We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-18 · 6 min read · Independent comparison
If you want a versatile, moldable plug you can shape to your own ear and use in the water, choose GyOnyx 6; if you need adjustable, mode-switching noise control with four tip sizes in the box, choose Clicar Ear Plugs.
• GyOnyx 6 biggest strength: Six pairs of moldable silicone plugs in six colors, each with its own case — a shape-it-yourself fit and fully waterproof design that covers sleep, swimming, travel and concerts.
• GyOnyx 6 biggest trade-off: Every plug starts at one size, so you have to pinch off excess silicone to tune the fit yourself, and there are no selectable noise modes.
• Clicar Ear Plugs biggest strength: A dial-based Switch with three modes (Quiet, Engage, Experience) plus four pairs of ear tips in XS, S, M and L, so you can match both the fit and the level of isolation to the situation.
• Clicar Ear Plugs biggest trade-off: It's a single black set with one carrying case, and the design is explicitly about reducing noise rather than blocking it completely — loud environments still come through.
• Who each pick is for: GyOnyx 6 suits swimmers, side sleepers and anyone who wants a stash of plugs for the whole household; Clicar suits people who want one precise pair they can retune as their day changes.
GyOnyx 6 is built around one idea: a soft silicone plug that you mold to your own ear instead of pushing a pre-shaped tip into your canal. That matters if you've ever had foam plugs feel scratchy or too deep after an hour. You pinch the silicone, press it into place, and it holds a pressure-free seal. If it feels like too much material, you pinch off the excess — a nice bit of forgiveness that fixed-size tips can't offer.
The second thing that stands out is the waterproof build. These are made to handle swimming, showering, surfing and bathing, and the same plug doubles as noise reduction for sleep, flights, study and concerts. That range is genuinely wide, and it's the reason I'd point a swimmer here first. Silicone that shrugs off water is a different animal from a plug you'd only trust on a nightstand.
The set itself is the third selling point. Six pairs, six colors — blue, transparent, rose, black, red and green — each in its own compact case. That's a practical setup for a household: one color for you, one for a partner, spares for the gym bag and the travel kit. Washable, reusable and gentle on sensitive skin, they're positioned as a durable swap for disposables. The real trade-off is that each plug is the same size out of the box, and there's no mode switch — you get one consistent level of reduction, shaped by how you mold it. If you want to dial isolation up or down without re-seating the plug, this isn't that product.
Clicar Ear Plugs take the opposite approach: instead of molding, they adjust. The core of the design is a Switch with an in-ear dial that flips between three modes — Quiet, Engage and Experience. Quiet is the one you'd wear to bed or on a plane. Engage is for situations where you still want to hold a conversation. Experience is tuned for live events, where you want the music clearer rather than muffled. That's a genuinely useful idea, because most people don't need the same amount of reduction at 3 a.m. as they do at a sound check.
Fit is handled by four pairs of ultra-soft silicone tips in XS, S, M and L, described as single-layer and aimed at children, the elderly, men and women alike. So rather than trimming material, you swap tips until the seal feels right — a more precise, repeatable method for anyone who's bounced between sizes. The ergonomic shape is meant to sit in the canal properly, which is where most of the comfort comes from in an in-ear design.
On performance, the stated figures are worth reading carefully. The plugs reduce noise above roughly 60 dB down to within about 30 dB — described as a level well suited to sleep — and the spec range runs 20–26 dB of flexible noise reduction, with the description citing noise as low as 28 dB. The manufacturer is explicit that this is not complete isolation, and I appreciate the honesty: these lower loud environments, they don't erase them. The rest of the package is tidy — a compact case with an integrated lanyard, a sleek black look, washable silicone, and a reusable build pitched as a sustainable swap for disposables. One set, one case, four tip pairs, three modes.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for swimming and showering → GyOnyx 6. The moldable silicone is explicitly built for water; Clicar lists swimming as a use case but leads with sleep and concert noise control.
• Best for a guaranteed fit without trimming → Clicar Ear Plugs. XS, S, M and L tips let you swap rather than reshape.
• Best for an unusual ear shape → GyOnyx 6. Moldable silicone plus the option to pinch off excess is more forgiving than any fixed tip.
• Best for sharing across a household → GyOnyx 6. Six pairs in six colors with six cases is a set, not a single pair.
• Best for conversation while wearing plugs → Clicar Ear Plugs. Engage Mode exists precisely for that; GyOnyx 6 has no equivalent.
• Best for concerts you actually want to hear clearly → Clicar Ear Plugs. Experience Mode is aimed at live sound, where GyOnyx 6 simply reduces everything.
• Best for pure simplicity → GyOnyx 6. No dial, no modes, no tip swapping — mold it, wear it, wash it.
If I were buying for myself, I'd pick Clicar Ear Plugs. In my opinion the three-mode Switch and the four tip sizes make it the more adaptable product for everyday life — sleep one hour, conversation the next, a loud room after that — and the manufacturer's own note about partial rather than total isolation sets realistic expectations. I'd steer toward GyOnyx 6 if water and fit are your priorities: swimming, showering, odd ear shapes, and a multi-pair set for the whole household. Both are reusable silicone, so the honest tiebreaker is how you'll actually use them.
I don't quote prices here, since they change. Both are reusable silicone sets rather than disposables, so the running cost depends on how long you keep them — check the current price on Amazon for each before deciding.
Clicar lists side sleepers directly and uses soft in-ear tips in four sizes, which helps when you're pressed against a pillow. GyOnyx 6 sits outside the canal rather than deep inside it, which many side sleepers find comfortable too — it's a fit question, not a clear winner.
No, and the manufacturer says so plainly. They reduce noise above about 60 dB to within roughly 30 dB, with a stated 20–26 dB range, so loud environments get quieter rather than silent. GyOnyx 6 works the same way — reduction, not elimination.
GyOnyx 6 is the safer bet. Its silicone is described as fully waterproof and rated for swimming, showering, surfing and bathing. Clicar mentions swimming among its uses but is primarily designed around sleep, snoring and concert noise.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.