The Exploration, Discussion and Innovation regarding Menstrual Products, with a Particular Focus to Inclusive Design for People with Physical Impairments.

The aim is to promote design innovation within the menstrual product industry, with consideration for people who are unable to use the limited product line available.

Within the participatory collaboration, the experience is shared through the voice of whom has encountered menstrual management challenges with a physical impairment. The objective of this is to demonstrate a reality and gain insight into exclusivity for people in this context.

In response to the case study and topic, the practice of design is identified in a series of speculative design curations. Each image addresses an area of inquiry that transcribes narrative, or speculates 'solution' and preposes potential innovation.

The connection to sustainability and design focuses on equality among all people of whom are physically impaired and feel limited to choice concerning the management of Menstruation. The design aspect probes the fundamental necessity for innovation that considers individual unique requirements in this context.

There are many challenges and contentious discussions around the subject of Menstruation. From the taboo, stigma and varied beliefs; there also comes the practicality of managing Menstruation. However, the physicality of using available products is essential to address within the Menstrual industry, for design innovation and equality among users.

A process that is thought to be a discreet and a personal task for the majority, though inconvenient, managing menstrual blood is a quick and easy 'fix' with the products available to absorb or collect one's flow. Though is it? The limited products available pose an additional cost, costs of either harming the environment due to the industries plastic consumption and medical concerns such as toxic shock syndrome. Furthermore, Menstrual products are considered too expensive for a necessity that is otherwise classed as a 'luxury'. However, in March 2020, the UK Chancellor promised to remove this 'Luxury' VAT from January 2021. (1)

Much conversation has opened up around the topic of Menstruation, particularly those focused on the industries product materials such as protests against the plastic in period products. Another prominent objection is tax prices on Menstrual items. Though these are two fundamental aspects to tackle for different reasons, they do not address the much-needed design shift within the industry. However, protesting against disposable menstrual products such as tampons and sanitary towels further limits the choice without proposing a suitable design alternative and considering the many who heavily rely on disposable products.

There are very few options for reusable menstrual products. However, reusable does not necessarily mean it is 'sustainable'. Reusable products such as Menstrual cups are often complex to use, and one would need to have specific mobility to insert and remove; also the design does not consider the possibility of 'abnormalities' of one's cervix and internal functions. Though the Menstrual cup design is efficient and has additional benefits such as affordances, the audiences for this product are limited. Moreover, reusable products such as pads and menstrual underwear are often expensive to buy and may need to be changed multiple times a day, depending on the heaviness of one's menstrual flow. In addition to reusable menstrual fabrics, they will need to be washed in regular intervals which can prove to be a challenging task for some.

Eco-ableism

Eco- ableism is a form of perception in favour of 'able-bodied' people. (2) For instance, the environmental movement tackles many issues concerning the manufacturing of single-use plastics, within various industries, including those of the menstrual product industry. However, the protest to rid disposable products lacks consideration to people who heavily rely on using single-use menstrual products. The same reliance can be identified in other disposable products from a diverse range of industries. Disposable products can be beneficial and create a sense of independence for people who are unable to use the reusable and a 'sustainable' alternative. For instance, the function of a disposable shower gel bottle can provide ergonomic inclusiveness that is extremely helpful to those with limited mobility. Compared to the suggested 'sustainable' alternatives such as a bar of a solid soap, which can pose challenges to use, challenges which are not considered when focused predominantly on environmental concerns. Considering the exclusivity, I have to protest the protest to disposing of the disposable. While I agree with the environmental movement, it would be good to consider the people who are impacted negatively by these actions, as the dependence on the single-use product can produce independence.

Curated Collection of Attempted 'MIY' & Material Innovations.

The series of menstrual cup shapes have been moulded with a 3D pen to create the simplistic appearance of a Cup design. Though these 3D extruded imitations are not functional, the idea represents the possibility of adapting the form of an existing product.

The knitted sample signifies a 'make it yourself (MIY) methods of absorption while reaping the benefits of reusability.

Lastly, the dark red obscure moulds describe the material 'innovation' aspect. They are made from a water-soluble polysaccharide polymer, produced from starch by the fungus Aureobasidium, called Pullulan. Pullulan is widely used as a coating agent for food and commonly used in instant beverages, creams, sauces, confectionery, among more. Moreover, It is typically used for edible packaging films in japan, due to it tasteless and odourless, application while providing bulk, texture and a has excellent oxygen barrier properties, exceptional moisture retention, and restricts fungal growth.

The material has proved itself to be an efficient packaging ingredient. The potential of Pullulan and it's many properties, 'Plastic' packaging for many items, including those in the menstrual industry, could consider this innovation, and reduce the industries high plastic consumption. (3)

Fig .1 - 'Make it Yourself' (MIY) Menstrual products are a great way to encourage reusability and affordability aspects. This image demonstrates my representation of 'MIY' in response to these issues of environmentally harmful materials, as well as the prices of commercially available products. The selection of objects are experimentations of both material innovation and product alternative.



These Images are 'Real world' visuals that demonstrate where and how the making of these objects would be situated in a domestic environment.

3D Moulded Menstrual Cup.

