How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-10-02 · 6 min read · Independent comparison
If you want a more premium-feeling pair with a metal charging case, a newer Bluetooth version and active noise cancellation, choose hometrannel Earbuds; if you need a lightweight, low-profile earbud with a distinctive semi-transparent case and official water-resistance, choose STUPIDYIN Earbuds.
• hometrannel Earbuds biggest trade-off: the enclosure is still plastic, and the earbuds are a touch heavier at 4g per bud — you're paying for the case and drivers, not a featherweight feel.
• STUPIDYIN Earbuds biggest strength: an official IP54 water-resistance rating and a genuinely tiny 0.12oz build, wrapped in a semi-transparent case that looks different from everything else on a desk.
• STUPIDYIN Earbuds biggest trade-off: older Bluetooth 5.3 and smaller 8mm drivers, with passive noise isolation instead of active cancellation — it blocks sound by sealing your ear, not by processing it.
• Who each pick is for: hometrannel for buyers who want the better spec sheet and a case that survives a backpack; STUPIDYIN for buyers who want the lightest, most discreet bud with real sweat protection.
The hometrannel Earbuds (model LYEJ-01, sold as the MAX60) are built around a few decisions that matter more than the marketing language. The first is the case: it's metal, not plastic, which changes how the whole package feels in your hand and how well it survives being tossed into a bag, a gym pouch or a coat pocket. The second is Bluetooth 5.4 — the newest version in this comparison — which is the spec you want if you've been burned by earbuds that stutter when you walk from one room to another or leave your phone in a locker.
The audio hardware is the real differentiator. hometrannel uses a 14.2mm dynamic driver covering 20Hz to 20,000Hz, and that large-diameter driver is the reason the brand can credibly talk about bass extension alongside a natural mid-range. Smaller drivers can sound clean, but they rarely move as much air down low. On top of that, this pair includes active noise cancellation and a voice-detection accelerometer, which is a fairly specific piece of hardware aimed at call clarity — it's designed to pick up when you're speaking so your voice comes through over background noise. Two microphones back that up.
Who should buy it: anyone who takes calls in noisy places, wants the newer Bluetooth standard, and cares about a case that doesn't feel disposable. The 30-hour total playtime with the case covers a work week of commutes without drama, and the 4g-per-bud weight is light enough for a full day. Dual Connect means you can run either bud solo, which is handy if you like keeping one ear open.
Who should skip it: if you want the absolute lightest possible bud, or you specifically need a stated water-resistance rating, this isn't the pick. The sheet lists active noise cancellation but no IP rating, so I'd treat it as a daily-use and light-workout set rather than something to wear through heavy sweat sessions. The 7-day return window is also shorter than the year of coverage the other brand offers.
STUPIDYIN's TP10 goes the opposite direction on almost every choice, and that's what makes it interesting. The case is semi-transparent white with a matte finish — you can faintly see the earbuds sitting inside, which gives it a tech-forward look without any lights or gimmicks. In white, it reads clean and minimal rather than flashy.
The buds themselves are the headline. At 0.12oz, they're extremely light, and the "bean-style" ergonomic shape is designed to sit flush against your ear rather than poke out. If you've ever had an earbud catch on a hood, a helmet strap or a pillow, that flush fit is the whole point. STUPIDYIN pairs that with an IP54 water-resistance rating, which is the concrete number hometrannel doesn't give you — it covers sweat and light splashes, so gym work and jogging are explicitly in scope.
Sound comes from 8mm dynamic drivers at 32 ohm impedance, spanning the same 20Hz–20,000Hz range. Smaller drivers than hometrannel's, so expect a tighter, punchier presentation rather than deep sub-bass, and STUPIDYIN leans into that with its own "punchy bass, clear treble" framing. Noise control here is passive: the in-ear seal does the blocking, not a processor. Bluetooth is 5.3, one generation behind, but it still supports instant pairing, and the case charges over USB-C. Battery follows the same 6-hours-per-charge, 30-hours-total structure as hometrannel.
Who should buy it: runners, gym-goers and anyone who wants buds that disappear in the ear. The IP54 rating plus the featherweight build is a genuinely coherent combination for movement. The 1-year manufacturer warranty is the better coverage of the two.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for call clarity in noisy places → hometrannel Earbuds. Two mics plus a voice-detection accelerometer and active noise cancellation is a call-focused hardware stack.
• Best for workouts and sweat → STUPIDYIN Earbuds. IP54 is the only stated water-resistance rating in this comparison.
• Best for a premium-feeling case → hometrannel Earbuds. Metal instead of plastic, and it's the more pocketable of the two case designs to hand around.
• Best for the lightest, most discreet fit → STUPIDYIN Earbuds. 0.12oz per bud with a flush, bean-style shape.
• Best for the newest wireless standard → hometrannel Earbuds. Bluetooth 5.4 versus 5.3.
• Best for bass depth and driver size → hometrannel Earbuds. 14.2mm dynamic drivers versus 8mm.
• Best for warranty coverage → STUPIDYIN Earbuds. A 1-year manufacturer warranty beats a 7-day return window.
• Best for a distinctive look → STUPIDYIN Earbuds. The semi-transparent white case is the more unusual design choice.
In my opinion, the hometrannel Earbuds are the better buy for most people. Bluetooth 5.4, the 14.2mm drivers, active noise cancellation and the two-mic setup with voice detection add up to a more capable everyday pair, and the metal case makes the whole thing feel like it will last. I'd pick STUPIDYIN only if your priority is specifically lightness and sweat resistance — the IP54 rating and 0.12oz build are real advantages for running and gym work that hometrannel simply doesn't match on paper. Check the current price on Amazon before you decide, since that's the one variable that could flip this either way.
FAQ
Not active noise cancelling. STUPIDYIN uses passive noise cancellation, meaning the in-ear seal physically blocks ambient sound. hometrannel lists active noise cancellation, which uses electronics to reduce background noise instead.
They have a lightweight 4g-per-bud design and a secure in-ear fit aimed at movement, but the spec sheet doesn't list a water-resistance rating. STUPIDYIN's IP54 rating makes it the safer choice if you sweat heavily.
hometrannel uses Bluetooth 5.4, while STUPIDYIN uses Bluetooth 5.3. Both support quick pairing and a stable wireless connection; 5.4 is simply the newer standard.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: XPIX Pro DJ Headphones vs Btuty IEM System 2.4GHz, Golvery Kids vs Generic Dual Fold Earbuds, WC PadZ Crusher Evo vs FENNIDICE Earbuds Pro 3, Sony WH-CH520 vs NUROUM OpenEar Pro