How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-25 · 6 min read · Independent comparison
If you want a complete, reusable bakeware set that covers cakes, muffins, cookies and sheet-pan bakes in a toaster oven or air fryer basket, choose GoodCook 4-Piece; if you need a constant supply of pre-cut non-stick liners that let you lift a round cake straight out of the pan with almost no cleanup, choose uxcell 100pcs.
• GoodCook 4-Piece — biggest strength: four pieces of heavy-duty steel bakeware in one go — an 8.4" x 6.5" sheet pan, a 7.6" x 5.5" baking rack, an 8.4" x 6.5" cake pan and a 6-cup muffin pan — all with scratch-resistant nonstick and dishwasher-safe construction.
• GoodCook 4-Piece — biggest trade-off: it is a fixed set of hard pans, so you still have to wash them between bakes, and the manufacturer recommends hand-washing for the longest life.
• uxcell 100pcs — biggest strength: 100 pre-cut, 11-inch round parchment sheets coated with food-grade silicone on both sides, non-stick, tear-resistant and rated from -68°F up to 450°F, so you can line a pan and throw the mess away.
• uxcell 100pcs — biggest trade-off: paper is a consumable — it does nothing on its own, and you will run out and have to buy more.
• Who each pick is for: GoodCook 4-Piece is for someone who wants a permanent, do-everything bakeware kit for a small oven; uxcell 100pcs is for someone who bakes round cakes constantly and hates scrubbing pans.
This set is best understood as a starter kit for a small oven. Everything in the box is sized for a toaster oven or a compact air fryer basket rather than a full-size range: the sheet pan and cake pan are both 8.4" x 6.5", the rack is 7.6" x 5.5", and the muffin pan holds six cups. That footprint is the whole point — it lets you bake a thin sheet cake, a batch of six muffins, or a tray of cookies without dragging out a half-sheet pan that won't fit.
Who should buy it: someone setting up a first small-oven baking kit, or replacing a mismatched collection of rusty pans, who wants one box that covers cakes, muffins, cookies and savory sheet-pan dinners. Who should skip it: anyone baking full-size layer cakes or 12-cup muffin batches, since the dimensions here won't fit that job. Also skip it if you specifically want a liner you can throw away — this set gives you pans to wash, not paper to discard.
uxcell 100pcs: Who It's For
These are round parchment liners, 11 inches across, sold 100 to a pack. They're made from wood pulp with a silicone coating on both sides, which is the combination that makes them non-stick, tear-resistant and oil-proof. Because the silicone is on both faces, food releases without extra oil sprayed on the sheet first, and grease doesn't soak through the paper into the pan underneath.
The temperature range is the number that matters most for air fryer and oven work: -68°F to 450°F. That covers baking, grilling, frying and steaming, so the same liner works in a microwave, a conventional oven, a steamer basket and an air fryer. The sheets are pre-cut and round, come with a hole in the surface for steam to pass through, and the packaging keeps them flat so they don't curl up the way a rolled sheet does.
Who should buy it: anyone who bakes round cakes, cheesecakes or springform cakes regularly and wants to lift the finished cake out cleanly, plus air fryer owners who are tired of scraping residue off the basket. Who should skip it: someone who wants actual bakeware — this is a consumable, and 100 sheets is a supply, not a tool. It also won't help with square or loaf-shaped bakes, since these are round.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for a complete bakeware kit → GoodCook 4-Piece. Four steel pieces cover cakes, muffins, cookies and sheet-pan meals in one purchase.
• Best for zero-scrub cleanup → uxcell 100pcs. Line the pan, bake, lift the cake out, bin the paper.
• Best for muffin and cupcake batches → GoodCook 4-Piece. The 6-cup muffin pan is the only piece here built for individual portions; the parchment is round and flat.
• Best for multiple cooking methods → uxcell 100pcs. Oven, microwave, steamer, grill and air fryer are all in range, from -68°F to 450°F.
• Best for a set you keep for years → GoodCook 4-Piece. Heavy-duty steel resists warping, and hand-washing is recommended to extend its life.
• Best if you hate washing dishes → uxcell 100pcs. The whole point is that the liner takes the mess and you throw it away.
• Best if you bake only occasionally → GoodCook 4-Piece. Pans don't expire; a 100-sheet supply can sit for a long time if you rarely bake.
If I were buying for myself and my goal was air fryer cake, I'd buy the uxcell 100pcs. In my opinion, a round, pre-cut, silicone-coated liner rated to 450°F solves the two things that actually go wrong with air fryer cake — sticking and cleanup — and 100 sheets means I'm not rationing them. I'd choose the GoodCook 4-Piece instead if what I really wanted was a permanent baking setup for a small oven, because the steel pans and 6-cup muffin tin do jobs no sheet of paper can. If you already own pans, the liners are the better add; if you own nothing, start with the set and add liners later.
Mix your batter as the box directs, then pour it into a pan that fits your air fryer basket — the GoodCook 4-Piece cake pan at 8.4" x 6.5" is sized for small ovens, or line a round pan with an 11-inch uxcell sheet. Bake at a moderate temperature rather than the oven temperature on the box, and check early, since air fryers circulate heat fast.
How to make air fryer cake?
Pour the batter into a lined or non-stick pan, smooth the top, and bake until a skewer comes out clean. The uxcell liners are rated to 450°F and let the cake slide straight out, which is why I'd reach for them; the GoodCook cake pan's nonstick coating does a similar job if you'd rather bake directly in steel.
They solve different problems. Pans give you structure and portion shapes like the 6-cup muffin tin; paper gives you release and no-scrub cleanup. In my opinion the smartest setup is a small pan plus a stack of round liners — which is why these two products complement each other more than they compete.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: FLANCCI Air Fryer Liners vs JolyWell 100Pcs: Air Fryer Cake, UBeesize XL 10 vs uxcell Air Fryer Cups: Air Fryer Cake, Zayookey 2 vs uxcell 100pcs: Air Fryer Silicone Liner