Labor Markets and the Rise of Contractor Firms
Abstract: This paper examines how competition among contractor firms affects wages of both outsourced and in-house workers. Using matched employer-employee and balance-sheet data for France (2009–2021), I document substantial heterogeneity in outsourcing across local labor markets: despite a stable average outsourcing share, markets with initially high outsourcing experience significant increases, driven by a surge in contractor-firm entry. Exploiting a shift-share instrument based on firms’ initial employment composition, I find that a one-standard-deviation increase in outsourcing exposure reduces contractor firms’ profit margins by about 13 percentage points and contractor firms' workers’ hourly wages by roughly 8\%, while raising profits, employment, and wages at non-contractor firms. To interpret these findings, I develop a search-and-matching model with endogenous outsourcing and Cournot competition among contractor firms. Firms choose between outsourcing and in-house production based on heterogeneous fixed costs. The model shows that when fixed costs are high relative to in-house productivity, outsourcing becomes widespread, and lower cost dispersion can further expand it by reducing the price elasticity of demand. A competition shock driven by lower vacancy-posting costs at contractor firms shifts employment toward outsourcing and widens the wage gap between outsourced and in-house workers. Calibrated to French local labor markets, the quantitative model accounts for about 30\% of the estimated widening of this gap, with margin compression translating into wage losses concentrated among workers already employed at contractor firms.
Presentations: Macro Seminar (PSE), Séminaire de l'ERUDITE (Créteil University), Brown Bag Seminar of Innovation Economics (Collège de France), Labor/Public Workshop (Sciences Po), 7th QMUL PhD Workshop in Economics and Finance, 24th Journées LAGV (AMSE), IZA@LISER Summer School in Labor Economics 2026