How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-19 · 7 min read · Independent comparison
• hp Gaming Headset — biggest strength: very light at 11.5 ounces with soft protein leather over-ear pads, a multi-point headbeam and a plug-and-play 3.5mm + USB setup that keeps things simple.
• hp Gaming Headset — biggest trade-off: it's a modest, comfort-first design with a single flexible mic and no driver size listed, so it's not the pick if raw bass output is your priority.
• BENGOO G9900 — biggest strength: a 50mm magnetic neodymium driver for strong bass, a 720° flexible noise-cancelling mic with a dedicated noise reduction chip, and on-ear volume plus one-key mute.
• BENGOO G9900 — biggest trade-off: it's heavier at 428 g and its LED lighting depends on the USB plug, so it's less of a grab-and-go headset for long sessions if weight bothers you.
• Pick hp Gaming Headset if you want light, comfortable, low-fuss listening across PS4, Xbox One, PC, Switch, laptop, tablet and phone.
• Pick BENGOO G9900 if you want punchier bass, a more adjustable mic and the widest listed platform list, including PS5.
The HP Gaming Headset is built around one idea: comfort you can forget about. The protein over-ear pads are designed for air permeability, the headbeam uses multiple points to follow the shape of your head, and the skin-friendly leather is meant to hold up over long stretches of music, gaming and phone calls. At 11.5 ounces it's a light headset, and in my opinion that's its single most useful trait — nothing kills a long session faster than a heavy pair pressing on your ears.
On the audio side, HP lists a dynamic driver, bass surround sound, LED lighting and sound isolation rather than noise cancellation. That distinction matters. The mic is an omni-directional unit with a noise-cancelling feature that's meant to pick up your voice sensitively and cut down background noise, and the long flexible boom lets you angle it where you want it. Volume sits on a wheel on the back of the left ear cup, which is easy to find without looking — a small thing that becomes a big deal mid-match.
Who should buy it: someone who wears a headset for hours, plays across several devices, and wants plug-and-play simplicity with a one-year warranty behind it. Who should skip it: anyone chasing maximum bass or a heavily adjustable mic, and anyone who wants a big, dramatic audio upgrade over a basic headset.
BENGOO G9900: Who It's For
The BENGOO G9900 leans harder into gaming atmosphere and low-end punch. The headline spec is the 50mm magnetic neodymium driver, which BENGOO pairs with a surrounding stereo subwoofer design for strong bass and a claimed 3D immersive feel. If your games live and die on footsteps, explosions and engine rumble, a larger driver is the kind of thing that shows up in everyday play — not a subtle difference.
The mic is the other standout. It's a 720° flexible boom with a noise reduction chip, so you can bend it to almost any angle and it's designed to cut environmental noise and keep your voice clear in real time. If you've ever fought with a stiff mic that only sits one way, the flexibility here is genuinely useful. Controls are on-ear too: volume up and down plus a one-key mute, which is faster to reach in a panic than a menu.
Comfort is handled with protein over-ear pads, soft leatherette cups and an adjustable headband that BENGOO says suits a range of head shapes. The honest trade-off is weight — 428 g is on the heavier side, so if you're sensitive to pressure over multi-hour sessions, that's the number to think about. The 6-foot cable is also worth noting: it gives you real slack to the controller or PC, which is more generous than a short cable would be.
Platform support is the widest here: PS4, PS5, New Xbox One, PC, Nintendo Switch, DS and 3DS, PSP, laptop, tablet, iPad, computer, mobile phone, Super Nintendo, Sega Game Gear and Game Boy Advance. The same Xbox One caveat applies — an old-version controller needs an extra Microsoft Adapter that isn't included. The USB plug drives the LED lighting, which BENGOO describes as red in the product title and elsewhere as white LED lights, so treat the lighting as an ambient extra rather than a fixed color guarantee.
Who should buy it: bass lovers, PS5 owners, players who want a bendable mic and instant mute, and anyone who values a long cable. Who should skip it: buyers who prioritize a featherweight fit, and anyone who wants lighting without an extra USB connection.
• Best for all-day comfort → hp Gaming Headset. At 11.5 ounces with breathable protein pads and a multi-point headbeam, it's the lighter, easier wear.
• Best for bass and immersion → BENGOO G9900. The 50mm neodymium driver and subwoofer tuning are the audio advantage.
• Best for mic flexibility → BENGOO G9900. A 720° boom with a noise reduction chip beats a standard flexible mic on adjustability.
• Best for quick controls → BENGOO G9900. On-ear volume plus one-key mute is faster than a volume wheel alone.
• Best for PS5 owners → BENGOO G9900. PS5 is explicitly listed; the HP sheet stops at PS4.
• Best for retro and handheld consoles → BENGOO G9900. Super Nintendo, Sega Game Gear, Game Boy Advance, DS and 3DS are all named.
• Best for plug-and-play simplicity → hp Gaming Headset. 3.5mm for audio and mic, USB only for lights, with a one-year warranty.
• Best for lightweight travel and mixed use → hp Gaming Headset. Music, calls and gaming on one light pair across tablet, phone and laptop.
If I were buying one of these for myself, I'd take the BENGOO G9900. The 50mm driver, the 720° noise-cancelling mic, on-ear mute and the wider platform list — PS5 included — cover more of what most gamers actually do with a headset, and the 6-foot cable is a real convenience. The HP is the smarter pick if weight and long-session comfort come first, and I'd happily recommend it to anyone who games in marathon stretches or wants the simplest possible setup. Weigh your priority honestly: bass and features versus lightness and simplicity. Either way, check the current price on Amazon before deciding, since that's the one variable this comparison deliberately leaves out.
Not universally. In my opinion the G9900 wins on bass, mic flexibility and platform coverage, while the HP wins on weight and comfort. "Better" depends on whether you value low-end punch or a lighter fit.
The HP data sheet lists PlayStation 4, not PS5. The BENGOO G9900 explicitly lists both PS4 and PS5, so if you own a PS5 and want a confirmed match, the G9900 is the safer choice.
Yes — both sheets state that an old-version Xbox One controller requires an extra Microsoft Adapter, which is not included. New Xbox One controllers work through the standard 3.5mm connection.
The HP uses an omni-directional mic with noise-cancelling and a long flexible boom. The BENGOO G9900 uses a 720° flexible mic with a dedicated noise reduction chip. Both are designed to cut background noise; the G9900 offers more adjustability.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.