Publication :
Barriola, I.; Deffains, B.; & Musy, O. (2023). Law and inequality: A comparative approach to the distributive implications of legal systems. International Review of Law and Economics, 106139. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0144818823000170
The literature on legal traditions focuses on the comparative macroeconomic effects of legal systems, concentrating on efficiency alone and leaving distributive issues to taxation. However, a country’s legal structure also conditions the primary distribution of income and may have a comparative advantage over taxation as a distributive instrument. We use cross-section and panel estimates to show that the level of income inequality in a country is correlated with its legal system. By several measures of inequality, common law countries are on average more unequal than civil law countries. We explain these results by the nature of the systems. The looser regulation in common law countries limits their capacity to achieve social objectives such as combating income inequality.
Working Papers :
One Map to Rule Them All: Incumbent Protection in the 2010 French Redistricting Job Market Paper
Draft: https://drive.google.com/file/d/1gTqxCOt9VDPk6txbNQvFaTOPg85RFEG9/view?usp=sharing
This paper evaluates the 2010 redistricting of French legislative constituencies by comparing the adopted map with 100,000 simulated plans in each of 91 French departments. We show that the adopted map exhibits no partisan bias, as it does not award any additional seats to the right-wing majority that drew it. Instead, it protects incumbent Members of Parliament (MPs) from both political camps by placing them in constituencies that are approximately 1.3 percentage points more favorable to them. Although redistricting gave the government an opportunity to reset incumbents' positions, the adopted map preserved their advantage. Since the adopted map keeps most of incumbents' former electorate, much of this advantage is inherited. However, even relative to simulated plans that retain as much of this electorate, the adopted map places incumbents in more favorable constituencies, an advantage that continuity alone cannot explain. Retention accounts for 63% of the total protection, and the choice of boundaries for the remaining 37%. We reconstruct the maps corresponding to different stages of the reform, namely the government's initial proposal and the map resulting from the amendments requested by the independent electoral commission. The commission's requests reduced this protection, and later changes partly restored it, a pattern consistent with a government seeking to protect incumbents. This boundary advantage holds with presidential votes, which do not depend on the identity of local candidates. The protection primarily benefits MPs who hold positions of power in the National Assembly or lead local executives. The 2010 redistricting thus reflects less partisan gerrymandering than a bipartisan preservation of incumbents' advantage, a form of protection that standard tests of partisan bias would miss.
Electoral Inequalities and Outcomes in France: An Algorithmic Redistricting Approach
Draft: https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=6113887
This paper examines the impact of electoral geography and redistricting on political representation in France. Using an algorithmic approach, we generate 1,000 alternative redistricting plans for 72 departments based on the 2017 legislative election. These simulated plans allow us to analyze two main issues. First, we study how alternative district maps affect electoral outcomes. We show that the electoral performance of the far right and the right is highly sensitive to redistricting, while the left exhibits intermediate sensitivity and the center limited sensitivity. We propose a definition to identify atypical redistricting plans at the departmental level associated with partisan bias, which can be linked to gerrymandering. Second, we assess how French electoral geography may generate inequalities in representation. Because voters in small constituencies carry more electoral weight than those in large ones, we analyze population imbalances across constituencies. Moreover, as political preferences are not proportionally distributed, some groups may be overrepresented or underrepresented. We examine how electoral geography may structurally misrepresent certain groups of voters. Beyond voting preferences, we conduct the same analysis for groups defined by socioeconomic characteristics.
The Death of Distance: Internet and Political Trust in Africa, with R. Chaba (LEMMA)
Draft: https://drive.google.com/file/d/1RjTVJw5uzGk9VCgnQvZOPKAfjrXJL_bj/view?usp=sharing
This paper shows that internet use reduces spatial disparities in political trust within Sub-Saharan African countries. We combine geocoded Afrobarometer surveys with mobile internet coverage data from the GSM Association. First, we use a border discontinuity design comparing ethnic groups divided by national boundaries to show that remote citizens report higher political trust than those near capital cities. Then, we estimate how internet use interacts with distance from the capital, instrumenting internet use with potential 3G coverage. We find that connectivity erodes the distance–trust gradient: at the median level of district internet use it has already fallen by a third. In remote districts where internet use is widespread, citizens perceive more corruption among politicians and become more critical, aligning with opinions typically found near capitals. The shift is concentrated in countries where corruption is high and among less educated citizens, consistent with an informational mechanism. These changes translate into increased demand for political accountability and reduced electoral support for incumbents.
Ongoing Research :
One Person, One Vote, One Euro? Redistricting and Departmental Grants after France’s 2015 Cantonal Reform
What Can We Learn from Open Court Data? Evidence from French Judgments (Postdoctoral project, SCAI. Large-scale analysis of French court decisions (Judilibre) using LLM-based extraction)