How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
If you want a solid stainless steel pan that can serve as a real baking surface and even replace a worn-out oven tray, choose GWY Air Fryer Replacement; if you need a stack of lightweight non-stick liners to keep your existing air fryer basket clean with almost zero effort, choose KAWENDE Air Fryer Liners.
• GWY Air Fryer Replacement — biggest strength: a food-grade stainless steel tray (14.5" x 11.6" x 0.8") with a flat, solid surface that handles up to 480°F and goes in the dishwasher. It's a pan, not a liner.
• GWY Air Fryer Replacement — biggest trade-off: it's a single rigid tray, so you get one piece per purchase, and it needs a one-time 300°F / 10-minute preheat before first use to help it stay flat.
• KAWENDE Air Fryer Liners — biggest strength: you get 5 reusable 13" x 9" Teflon sheets that withstand up to 500°F, cut the mess in your existing pan, and work in ovens, microwaves and steamers too.
• KAWENDE Air Fryer Liners — biggest trade-off: they're flexible liners, not cookware — they protect and release food, but they don't give you a rigid baking surface or stand in for a missing tray.
• Pick GWY if you want a durable, oven-safe pan for roasting, baking and sheet-pan meals. Pick KAWENDE if you want fast cleanup on top of the cookware you already own.
This is a genuine piece of cookware. The GWY tray is a 14.5" x 11.6" x 0.8" stainless steel pan with a flat, solid surface, and it's built to be used directly in a Cuisinart TOA-95. If you own a Breville BOV900BSS or a Black & Decker Extra-Wide 8-slice toaster oven, it sits on top of the original wire rack rather than clipping in — a simple, stable setup that keeps the tray level.
What it does best is the stuff liners can't do: roasting vegetables, baking cookies, sheet-pan dinners, anything where you want even heat under solid food and a surface you can slide a spatula across. The steel is food-grade, BPA-free and odor-free, and it's rated to 480°F, so it keeps up with normal oven and air-fry-roast temperatures. Cleanup is dishwasher-friendly, with a short soak for anything stubborn, and a soft sponge keeps the finish looking right.
There's one quirk worth knowing before you buy: GWY recommends a one-time preheat — 10 minutes at 300°F — before first use so the steel settles and stays flat. Do that once and you're set.
KAWENDE Air Fryer Liners: Who It's For
The KAWENDE set is the opposite philosophy: five reusable 13" x 9" rectangular Teflon sheets, black, thin and flexible. You drop one into your air fryer pan or basket, cook, then wash it by hand or in the dishwasher and use it again. That's the whole idea, and it's a good one if the thing you hate most is scrubbing grease and baked-on residue off a grill plate.
The liners are designed for the Breville Smart Oven Air Fryer Pro BOV900BSS and Cuisinart air fryer toaster oven combos, and the material is a food-grade fiberglass-and-Teflon construction rated to 500°F — a touch higher than the GWY tray. They're also genuinely non-stick and grease-proof, which means food releases cleanly and less fat ends up baked onto your pan. That's not just convenience; keeping the basket cleaner over time is a small way to protect the appliance you already paid for.
The versatility is the underrated part. KAWENDE says these work in ovens, microwaves and steamers too, so a five-pack can cover more than one appliance in the same kitchen. Five pieces also means you can rotate: one in use, one drying, one in the drawer.
Who should skip them? If your tray is missing, warped or you're tired of flimsy cookware, a liner won't fix that — it needs something solid underneath. And if you want to bake cookies or roast a tray of vegetables with real structure, silicone-thin sheets aren't a substitute for a steel pan. They're a mess-management tool, not a cooking surface.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for replacing a worn or missing tray → GWY Air Fryer Replacement. It's a real 14.5" x 11.6" stainless pan, not a liner.
• Best for fast cleanup → KAWENDE Air Fryer Liners. Five sheets you can rinse, wash or stack, so grease never touches the grill plate.
• Best for protecting the appliance you already own → KAWENDE Air Fryer Liners. Non-stick, grease-proof sheets keep food residue off the basket.
• Best for higher heat ceiling → KAWENDE Air Fryer Liners, rated to 500°F versus the GWY tray's 480°F. Both are plenty for normal air-fry cooking.
• Best for multi-appliance kitchens → KAWENDE Air Fryer Liners, since they're also listed for ovens, microwaves and steamers.
• Best for durability and a permanent kitchen tool → GWY Air Fryer Replacement, built from stainless steel with a dishwasher-safe finish.
• Best for owning spares → KAWENDE Air Fryer Liners. You get 5 pieces in one set; GWY is a single tray.
In my opinion, these two aren't really competitors — they solve different problems, so the honest answer is that many people would want both. If I had to pick one, I'd buy the GWY Air Fryer Replacement for a Cuisinart TOA-95, Breville BOV900BSS or Black & Decker Extra-Wide oven, because a stainless tray rated to 480°F that's dishwasher safe and works as an actual baking pan gives you more capability for the money — you can roast, bake and serve off it, and it can stand in for a tray you've lost.
The KAWENDE liners are the smarter buy if your cookware is fine and your only real complaint is the cleanup. Five reusable, non-stick sheets rated to 500°F that also work in the microwave and steamer are a low-effort way to keep a good air fryer clean. That's a genuinely useful accessory — just not a replacement for a pan.
If you're still weighing it up, check the current price on Amazon for each and let the fit with your oven decide.
FAQ
Yes, with a caveat. GWY says the tray is used directly in the Cuisinart TOA-95, and for the Breville BOV900BSS or Black & Decker Extra-Wide 8-slice ovens it sits on top of the original wire rack. Check your oven's internal dimensions against 14.5" x 11.6" before ordering.
Reusable. The KAWENDE set is 5 Teflon sheets you wash by hand or in the dishwasher and use again, so one set covers regular cooking. The GWY tray is likewise a permanent piece — dishwasher safe, rated to 480°F, and designed to hold its shape with proper care.
It depends on what you're missing. If you need a durable pan that can handle roasting and baking, the GWY tray does more per piece. If you already own good cookware and just want easier cleanup, the KAWENDE five-pack spreads the benefit across several appliances.
Only for the GWY tray: preheat it in a 300°F oven for 10 minutes once, which lets the steel settle and helps prevent warping. The KAWENDE liners are ready to use straight out of the pack.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: GWY Air Fryer Replacement vs jojofuny 1pc: Air Fryer Double, GZHCJJ Air fryer Replacement vs Tastee Air Fryer Liners, GWY Air Fryer Replacement vs ELEOUTI Square Grill Rack