Is All Pudding Edible?

This question was recently posed to us. Naturally, our initial thoughts were "Of course all pudding is edible! Now, be gone with you, and stop wasting our valuable time on such silly questions!" Then, after some reflection, we thought that maybe we were being a bit of a hasty pudding ourselves.

We received the following submission to our Pudding Determination form:

After careful, sometimes heated deliberations with our distinguished panel of judges (which included two different brands of cheap wine, and a possible referral to the United Nations Select Commission on the Nature of Gelatinous Foodstuffs - UNSCNGF) our experts have concluded that Pudding the Rescue Cat is pudding. However, we strongly recommend that this particular pudding be enjoyed in a manner that would not include eating her or causing her trauma in any other way. Pudding is officially declared to be an inedible pudding. Our management team wishes her a long and happy puddingly life.