How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-24 · 7 min read · Independent comparison
• HQT 8QT — biggest strength: purpose-built for one machine, the Gourmia GAF838 8-quart air fryer, with a nonstick double-layer coating, a grab handle and a dishwasher-safe design.
• HQT 8QT — biggest trade-off: it is locked to that single 8QT Gourmia model, and the nonstick coating needs gentle care — no abrasive pads or metal scouring balls.
• Itsall Stainless Steel Replace — biggest strength: solid SUS304 stainless steel with no coating at all, so there is nothing to peel, flake or wear through, and it handles heat up to 500°F.
• Itsall Stainless Steel Replace — biggest trade-off: it only fits Ninja Crispi FN090, FN091, FN100, FN101 and FN103 with 2.5Qt or 4Qt glass containers — not 5-cup or 6-cup, and never in a microwave.
• Who each pick is for: HQT 8QT for the Gourmia 8QT owner who wants an easy-release, easy-clean tray; Itsall for the Ninja Crispi owner who wants a bare-metal rack that will outlast any coating.
The HQT 8QT is a square crisper plate and grill rack designed around a single air fryer: the Gourmia GAF838 8-quart digital model. That focus is the whole point. Because it is shaped for that basket, it sits in as a replacement tray or insert grate rather than a generic add-on you have to fight into place. The spec sheet does note one honest caveat — the four feet can be adjusted for tightness so the tray matches your specific unit, which is a sensible touch when you are dropping a plate into a basket you already own.
The build is food-grade carbon steel with a double-layer nonstick coating that the maker describes as high-temperature resistant and slow to flake. It is BPA-free and stated to meet FDA standards, so it is aimed at direct food contact. The design details are the practical ones: a handle so you can lift it out of a hot basket without tongs gymnastics, and dishwasher-safe construction for the nights you cannot be bothered. The square shape gives you a flat, defined cooking surface in an 8QT basket, which is what you want when you are laying out wings, vegetable pieces or a fillet and would rather they sit on a grate than sink into the bottom.
Who should buy it: anyone running the Gourmia GAF838 8QT who wants a coated, easy-release tray with a handle, and who values the extras in the box — a nonstick cleaning cloth and eight silicone rubber feet to swap in as the originals wear. Who should skip it: anyone with a different air fryer brand or size. This is not a universal rack. If your basket is not the GAF838 8QT, this is the wrong purchase, full stop. Also skip it if you specifically want an uncoated metal surface — that is not what this is, and the coating is the reason it releases food so easily.
The Itsall rack goes the opposite direction on materials. It is solid SUS304 stainless steel with no coating whatsoever, which means there is no nonstick layer to chip, peel or degrade over time. For anyone who has watched a coated accessory start flaking after months of high heat, that is the entire appeal. It is rated for air frying and oven use up to 500°F, and the seamless welded wire construction is built to hold its shape instead of warping into a wavy mess.
The design is all about airflow. It is an elevated rack, so food sits above the floor of the container and hot air circulates underneath as well as over the top — that is how you get more even browning instead of a soggy underside. The edges are rounded and free of sharp points, which matters more than people expect when you are reaching into a hot glass container. It is dishwasher safe and stands up to metal utensils, so you are not babying it the way you would a coated tray.
Compatibility is the catch, and it is a strict one. This fits Ninja Crispi models FN090, FN091, FN100, FN101 and FN103, and only with the 2.5Qt and 4Qt glass containers. It does not fit 5-cup or 6-cup containers, and it must not go in a microwave. Who should buy it: Ninja Crispi owners with the right glass container size who want a coating-free, long-haul rack they can scrub without worry. Who should skip it: anyone with a Gourmia, anyone with a 5-cup or 6-cup Crispi container, and anyone who wants a microwave-safe accessory. No tools are needed — you drop it in, cook, and let it cool before lifting it out.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for a Gourmia GAF838 8QT owner → HQT 8QT. It is made for that exact model, not a universal fit.
• Best for coating-free cooking → Itsall Stainless Steel Replace. Solid SUS304, no coating to peel or degrade.
• Best for easy release and easy cleanup → HQT 8QT. Double-layer nonstick plus a handle and dishwasher-safe design.
• Best for high-heat tolerance → Itsall Stainless Steel Replace. Rated stable up to 500°F.
• Best for airflow and even browning → Itsall Stainless Steel Replace. The elevated wire rack lets heat circulate under the food.
• Best for scratch resistance → Itsall Stainless Steel Replace. Safe with metal utensils; the HQT coating should not meet abrasive pads or metal balls.
• Best for out-of-the-box extras → HQT 8QT. Ships with a nonstick cleaning cloth and eight spare silicone rubber feet.
If I owned the Gourmia GAF838 8QT, I would buy the HQT 8QT — it is purpose-built for that basket, the handle makes hot-basket handling genuinely easier, and a nonstick surface plus dishwasher-safe cleaning is the low-effort path for weeknight cooking. If I owned a Ninja Crispi with a 2.5Qt or 4Qt glass container, I would buy the Itsall Stainless Steel Replace instead. In my opinion, bare SUS304 is the smarter long-term accessory: nothing to flake, nothing to baby, and the elevated wire design does more for even browning. Match the rack to your machine first — that decides it before anything else.
how to use air fryer rack
Place the rack inside your air fryer basket or compatible glass container, then set food on top of it rather than on the floor of the basket. The elevated design lets hot air circulate underneath, which is how the Itsall rack supports more even cooking. For the HQT tray, adjust the tightness of the four feet so it sits level in the Gourmia GAF838, and use the handle to lift it out.
how to clean air fryer rack
Both racks are dishwasher safe, so the dishwasher is the easy route. The HQT plate has a double-layer nonstick coating, and the maker specifically warns against rough abrasive cloths or metal scouring balls that would damage it — that is why a nonstick cleaning cloth is included. The Itsall rack is uncoated SUS304 stainless steel and tolerates metal utensils, so a normal scrub is fine.
how to air fry rack of lamb
A rack of lamb is a thick, high-heat cook, and both accessories are designed for that kind of work. The key is airflow: an elevated rack like the Itsall lifts the meat so heat circulates around it, and it stays stable under high heat up to 500°F. The HQT tray is rated high-temperature resistant with a nonstick surface, so the meat releases rather than sticking.
how to air fry rack of ribs
Ribs need steady heat and a rack that will not sag under weight. The Itsall's seamless welded wire structure is built to hold its shape, and the elevated design keeps the underside from sitting in rendered fat. If you are using the HQT, keep in mind it fits the Gourmia GAF838 8QT specifically, and its adjustable feet let you level the tray inside the basket.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: HOODANCOS Air Fryer Rack vs OUNONA Stainless Steel Air, HQT 8QT vs INFRAOVENS Air Fryer Parchment: Power XL Air, AODPWEN 4pcs vs KAWENDE Stainless Square Steel: Air Fryer