How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-24 · 6 min read · Independent comparison
• GXF Air Fryer Replacement — biggest strength: A single food-grade stainless steel tray sized 14.5" x 11.6" x 0.8", rated to 480°F, dishwasher safe, and bundled with four reusable fiberglass baking mats.
• GXF Air Fryer Replacement — biggest trade-off: It is one tray only, it's shaped for specific ovens (Cuisinart TOA-95 directly, Black & Decker Extra-Wide 8-slice on the original rack), and it needs a one-time 300°F preheat for about 10 minutes before first use to help it stay flat.
• CURTA 8 — biggest strength: A 30-pack of heavy-duty round aluminum foil pans, 8" diameter by 1.8" deep, each with a clear lid — ideal for volume baking, meal prep, takeout and storage.
• CURTA 8 — biggest trade-off: They are foil pans, so they're meant to bend, dent and eventually be thrown away — better for one-off jobs and giving food away than for a permanent spot in your kitchen.
• Who GXF is for: Home cooks with a compatible toaster oven air fryer who want one sturdy, reusable pan and mats they'll use over and over.
• Who CURTA is for: Bakers, hosts, caterers and anyone portioning or transporting food in quantity.
This is a replacement tray, and that word matters. It's built to slot into the Cuisinart TOA-95 as a direct-use pan, and it also works in Black & Decker Extra-Wide 8-slice toaster ovens when placed on the oven's original wire rack. If you own one of those, you already know the pain of a flimsy pan that buckles under a sheet-pan dinner. The GXF is the opposite of that — food-grade stainless steel, 0.8" tall, with a solid flat surface that spreads heat evenly across cookies, roasted vegetables, garlic bread and full sheet-pan meals.
The extras are where it earns its keep. Four reusable fiberglass baking mats come in the box, and they're naturally non-stick and heat resistant, which means cookies and pastries lift clean off and cleanup is a rinse rather than a scrub. The tray itself is dishwasher safe, and stuck-on food releases after a short soak. It's rated to 480°F, so it handles normal roasting and baking without drama.
CURTA 8: Who It's For
CURTA 8 is a completely different animal — a 30-pack of round aluminum foil pans, each 8" across and 1.8" deep, with a clear lid for every one. The aluminum is described as extra heavy-duty, built to handle both home and commercial use without bending or breaking, and the lids snap on securely so you can see exactly what's inside without opening anything. That combination is why these turn up in catering, takeout and meal-prep kitchens.
Think about what you actually do with them: bake a round cake, roast a small batch of meat, portion a week of lunches, send guests home with dessert, stack leftovers in the fridge. Then either wash and reuse one or toss it — your call. The aluminum is recyclable, so the disposal route isn't a wasteful one, and there's no scrubbing guilt if you'd rather not deal with it.
Buy CURTA 8 if you cook, bake or serve in volume and you want pans that are ready to go, stack neatly and travel with lids on. Skip it if you want one permanent pan you'll use for years, or if you're specifically trying to fit a tray into a Cuisinart TOA-95 — this isn't that product. Foil pans flex, dent and crease; that's the trade-off you accept for 30 of them and no cleanup obligation.
• Best for a Cuisinart TOA-95 or Black & Decker Extra-Wide 8-slice oven → GXF Air Fryer Replacement. It's designed to fit those ovens, either directly or on the original rack.
• Best for high-volume baking, catering or takeout → CURTA 8. Thirty lidded pans means you're never short a container when you're feeding a crowd.
• Best for everyday reusable cooking → GXF Air Fryer Replacement. Stainless steel rated to 480°F, dishwasher safe, plus four non-stick fiberglass mats you'll use constantly.
• Best for storing and transporting food → CURTA 8. The clear lids let you see contents and keep things fresh and protected in the fridge or on the road.
• Best for cookies, roasted veggies and sheet-pan dinners → GXF Air Fryer Replacement. The flat, solid surface is made for even heat across a wide area.
• Best for round cakes and single portions → CURTA 8. The 8" round shape and 1.8" depth are sized for a cake layer or an individual meal.
• Best for durability over many years → GXF Air Fryer Replacement. Properly cared for, stainless steel holds its shape far longer than foil.
• Best for zero cleanup effort → CURTA 8. Use it, then recycle or dispose of it — no soaking, no dishwasher space used.
In my opinion, most people reading this should buy the GXF Air Fryer Replacement — but only if they own a compatible oven. If you do, you're getting one pan and four mats that will outlast any foil tray by a wide margin, and the 480°F rating and dishwasher-safe stainless steel cover the majority of home baking and roasting. I'd pick it for anyone who cooks regularly and hates replacing warped pans.
That said, I'd recommend CURTA 8 without hesitation for bakers, hosts and anyone running a food business. Thirty lidded round pans you can bake in, store in and give away is a genuinely different job, and foil does it better than steel ever could. Check the current price on Amazon for either one before you commit — the button on this page will show you where things stand today.
FAQ
what is an air fryer baking pan
An air fryer baking pan is a flat pan sized to sit inside an air fryer or toaster-oven-style air fryer so you can bake and roast without food falling through the rack. The GXF tray is exactly this: 14.5" x 11.6" x 0.8" of food-grade stainless steel, designed for the Cuisinart TOA-95 and, on the original rack, Black & Decker Extra-Wide 8-slice ovens.
An air fryer cake pan is a smaller, deeper pan used for baking cakes and single portions in an air fryer. CURTA 8 fits that description well — an 8" round aluminum pan, 1.8" deep, sold in a 30-pack with clear lids, so you can bake a round cake and then store or transport it in the same pan.
what is an air fryer safe baking pan
An air fryer safe baking pan is one rated to handle the temperatures your appliance reaches. The GXF tray is rated up to 480°F and is made of food-grade, BPA-free stainless steel; CURTA 8's aluminum pans are described as suitable for broiling, baking, roasting and air fryer use.
are air fryer pans oven safe
Generally yes, provided the pan's temperature rating covers your oven setting. The GXF pan handles up to 480°F, so it works in a standard oven as well as a compatible air fryer oven; just remember the one-time preheat of about 10 minutes at 300°F before first use to help it stay flat.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: GXF Air Fryer Cooking vs GCQFZ Toaster Oven Replacement, rhsaae 3PCS vs GXF Air Fryer Toaster, SettleDown Replacement Air Fryer vs LYHOLKEER Silicone Air Fryer