How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-25 · 7 min read · Independent comparison
• KEESHA 100SG100 — biggest strength: It is a complete replacement set. You get an actual 12-inch stainless steel crumb tray plus four non-stick black liners, so you can restore a lost or worn tray and protect it at the same time.
• KEESHA 100SG100 — biggest trade-off: It is built around the Ninja Foodi flip-oven platform, so it only makes sense if your model appears on that compatibility list.
• SOKHOND Tray Liners — biggest strength: Three reusable silicone liners sized 11.8 by 10.6 inches that trap crumbs and grease and wipe clean, which is exactly the kind of mess control a French door oven needs.
• SOKHOND Tray Liners — biggest trade-off: This is a liner set, not a tray. If your original crumb tray is missing, these mats sit on top of what you already have — they do not replace it.
• Who each pick is for: KEESHA for a Ninja Foodi owner who wants a fresh tray with liners included; SOKHOND for a Midea Flexify owner who just wants easier cleanup.
The KEESHA 100SG100 is a crumb tray replacement set, and the "set" part matters. In the box you get one new replacement crumb tray and four black liners. The tray itself is 12 inches, made of 304 stainless steel, and it is designed to slot into the Ninja Foodi digital air fry countertop ovens — the flip-away models like the SP101, SP100, SP080, SP151, SP201, SP301 and the FT102 variants, along with the many color-suffix versions of those same ovens.
What that means in daily use: the steel tray catches the crumbs and drips that fall below the cooking rack, and the liners sit on top as a barrier you can pull out and rinse. The liners are PTFE with a non-stick surface, BPA-free and PFOA-free, and they are dishwasher safe. So the realistic routine is simple — lift the liner, wipe or rinse it, and let the tray underneath stay mostly clean instead of scrubbing it every time you cook.
Who should buy it: someone whose Ninja Foodi flip oven is missing its crumb tray, or whose tray has gotten so stained and grimy that a replacement makes more sense than another round of scrubbing. You get the tray and the liners together, which is the practical combination, because the liners are what actually keep the tray clean.
One usage note worth respecting: the liners handle a maximum of 480°F, and KEESHA recommends staying below 450°F to protect their service life. That is easy to live with, but it is a real ceiling if you like running your oven at its highest settings for long stretches.
SOKHOND Tray Liners: Who It's For
The SOKHOND Tray Liners set is three reusable silicone mats, each 11.8 inches long by 10.6 inches wide, intended for the Midea Flexify French door toaster oven and air fryer combo, the 26.4 QT, 10-in-1 countertop model. The liners are sized to sit on the tray or rack and catch what falls, so the basket and tray below stay far cleaner than they would otherwise.
The whole pitch here is cleanup. Silicone traps crumbs and grease instead of letting them bake onto metal, and when you are done you wipe it down or rinse it. That is the difference between a two-minute post-dinner task and a soak-and-scrub session. The material is non-toxic silicone with no chemical odor, and it is rated to 450°F (230°C).
SOKHOND also makes an environmental argument that holds up: unlike paper liners you throw away after one use, silicone can be reused over and over, and it will not flutter up into the heating element the way a lightweight paper liner can. If you have ever watched a paper liner lift and curl in a hot oven, that safety point lands.
Who should buy it: Midea Flexify owners who want the crumb tray and basket to stay cleaner with less effort, and who like the idea of three mats so one can be in the wash while another is in use. The multicolor set also makes it easy to rotate them.
Who should skip it: anyone hoping this replaces a missing crumb tray. It does not — these are liners, and they need something solid underneath. Skip it too if your oven is not the Midea Flexify French door combo, since the 11.8 by 10.6 inch sizing is chosen for that interior.
SOKHOND's own guidance is worth following: always place the mat on the tray or rack, never directly on the heating element, and skip the preheat mode to extend its lifespan. That is standard silicone care, and it keeps the mats flat and usable for a long time.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for replacing a missing or damaged crumb tray → KEESHA 100SG100. It is an actual 12-inch 304 stainless steel tray, not just a mat.
• Best for Ninja Foodi flip-oven owners → KEESHA 100SG100. The compatibility list covers SP101, SP100, SP080, SP151, SP201, SP301, SP102, SP101A/BK/C/CM/CO/NP/Q/QBK/QCM/QNV/QRD and the FT102 variants.
• Best for Midea Flexify French door combo owners → SOKHOND Tray Liners. Sized 11.8 by 10.6 inches for that 26.4 QT, 10-in-1 oven.
• Best if you want both a tray and liners in one purchase → KEESHA 100SG100. One tray plus four liners in a single set.
• Best if you want multiple liners to rotate → SOKHOND Tray Liners. Three mats, so there is always a clean one ready.
• Best for dishwasher convenience → KEESHA 100SG100. The black liners are explicitly dishwasher safe.
• Best heat ceiling → KEESHA 100SG100. Liners rated to 480°F, with a recommendation to stay under 450°F; SOKHOND is rated to 450°F.
In my opinion, the deciding question is whether you need a tray or just want to keep one clean. If your Ninja Foodi flip oven is missing its crumb tray, or the tray is beyond saving, I would buy the KEESHA 100SG100 — it gives you the steel tray and four liners in one shot, and the liners do the daily dirty work so the tray stays presentable. If your Midea Flexify already has its tray and you simply want crumbs and grease to stop welding themselves to it, I would buy the SOKHOND Tray Liners. Three mats, a 450°F rating, and a cleanup routine that takes seconds. That is the honest split.
how to clean air fryer crumb tray
Pull the tray out once the oven is fully cool, then wipe it with a damp cloth and mild dish soap. For the KEESHA 100SG100, the simplest approach is to use the included non-stick liners as a barrier and just rinse those — they are dishwasher safe — so the stainless tray itself rarely needs more than a wipe.
how to clean breville air fryer crumb tray
Breville ovens are a different platform from both products here, so check your own model's tray before buying either. The general method still applies: let it cool, remove the tray, and wash with warm water and mild soap. If you own a Midea Flexify instead, the SOKHOND liners sit on the tray and catch the mess so you wipe silicone rather than scrub metal.
how to clean ninja air fryer crumb tray
On Ninja Foodi flip ovens, slide the crumb tray out from under the cooking area once it has cooled. The KEESHA 100SG100 is made for exactly these ovens, and its PTFE liners are reusable and dishwasher safe, so crumbs and grease land on the liner instead of baking onto the steel tray.
how to get grease stains off of air fryer crumb tray
Baked-on grease usually needs a warm soak with dish soap before a soft scrub. The easier long-term fix is prevention: the SOKHOND silicone liners trap grease before it reaches the tray, and the KEESHA liners do the same on Ninja Foodi flip ovens — both are rated to at least 450°F for normal air fryer use.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: SIUDANGKA Crumb Tray Replacement vs Anniparts 304: Air Fryer, DNSSY Air Fryer Liners vs LYHOLKEER Silicone Air Fryer, Generic AAFEEN 100 vs Fukaisu 8: Air Fryer Parchment Liners