Fig .2 - Drawing around the menstrual cup with a 3D pen to imitate the form. Using the menstrual cup as a template allows the 3D mould easily removed from the flexible silicone.


'Bioplastic' Material Innovation.

Pull.mp4

Vid .1 - Two essential ingredients, water and powder, formed Pullulan. The liquid produces a slime-like substance which is then applied to a template and solidifies overnight. The clip shows the simple process to produce the 'bioplastic'—a non- complex approach to start innovating.


'MIY' Menstrual Products.

Fig .3 - Knitting is an excellent example of a 'MIY' technique as its a very domesticated craft and can be made with many absorbent materials.

Studio Exhibition. (Part. 1)

Fig .4 - For Studio formative part 1 exhibition, I curated an interactive exhibit, which surveyed the audience to respond on what they thought to be the most and least 'efficient' product to use for managing Menstruation.

Fig .5 - Tampons were used as stamps for printing red or green marks that represent the opinions. This approach creates a humour element around the publicly displayed 'taboo' subject. It opened up a conversation concerning Menstruation, menstrual products and exclusivity. The exhibition turned out to be a slightly educational display for some, as there were people who did not know about specific products, their functions or existence. The opinions were diverse and interesting points were made about the experience of people, and these methods, of which, being both good and bad.

Analyses of Public Response.

The question was open to interpretation; some people thought the question was more concerning the environment, some about the efficiency of use and others thought it was concerning product cost. However, the results of the colour coordinated sheets concluded: (Number represents the amount of people)

Menstrual Cups

LEAST 'EFFICIENT' - 2

MOST 'EFFICIENT' - 17

Period Underwear

LEAST 'EFFICIENT' - 12

MOST 'EFFICIENT' - 14

Contraception

LEAST 'EFFICIENT' - 20

MOST 'EFFICIENT' - 4

Pad(s)

LEAST 'EFFICIENT' - 20

MOST 'EFFICIENT' - 11

Tampons

LEAST 'EFFICIENT' - 12

MOST 'EFFICIENT' - 7

Sea Sponge

LEAST 'EFFICIENT' - 12

MOST 'EFFICIENT' - 4

Collage Illustrations.

Collage .1 - Senses.

Another element within the studio exhibition was a series of collages that abstractly represent the issues around the limits of choice to manage Menstruation.

The first image primarily expresses the association of 'impairment' and menstrual management. The loss of senses in this instance can potentially pose challenges for some. For example, challenges distinguishing menstrual blood from other fluids, as well as, knowing when the 'Product' has reached capacity and needs to be changed. (4)

In a more light-hearted narrative, the moon image correlates the beliefs of Menstruation cycles and the relationship with the lunar phases.


Collage .2 - Sterilisation.

The second image visualises the narrative of the contraceptive method in the context of menstrual suppression. There are many reasons why someone might choose to use contraception, as well as responding successfully to their body. However, the choice of this method and its 'success' is not guaranteed. For some, it may be the last resort, and as a result, may not fulfil the expectations and respond to the body well.

The variations of contraceptive methods such as the Pill, Inplant, Injection and even Hysterectomy Surgery may be a harmful risk and additional hazards for those who are medically vulnerable. In contrast, contraceptives are an excellent prospect for some. Still, the transparency of the potential effects that these hormonal manipulators can have on the mind and body is hard to generalise to the diverse set of groups.

Collage .3 - Physicality.

The third collage represents the material in which disposable menstrual product derives. A scenic image, consisting of a cotton field and women are inserting and removing tampons, a concept that manifests the type of movement required to use this conventional product. The colourful round star behind these women is not an identifiable message without explicit explanation; however it is a wheelchair wheel, this was to create the contrasts of movement, and the ability to use this product without the dexterity of one's legs. (5)


Collage .4 - The Menstrual Aesthetic.

Lastly, this image is purely aesthetic. The hands behind the shark fins offer this cervix and menstruating body the products in which are conventionally used to manage the flow of blood.



(1) George, Amika. “The Best News in the Budget Is That Tampon Tax Has Been Abolished. Period. .” The Telegraph. Telegraph Media Group, March 11, 2020. https://www.telegraph.co.uk/women/politics/best-news-budget-tampon-tax-has-abolished-period/.(2)Mary Imgrund, “Eco-Ableism: What It Is, Why It Matters and How It Affects Disabled People,” Eco Warrior Princess, November 11, 2018, https://ecowarriorprincess.net/2018/08/eco-ableism-what-it-is-why-it-matters-how-affects-disabled-people/.(3)YOSHIO TSUJISAKA and MASAKAZU MITSUHASHI, “Pullulan,” Pullulan - an overview | ScienceDirect Topics, accessed October 1, 2019, https://www.sciencedirect.com/topics/agricultural-and-biological-sciences/pullulan.(4)Clár McWeeney, “Disabilities and Menstruation,” Disabilities and menstruation (Clue, February 24, 2020), https://helloclue.com/articles/cycle-a-z/menstruating-while-disabled.(5)Bridget Duckworth, “Overview of Menstrual Management for Disabled Women,” Canadian Journal of Occupational Therapy 53, no. 1 (1986): pp. 25-29, https://doi.org/10.1177/000841748605300106.