How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-24 · 6 min read · Independent comparison
• JECOMPRIS 3 — biggest strength: A thick silicone tray (8.26 x 8.26 x 1.77 in) with real depth, so it holds chicken legs, wings and chips in place and keeps grease and crumbs off the basket floor. You get three of them.
• JECOMPRIS 3 — biggest trade-off: Solid silicone blocks airflow underneath the food, so you lose some of the hot-air circulation that makes air-fried chicken legs crispy. It also can't go in the dishwasher.
• BUGUUYO 4pcs — biggest strength: Thin (0.04 in) PTFE mats with ventilation holes that let hot air move under and around the food, plus they're dishwasher safe. Four mats in the pack.
• BUGUUYO 4pcs — biggest trade-off: Almost no depth and a white surface that shows every stain, so they do little to contain a messy, marinated batch of chicken legs.
• Who each pick is for: JECOMPRIS 3 for the cook who wants easy cleanup and batch lifting; BUGUUYO 4pcs for the cook who prioritizes even browning and crispy skin.
JECOMPRIS 3 is a set of three silicone air fryer trays, each measuring 8.26 x 8.26 x 1.77 inches. The depth is the whole point. Most air fryer liners are flat sheets you lay on the basket floor; this one is a shallow dish with raised sides, so a row of chicken legs sits inside it rather than directly on the basket grate. That matters when you're cooking something that releases fat — the tray catches the drippings instead of letting them pool and burn onto the basket.
In my opinion, this set fits two kinds of cooks: the one who rotates batches and wants a clean liner ready to go (three mats make that easy), and the one who hates scrubbing a basket after a greasy cook. Skip it if crispy skin is your non-negotiable goal. Solid silicone under the food means the underside of a chicken leg steams more than it crisps. That's a real trade-off, not a knock on the design — it's just what a deep tray does.
BUGUUYO 4pcs: Who It's For
BUGUUYO 4pcs takes the opposite approach. These are thin PTFE mats, 9 x 9 x 0.04 inches, in white. The 0.04-inch thickness tells you everything: these are flat sheets, not trays. The feature that earns them a place in your basket is the ventilation holes. Hot air passes through those holes and reaches the underside of your chicken legs, which is exactly what you want if the goal is browned, crisp skin all the way around rather than just on top.
They're rated dishwasher safe, which removes the hand-washing step entirely — a genuine convenience if you cook air fryer chicken legs a few times a week, since greasy liners pile up fast. The smooth surface is designed for clean food release, and the sheets list bread, chips, snacks, chicken wings and legs among suitable foods. The package is four mats, so you can keep a couple in rotation while the others are in the wash.
The honest trade-offs: white PTFE stains, and thin flat mats do nothing to contain marinade or drippings — a wet rub will run straight through the holes onto the basket. They're also flexible and light, so they need to sit flat before you load food on. Buy these if even heating and crispiness rank above tidiness. Skip them if you're cooking saucy, sticky chicken legs and want zero mess.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for crispy skin → BUGUUYO 4pcs. The ventilation holes let air circulate under the food, which a solid silicone tray can't do.
• Best for catching drips and grease → JECOMPRIS 3. The 1.77-inch depth contains what a 0.04-inch flat mat lets through.
• Best for batch cooking and rotation → JECOMPRIS 3. Three deep trays hold more food per liner; four thin mats are better for back-to-back small batches.
• Best for dry-seasoned chicken legs → BUGUUYO 4pcs. Rubs and dry spices stay put and the holes keep the underside browning.
• Best for marinated or saucy chicken legs → JECOMPRIS 3. Raised sides keep wet marinade off the basket floor.
• Best for a tidy-looking basket after cooking → JECOMPRIS 3. Less scraping and scrubbing of the basket itself.
• Best for stacking and storing in a drawer → BUGUUYO 4pcs. At 0.04 inches thick, four mats take up almost no space.
I'd buy JECOMPRIS 3 for chicken legs specifically. Legs are a greasy, unevenly shaped cut, and the deep silicone tray handles that mess better than a flat perforated sheet — you lift the whole tray out, rinse it, and the basket stays clean. The three-pack means you're never stuck hand-washing mid-cook. That said, if your priority is shatteringly crisp skin rather than easy cleanup, BUGUUYO 4pcs is the smarter pick, and I'd say so without hesitation. Check the current price on Amazon for both before deciding, since the value math depends on what each is going for when you buy.
how to air fry chicken legs
Pat the legs dry, season them, and arrange them in a single layer so hot air can reach every surface. If you're using a JECOMPRIS 3 tray, leave a little space between pieces rather than crowding them, and flip them partway through so both sides brown. With BUGUUYO 4pcs, the ventilation holes do some of that work for you, but flipping still helps.
how to air fryer chicken legs and thighs
Legs and thighs cook at similar rates because both are dark meat, but thighs are thicker, so give them a few extra minutes. Use a liner that fits your basket without blocking airflow — a flat BUGUUYO mat with holes suits mixed pieces well, while a deep JECOMPRIS tray works if you're cooking a full, greasy batch and want the drippings contained.
how to air fry chicken legs and thighs
Keep pieces in one layer, don't stack them, and check doneness at the thickest point rather than going by time alone. Both liners here are reusable and heat resistant, so you can run multiple batches back to back — just remember JECOMPRIS trays are hand-wash and BUGUUYO mats are dishwasher safe, which affects how fast you can turn batches around.
how to air fry chicken legs crispy
Dry the skin thoroughly before cooking and avoid wet marinades, which steam the skin instead of crisping it. This is where BUGUUYO 4pcs has the edge: its perforated PTFE surface lets hot air hit the underside of the legs. A solid silicone tray like JECOMPRIS 3 will still give you good results, but expect slightly softer skin on the side resting against the mat.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: JECOMPRIS Non-Stick Air Fryer vs VICASKY Rotisserie Chicken Fork, RTT Chicken Leg vs Turbo Trusser Chicken I As: Air Fryer, Abizarch 4Pcs vs COSMOBETTY 2pcs: Air Fryer Recipes for