How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-22 · 7 min read · Independent comparison
• GWBSXM Air Fryer Grill — biggest strength: a 6.1" round stainless-steel grill plate with a PTFE non-stick coating, a lift-out handle, and three rubber bumpers included, sized specifically for Chefman 2 QT, Dash, Power XL 2 QT and Bella 1.6 QT fryers.
• GWBSXM Air Fryer Grill — biggest trade-off: at 6.1 inches it only fits those small baskets, and the brand explicitly warns it is not suitable for other models.
• ALFYRCFT Air Fryer Replacement — biggest strength: a large 9.4 x 8.9 x 4.5 inch non-stick metal basket built to replace the whole cooking basket in Power Air Fryer XL 5.3qt, 5.8qt and Dash Deluxe 6qt machines.
• ALFYRCFT Air Fryer Replacement — biggest trade-off: it only has two holes, fits a narrow list of specific models, and the manufacturer asks you to confirm dimensions before buying.
• Who each is for: GWBSXM is for someone with a compact 2-quart air fryer who wants a grilling/crisping insert; ALFYRCFT is for someone with a big 5.3–6-quart fryer whose original basket is worn out or damaged.
The GWBSXM Air Fryer Grill is a round 6.1 x 6.1 inch plate made from food-grade stainless steel with a black PTFE non-stick coating applied in two sprayed layers. It's designed to sit inside a small air fryer basket and act as a raised cooking surface — a crisper plate in the classic sense. The food-grade steel is described as BPA-free, non-toxic and tasteless, and the brand states it meets FDA standards, which is the kind of claim you want to see on anything that touches your dinner directly.
What makes it genuinely useful is the handle. Anyone who has tried to lift a hot flat plate out of a deep air fryer basket knows the problem — you either burn your fingers or dig around with tongs and flip the food. A built-in handle solves that in one motion, and it's a small design detail that shows the maker thought about real cooking rather than just copying a shape.
The second practical point is cleaning. The non-stick surface is meant to release food without scraping, and the plate is dishwasher safe. The brand also gives sensible care instructions: don't scrub it with abrasive cloths or steel balls, don't wash it while it's still hot, and let it cool before touching it. Those warnings tell you the coating is the part that matters — treat it reasonably and it should hold up.
Who should buy it? Someone with a Chefman 2 QT, a Dash, a Power XL 2 QT or a Bella 1.6 QT air fryer who wants to cook fries, pizza, chicken wings, steak or fried vegetables on a flat, non-stick surface rather than straight in the basket. The package includes one grill plate plus three rubber bumpers, which sit on the underside and keep the plate steady so it doesn't rattle around while the fan runs.
Who should skip it? Anyone with a larger air fryer. This is a 6.1-inch plate and the brand is blunt that it is not suitable for other models. If your basket is wider than that, this simply won't drop in. Also measure before you order — the manufacturer's first warning is literally to check your air fryer's size first. That's the single most common way people get this wrong.
The ALFYRCFT Air Fryer Replacement is a different kind of product entirely. It's not an insert — it's a whole replacement basket, measuring 9.4 x 8.9 x 4.5 inches, made of metal with a black PTFE non-stick coating. If your original basket is scratched, peeling, dented or just worn out after years of daily fries, this is the part that gets your fryer back in service rather than sending the whole appliance to the bin.
The size tells you immediately who it's aimed at: people with big air fryers. The brand lists compatibility with the Power Air Fryer XL 5.3qt, a 5.8qt air fryer, and the Dash Deluxe 6qt. That's a 5.3 to 6-quart class of machine — roughly three times the cooking footprint of the small 2-quart fryers the GWBSXM plate is built for. You can cook a proper batch of chicken wings, a whole pizza, steak, or a full tray of fried vegetables in one go instead of cooking in shifts.
Two things stand out as honest trade-offs. First, the basket has only two holes. That's a deliberate, simpler design, but it means airflow and grease drainage work differently than a basket with a dense perforation pattern — worth knowing if you're used to a specific crispiness result. Second, compatibility is narrow. The brand states plainly that it only fits those specific models and asks you to confirm the size before purchasing, and it notes the accessory is only suitable for specific air fryer models.
Who should buy it? Owners of a Power Air Fryer XL 5.3qt, a 5.8qt model or a Dash Deluxe 6qt whose basket has reached the end of its life. Who should skip it? Anyone with a small 2-quart fryer, and anyone whose model isn't on that list — measure first, because a 9.4-inch basket simply won't fit a compact machine.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for compact 2-quart air fryers → GWBSXM Air Fryer Grill. It's purpose-built for Chefman 2 QT, Dash, Power XL 2 QT and Bella 1.6 QT.
• Best for large 5.3–6-quart air fryers → ALFYRCFT Air Fryer Replacement. It's sized for Power Air Fryer XL 5.3qt, 5.8qt and Dash Deluxe 6qt.
• Best for upgrading a working fryer → GWBSXM Air Fryer Grill. It adds a flat, handled crisping surface without replacing anything.
• Best for rescuing a fryer with a worn basket → ALFYRCFT Air Fryer Replacement. It replaces the basket itself, not just the cooking surface.
• Best for easy, safe handling of hot food → GWBSXM Air Fryer Grill. The handle design means you lift the plate out instead of fishing for it.
• Best for cooking big batches at once → ALFYRCFT Air Fryer Replacement. The 9.4 x 8.9 x 4.5 inch basket holds far more food per round.
• Best for dishwasher convenience → both. Both use a non-stick coating and both are stated as dishwasher safe.
• Best if you're unsure about fit → neither, until you measure. Each brand warns you to confirm your air fryer's dimensions before ordering, and both are model-specific.
If I were buying for a small Chefman, Dash, Power XL 2 QT or Bella 1.6 QT, I'd take the GWBSXM Air Fryer Grill. In my opinion the handle alone justifies it — being able to lift a hot non-stick plate straight out of the basket is the difference between cooking often and avoiding the machine. The included rubber bumpers and dishwasher-safe coating round out a well-thought-out little accessory.
If I had a Power Air Fryer XL 5.3qt, a 5.8qt or a Dash Deluxe 6qt with a tired basket, I'd take the ALFYRCFT Air Fryer Replacement instead — there's no point buying a 6.1-inch insert for a machine that size. These two barely compete; they serve opposite ends of the air fryer market, so the real question is which machine is sitting on your counter.
FAQ
Only if your basket takes a 6.1-inch round plate. The brand lists Chefman 2 QT, Dash, Power XL 2 QT and Bella 1.6 QT, and states it is not suitable for other models. Measure your basket before ordering.
Yes. Both products use a non-stick coating and both are described as dishwasher safe. GWBSXM does advise against abrasive scrubbers and steel wool, and against washing the plate while it's still hot.
That depends entirely on your machine, not on the products themselves. A 6.1-inch insert won't work in a 6-quart fryer, and a 9.4-inch basket won't fit a 2-quart one. Pick based on your air fryer's size, then check the current price on Amazon before you commit.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: JCLMER Cast Iron Grill vs ZuKaYeHome Air Fryer Replacement, GWBSXM Air fryer Replacement vs SANTOUXIANG 3-Pack, GWBSXM 10 vs GXCSY Air fryer Replacement: Air Fryer OR Oven