point of the product.
• Best for instant muting → MEIRIYFA Boom Mic Cable. The up/down switch handles mute and volume; the LecLooc wheel is volume only.
• Best for reach and cable length → LecLooc Replacement. 6.5 ft versus 4.4 ft is roughly two extra feet of slack.
• Best for controller, MixAmp and PC-splitter setups → LecLooc Replacement. The 4-pole end is aimed at exactly those sources.
• Best for calls, podcasts, VOIP and live chat → MEIRIYFA Boom Mic Cable. Those are the use cases it's explicitly built around.
• Best for durability-oriented build → LecLooc Replacement, in my opinion, because the nylon braided jacket and oxygen-free copper core are the headline materials.
• Best for width of device compatibility → MEIRIYFA Boom Mic Cable. It lists Mac, Windows, PS4, Xbox One, iPhone and Android support.
If I had to pick one, I'd buy the LecLooc Replacement for anyone who already owns an Astro headset, because getting the connector layout right is the entire job and a braided 6.5-foot cable with a volume wheel covers the vast majority of gaming sessions. That said, I'd steer you to the MEIRIYFA Boom Mic Cable without hesitation if your headphones aren't Astros and you actually need a mic with a mute switch. Match the cable to the headset you own, not to the one with the longer feature list — in this comparison, the "better" cable is simply the one that fits your gear.
The LecLooc Replacement is the one designed for that job. It uses a 5-pole 3.5mm plug for the headset and a 4-pole plug for the Xbox One controller, PS4, MixAmp or PC splitter. The MEIRIYFA cable is a general-purpose boom mic cable, not an Astro-specific replacement.
No. The inline wheel controls headphone volume only, and the product listing states plainly that this cable has no mute button. If you want one-touch muting, the MEIRIYFA Boom Mic Cable has a switch that handles both mute and volume.
I don't quote prices here because they change often. Both are budget accessories, so the practical move is to check the current price on Amazon using the button on this page and compare the two side by side before deciding.
I wouldn't count on it. It's a male-to-male 3.5mm cable with a boom mic, built for headphones with a standard 3.5mm input, not for the specific connector setup Astro A40, A40TR and A10 headsets use. For those headsets, the LecLooc Replacement is the correct fit.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.