How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-25 · 7 min read · Independent comparison
• HEISENLIN's biggest strength: a food-grade 304 stainless steel crisper plate with a non-stick coating, a built-in handle, rubber bumpers and dishwasher-safe cleanup — a direct replacement for a worn or missing tray.
• HEISENLIN's biggest trade-off: it's sized for most 5QT round baskets (8.74 in with bumpers, 8.54 in without), so you must measure your inner basket diameter first or it won't fit.
• TZARROT's biggest strength: over 200 food entries across five categories with cooking times, temperatures and food sizes, printed large on oil-, water- and tear-resistant plastic paper with a magnetic backing.
• TZARROT's biggest trade-off: it's a reference chart, not a part — it fixes guesswork, not a broken tray, and the soft magnet isn't heat-proof, so it can't live next to a hot appliance.
• Who each pick is for: HEISENLIN is for anyone whose 5QT air fryer basket needs a new crisper plate; TZARROT is for anyone who owns a working air fryer but keeps burning or undercooking food.
The HEISENLIN replacement tray is a round crisper plate measuring 8.74 inches across with the rubber bumpers on, or 8.54 inches without them. It's built from food-grade 304 stainless steel, meets FDA standards, and contains no BPA. In my opinion, that material choice matters more than most people realize — a crisper plate sits directly under your food, gets hot, and gets scraped every single time you cook. Stainless steel with a non-stick coating is a sensible combination: the steel holds up, and the coating keeps food from welding itself to the surface.
The design details are aimed at daily use. There's a handle, which sounds minor until you've tried to lift a hot plate out of a basket with tongs. It's dishwasher safe, and HEISENLIN even includes a non-stick cleaning cloth and four replacement rubber feet in the box. The rubber bumpers are the part I'd pay attention to: they lift the plate slightly off the basket floor so air can circulate underneath, which is the whole point of a crisper plate in the first place.
Who should skip it? Anyone with a different capacity or a non-round basket. The listing is explicit: measure your basket's inner diameter before ordering. If your air fryer is a 6QT, an oval, or a dual-basket model, this plate is probably not going to seat properly. Also skip it if you want a full accessory kit — this is one plate plus small extras, not a bundle. And one caution worth repeating: don't scrub it with abrasive pads or metal balls, and don't clean it while it's still hot.
TZARROT Air Fryer Magnetic: Who It's For
The TZARROT magnetic cheat sheet solves a completely different problem. It's a flip chart with over 200 food entries covering poultry and seafood, bakery and desserts and snacks, lamb and pork and beef, legumes and vegetables, and a frozen section. Each entry gives cooking time, temperature and food size. It measures 7.8 by 7 inches and weighs just 4.3 ounces, so it's light enough to stick on a fridge door and forget about until you need it.
The practical appeal here is ending the trial-and-error phase of air frying. If you've ever stood over a basket wondering whether frozen wings need 18 minutes or 24, a chart that's classified and labeled with readable font is genuinely useful. The pages are made of sturdy plastic paper that resists oil, water and tears, and the glossy finish wipes clean — which matters in a kitchen where a paper chart would be ruined within a week.
This is for you if your air fryer works fine but your results are inconsistent, or if you're new to air frying and don't yet have a feel for times and temps. It's also a reasonable gift alongside a new air fryer — the shrink-wrapped box presentation supports that, and the brand positions it for housewarming or wedding gifting. The magnetic backing plus the option to hang it means it can live wherever you actually cook, not buried in a drawer.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for a broken or worn tray → HEISENLIN Air Fryer Replacement. It's a functional part, not an accessory.
• Best for ending guesswork → TZARROT Air Fryer Magnetic. Over 200 entries with time, temp and food size.
• Best for easy cleanup → HEISENLIN. Dishwasher safe with a non-stick coating and a cleaning cloth included.
• Best for kitchen durability → TZARROT. Oil-, water- and tear-resistant plastic paper that wipes clean.
• Best for gifting → TZARROT. Shrink-wrapped box packaging designed to pair with a new air fryer.
• Best if you're unsure about fit → neither, until you measure. HEISENLIN needs a basket near 8.74 inches inner diameter; TZARROT needs no fit at all but needs counter or fridge space.
• Best for stainless steel construction → HEISENLIN. Food-grade 304 steel, FDA-compliant and BPA-free.
• Best for covering many food types → TZARROT. Five labeled categories from frozen snacks to poultry and seafood.
• Best for a spare-part owner → HEISENLIN. A second plate means no mid-cook washing bottleneck.
In my opinion these two aren't really an either/or — they fix different problems, and plenty of people would benefit from both. But if you're forcing a single choice, I'd buy the HEISENLIN Air Fryer Replacement. A working crisper plate is the difference between an air fryer you can use tonight and one that sits unused because the tray is scratched or missing. The TZARROT chart is genuinely helpful, but it's a nice-to-have layered on top of a functioning appliance. Buy the part first, then the chart. Either way, check the current price on Amazon before you commit — and measure your basket if you're going with HEISENLIN.
FAQ
what is the best air fryer consumer reports
I can't speak to third-party testing programs, and I'd be cautious about any single "best" claim. What I can say is that the best air fryer for you is the one that fits your basket size and cooking habits. If your current 5QT unit works, the HEISENLIN replacement plate keeps it running; if you're still learning times and temps, the TZARROT chart helps you get consistent results from whatever you own.
Availability and model lineups differ by region, so a chart or plate that fits a US-market 5QT GowiseUSA or PowerXL may not match what's sold in New Zealand. The TZARROT magnetic chart is region-agnostic — it's just times and temperatures. The HEISENLIN plate is not: it fits most 5QT round baskets, so measure your inner basket diameter before ordering regardless of where you bought your air fryer.
which is the best air fryer consumer reports
Again, I'd reframe the question. These two products don't compete as air fryers — one is a stainless steel crisper plate for 5QT round baskets, the other is a 7.8-inch magnetic cooking guide with 200+ food entries. Pick HEISENLIN if you need a replacement part; pick TZARROT if you need cooking references. If you need an actual appliance, neither is the answer.
Not strictly, but they complement each other well. The HEISENLIN plate restores or upgrades your cooking surface with its non-stick, dishwasher-safe design. The TZARROT chart tells you what time and temperature to use for over 200 foods. One improves the hardware, the other improves the decisions you make with it. If you're starting fresh with a used 5QT air fryer, buying both makes practical sense.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: HEISENLIN Air Fryer Replacement vs KunoNana Air Fryer Grill, GZHCJJ Air fryer Replacement vs Kispog Magnetic Air Fryer, HEISENLIN Air Fryer Replacement vs sjeygfr Air Fryer Safety